I'd back a fit Hickey & Longa in any day. Remains to be seen if either can rest forward and be dangerous. Same can be said for Stanley. exactly Stanley was for most games dead wood in the forward line and an average at best ruck ... with Longer we have an average ruck who is dead wood in the fo...

Well based on that comment lets trade every single player over 26 years of age or retire them and hope to fluke a player in the draft. At least we will know we will lose every week with that forward line. now you are just being silly no one is saying to slice the list up for nothing picks but as yo...

Don't like this trade. Stanley seems to be the only one that can play ruck/fwd - very mobile and takes marks, lots of them, many contested. They spend years developing him, only for someone else to benefit. He's only about 23, what sort of message does that send to the playing group? DP 21 and the ...

I'd back a fit Hickey & Longa in any day. Remains to be seen if either can rest forward and be dangerous. Same can be said for Stanley. exactly Stanley was for most games dead wood in the forward line and an average at best ruck ... with Longer we have an average ruck who is dead wood in the fo...

Well based on that comment lets trade every single player over 26 years of age or retire them and hope to fluke a player in the draft. At least we will know we will lose every week with that forward line. now you are just being silly no one is saying to slice the list up for nothing picks but as yo...

I'd back a fit Hickey & Longa in any day. Remains to be seen if either can rest forward and be dangerous. Same can be said for Stanley. exactly Stanley was for most games dead wood in the forward line and an average at best ruck ... with Longer we have an average ruck who is dead wood in the fo...

Couldn't be bothered reading past page one so sorry if repeating things. Firstly Im not sure Jaxons can claim this one. Was on SEN right at that time though I believe he has some knowledge of trades going from Ben last year. Anyway 21 is overs for Stanley however that doesn't make the trade a good ...

Couldn't be bothered reading past page one so sorry if repeating things. Firstly Im not sure Jaxons can claim this one. Was on SEN right at that time though I believe he has some knowledge of trades going from Ben last year. Anyway 21 is overs for Stanley however that doesn't make the trade a good ...

Couldn't be bothered reading past page one so sorry if repeating things. Firstly Im not sure Jaxons can claim this one. Was on SEN right at that time though I believe he has some knowledge of trades going from Ben last year. Anyway 21 is overs for Stanley however that doesn't make the trade a good ...

makes it sound better then 1 first round and two early second round picks ...

but Pluggs these rumours do have some value ... we are 3 weeks from the g/f and people are still talking footy and its still dominating the sports reports - this year especially the interest has been the biggest so for the state of the game this is huge add to the fact its been nearly 8 weeks since ...

we wont get 10 for him .... not unless we chuck in Milera and our pick 22

Inconsistency is definitely an issue. But I still believe that Rhys will rise to the occasion as the Club gets stronger in time. I see no value in a trade for pick 21. At least pick 14 and a player. Otherwise my bottom line is leave him where he is and hold the faith. Go Sainters ! ! highly over ra...

So what is the story here? Yes or no? Take your pick. Stinger or Jaxons? ill stick with Bains .... Stinger wouldnt know his elbow from his you know what i mean the guy admitted he wrote a letter to the club asking them not to trade Dal (hardly the workings of someone in the know more a sooky fanboy...

how has Stanley finally arrived ?? he looked good in patches in 3 games last year other than that it was same old same old from him ... he may improve signifigantly with better delivery but the fact is he isnt going to get that from us for a fair while yet .. as for sending him to freo over geelong ...

gringo do we really need to replace Stanley ?
a fit Hickey can float forward from the ruck
Bruce can move forward , Tom Lee/Spencer White may get more of a run up front .. is Stanleys role really a vital cog especially considering we are morethan likely going to be a bottom 2 team again next year

Spurt i think you are Waaaaaayy off the mark with AR ... AR is a cooler headed coach he doesnt get angry as such .. Watters used to talk for the sake of talking and would often repeat himself and then contradict himself he was all puff and blow hence why the players never really brought into him as ...

Geelong must see him as a 3rd banana fwd/ruck. They already have the Tomahawk and Mitch Clark. Surprised given that they already have Clark. They have also over recent years completely changed their staregy with the recruitment of recycled players. We're they once proud that their team was all home...

Ok so let's say wright gets taken at 3. McCartin ain't a ruck and none of our other rucks can play forward. Seriously not liking it. Trade Longer. Oh that's right no one would want him. Stanley could embarrass is if he goes. Sure if he was 25 or older piss him off, but gee, pick 21 doesn't inspire ...

really? the saints hired an insane man to be head of the trade period and help with list management? yeah sure i can see that not ask dermie why the hawks gave him the flick......... Dermie also thinks Scott Watters was going to be the next Kevin Sheedy .... his opinion is not exactly bankable

Great to see that they are fairly compensated as usual whilst we got SFA for Ball. yep......if beams is worth two goods picks and a player....why are posters on here keen to see jack go for one top 20 pick ffs???? i would rate Beams a fair bit higher than Steven ..... Steven is the best player in a...

the issue i feel with Rhys is he has the body for footy he has the size and the speed and he has the skills to be a very good player but to me i think he is a little too timmid.. for a guy his size he should be struting about throwing his weight about like Gehrig did back in the day not really his f...

if he is contracted then he is stuck at the dogs if they dont trade him .. he would have to "retire" and sit out a year to get out of it...

I will be livid if we trade out Steven, and will criticize the decision accordingly if it eventuates. . i wrote to the club last year asking them not to let dal go..didn't make any difference of course. but....if jack goes i also will be livid...and may not renew my membership.....or any of the oth...

Steven is a great player no doubt but is he the guy you can build a club around ? he had a great year in his B&F year but he had the likes of Dal Lenny and Joey takeing the majority of the heat that year so while it was a breakout year its still yet to be seen if it can be built on - i dont want...