Can you please highlight where the umpiring has been named as the cause of the loss? Can you point out where posters have singled this out, or where they have said that if not for the umpiring we would have won? We had our chances last night, didnt take them, and coud have won the game. We made err...

Can you please highlight where the umpiring has been named as the cause of the loss? Can you point out where posters have singled this out, or where they have said that if not for the umpiring we would have won? We had our chances last night, didnt take them, and coud have won the game. We made err...

Standard reactionary umpire bashing garbage from various posters looking for somewhere to vent their spleen. From 58 - 43 up we went down 103 - 94. Simply not good enough. Not hungry enough, not confident enough, not enough quality. Stop pointing the finger at the umpiring and start pointing at our...

Coaching next for Fraze? Didn't GT say he'd make a great coach one day?

Fishers one was a disgrace dud, have you ever played footy?? Awful decision, the worst for the nigt, and there were 5 or 6 shockers! He dragged it in so he loses all rights unless he gets it out. Correct decision. the flowering filth maggot was standing on the ball ffs..... :roll: :roll: :roll: :ro...

Anyone who thinks that the umpires don't have any effect on the outcome of games is living in fairy land. Simply put, Collingwood received 4 very dubious free kicks that directly resulted in goals. In a 9 point result that does effect the outcome. The one against BJ that Lockyer got was a disgrace ...

The ball was a foot in front of Fisher, he dragged it closer to him then failed to knock it out or make sufficient attempts to clear the ball. I disagree with the rule, but don't disagree with the free kick. Well, if thats what we have come to, and thats the way we are going to play the game, call ...

the free at the start of the 4th a bit crap to say the least I had a perfect view and it was there. Gardiner did not need to block the pies player. It was just plain dumb. Was soft as....view or no view. Umpires lost it for us. Not Milne or Lenny's kick at goal or lack of skill. I never said they l...

fisher camped over it...given...however he didnt touch out utter bulls*** Ur not allowed to camp over it u gotta knock it out mate Pack converged instantly, no opportunity, and he didnt drag it in. In control of ball. Same thing. So when a midfielder grabs the ball off a ruck contests, takes 2 step...

fisher camped over it...given...however he didnt touch out utter bulls*** Ur not allowed to camp over it u gotta knock it out mate but that's the thing. isnt this the free where rocca had the ball pinned between his legs... so it wasnt even in fisher's possession? Think that was the hudgton one...a...

LENNY LEADS THE WAY wrote:

Saints Premiers 2008 wrote:fisher camped over it...given...however he didnt touch out

utter bulls***

Ur not allowed to camp over it u gotta knock it out mate

Pack converged instantly, no opportunity, and he didnt drag it in.

the free at the start of the 4th a bit crap to say the least I had a perfect view and it was there. Gardiner did not need to block the pies player. It was just plain dumb. Was soft as....view or no view. Umpires lost it for us. Not Milne or Lenny's kick at goal or lack of skill. I never said they l...

plugger66 wrote:

Sainterman wrote:Fishers one was a disgrace dud, have you ever played footy?? Awful decision, the worst for the nigt, and there were 5 or 6 shockers!

He dragged it in so he loses all rights unless he gets it out. Correct decision.

If you consider that dragging it in....I don't.

Sorry Plugger, we best not comment on the umpires, keep the game sanitised. You think the umpires were good tonight??

Fishers one was a disgrace dud, have you ever played footy?? Awful decision, the worst for the nigt, and there were 5 or 6 shockers!

plugger66 wrote:

aquariusJ30 wrote:the free at the start of the 4th a bit crap to say the least

I had a perfect view and it was there. Gardiner did not need to block the pies player. It was just plain dumb.

Was soft as....view or no view.

Fisher had no opportunity to knock it out, watch the replay. Awful decision.

The Fisher and Goddard free kicks were very bad umpiring decisions and not errors.

A Casey thread has managed to become a GT thread...??!!

i would have thought Sam Fisher would have got a game for dream team...any reason why he didnt?

Great stuff!!

I think Lewis Hamilton from F1 was also grromed from a young age, although I believe it was McLaren that paid the way for him. He is now on a lifetime binding contract!

bobmurray wrote:No wonder some people have high post counts,this thread went round and round and then went nowhere.......

I need a lie down after reading 5 pages of drivel.....

Ready for bed after reading that thread! Really, perhaps some PM's might have done the trick!

35

Hamstring problem, although not sure of severity.