Interesting comment from Watters at last night's presser. Apparently we have had the least number of top 20 picks of any club over the past decade. It'd funny but I've never thought of it in those terms, but it's certainly a disadvantage when trying to maintain a strong list from on top of the ladd...

No mention of Siposs.. nothing to mention?

He kicks like mule but they float where he wants them to. i like him looks a player. Yes, wouldn't be too confident with the big lad lining up for goal.. Or Stanley for that matter.. Or Riewoldt. What's with our tall's horrendous kicking? Loving Lee's kick - still has the odd silly miss, but I get ...

I'm happy that we're at least having a think about all avenues..

Doesn't mean we'll do it. But I'm glad we're being proactive & feeling things out.

As Scott said; there wouldn't be a club in Australia who wouldn't like Tom Boyd there.

From the sounds of it well done SW. kosi not playing nether he should after Lee doing ok last week. Milney in from the sounds of it. Be prepared those going to the game. Its going to be loud and ugly. I'm tipping a deafening 'boo' like we've never heard before when he kicks one.. Imagine he kicks a...

Anyone ooing & ahhing whether Milne should play this week need to grow a pair. At this point, if anything, the longer we leave him out will only have a detrimental effect on his return reception.. Rip off the bandaid & get him back in the fold. Of course he should play. Should of played last...

I wish I had the skill of conveying my feelings/thoughts as well as i am able to speak them, but here goes nothing. Kosi - no, not this week, not sure he would be a better selection then others as already mentioned. Milne - no. This is a hard one as most would agree. Without a shadow of a doubt he ...

I think get Kosi to his 200 this week then have him announce his retirement effective immediately. Leave Hickey out or rest Ben if he has any sort of niggle. Lee must stay. Mine should come back in for any of the other three smalls. With Kosi's history with injury if you play him in the VFL this we...

I think he may have started thinking that he had "made it". Not a slight on the kid, but we signed him up early, as we should have. Next year should see his head in the game a lot more. He has a lot of talent. Who knows what Arryn's thinking.. as a young player not getting a game, probabl...

In fact, I've completely flip-flopped from the beginning of the season to now believe he's probably the most likely of the 3 to make it.

The difficult part is that both of TDL & Saad kicked 2 goals, which will encourage the coach to keep at least one of them in the side… same goes for Milne, where often he'll have an average game, but still kick his 2. If you got 2 goals out of TDL, Saad & Milne every week, I guess you'd tak...

Who's to say that Dal won't ask to be traded at the years end? Yes he's part of the "fabric" of our club but what if he came in and said "I don't want to execute the clause in my contract" why wouldn't we package him up with pick 22? Gold Coast would lap that deal up I reckon an...

dragit wrote:Cool, stinger has approved discussion… carry on everyone.

lol. Isn't that the point of a forum? Of course we've all got no idea stacked up to the people that do. We like to discuss all things St Kilda..

At the moment that's rebuilding.

Fight on keyboard warriors!

The difficult part is that both of TDL & Saad kicked 2 goals, which will encourage the coach to keep at least one of them in the side… same goes for Milne, where often he'll have an average game, but still kick his 2. If you got 2 goals out of TDL, Saad & Milne every week, I guess you'd tak...

If we trade Dal or Monty, we show that we are kicking out the heart of the Club and what does that say to the younger guys, sponsors and many supporters? They have given a lot and that's what you build Club integrity around. I hope that loyalty still counts for something, despite the "anything...

Are we talking about the same Stanley. The Stanley that has probably played his best season since being drafted and also his best season because of the fact that he's been able to string more games together than he ever has and the fact that he has had to learn a key back position and impressed at ...

Would anyone do this Keep pick 3 - not negotiable. We must use this on a mid. Trade pick 22 plus one of (Gwilt Gilbo or Seany D) for a top 10 pick. Then we have two top 10 picks to use on young gun midfielders. Then we pick up Mitch Brown late in draft or in the pre season draft Don't know if that'...

Lee looks good, but hickey was woeful. Our ruck got smashed again. Stanley is out of form ,looks lost at times. The thing is.. has Stanley ever been IN form? I think a game or two back he looked likely up forward for a patch.. & that's the best I can remember from the guy. God, the thing that s...

Yes it was me who said Milney should retire. i have always supported Milney. i have from day one in this incident. he cops so much flack off guys at our footy club and especially girls who i know but i always say there is 2 sides to the story. that however doesnt change my mind that it will be a pr...

He has never been cleared and i doubt you would know if there is any pressure on the woman to continue this. She may feel she was wronged and wants justice. I for one will continue to support Milney but i dont by much of what you wrote. Plugger wasn't it you that started a 'Milne must retire immedi...

We love him cause he has guts, but he is a good honest battler really. I concur. & he is one of my favourites! Love when he breaks out & has a 30 possession game. or kicks 4. Albeit once or twice a year.. I actually had really high hoped for Armo this year. Every indication he was taking hi...

Love the optimism but need to have a reality check. We need to get some midfield stars. We have a Lyon legacy of mainly GOPs. The rebuild started last year and I am confident that Pelchen will be a big draft player over the next two years emphasising ball skills in a "Hawthorn" type rebui...

That's a good post mate, totally understand... I love what milney has done for the club, but I am looking forward to this whole saga being behind the club. Looking forward to going to the football without having hearing 20,000+ rabid morons screaming "you're a farking rapist c***" I'm ove...

What's the best thing for the club? Sponsorship considerations etc? Not just what Milney wants to do. As sn aside, I personally think Milnes career is finished anyway, he's had one good game in 10 so far this year, will the circus that goes with him playing out the season be worth it? You guys obvi...

What is this obsession that older players >26 are past it? And obsession with filling the boots with kids? It's never worked without seniority... Think It's just the general view of the AFL fan majority who don't actually know a whole lot. A lot less than they'd like to think anyway. So they take t...