If the cats were to lose to Adelaide, and the Hawks still beat the Dogs, wouldn't the second week be reversed? Geelong would be the highest ranked loser and therefore get to play the lowest ranked winner, or the winner of the Sydney v North game. The winner of us v Pies would be playing the loser o...

If the cats were to lose to Adelaide, and the Hawks still beat the Dogs, wouldn't the second week be reversed? Geelong would be the highest ranked loser and therefore get to play the lowest ranked winner, or the winner of the Sydney v North game. The winner of us v Pies would be playing the loser of...

I don't think Gilbert is our next key backman, in fact I have just done a brief scouting mission myself. And I found the answer! Not sure about the ball skills though. Just deprive him of all food for the week and stick some meat in the full forwards socks when he's not looking! http://i213.photobu...

We actually agree there Plugger, Bulldogs very important game for us.

Can always hope for Port to beat North, Freo over Collingwood, and the Bulldogs over the Crows! With a win that'd leave us 4th!

Plugger not turning up? I hope he does, would be nice for Harves to have him there whatever the big man might think about the Saints. Always wondered why he wants nothing to do with us post his departure, was never that acrimonious a parting was it? What a great day it will be on Sunday...so glad w...

Cannot wait. Great that the club is putting on such a fantastic day for Harves...! Will be there for sure..!

Let's NOT let the negatives interfere with what is going to be a GREAT DAY for ROBERT HARVEY & A GREAT DAY FOR St KILDA FOOTBALL CLUB . Spud has stated that he hadn't given up on either just yet. Lets just enjoy the day and show the footy world once again that; NO-ONE DOES THESE THINGS BETTER T...

Through the late 80 and early 90's Plugger was everything down at St Kilda. It is so incredibly disappointing that he makes no effort whatsoever to put anything back into the club that made him a superstar. I will hold back my real feelings on the guy in the hope he turns up...but his record is very...

Plugger not turning up? I hope he does, would be nice for Harves to have him there whatever the big man might think about the Saints. Always wondered why he wants nothing to do with us post his departure, was never that acrimonious a parting was it? What a great day it will be on Sunday...so glad we...

Dals goal on the run wasn't bad either....!

Plenty of one %'ers tonight from Dal. Nice to see.

Can archie and the gang down there get anything right? Or do we just announce things and hope for the best...??

I believe we might be, just unintentionally!

Something to consider. OK for Dan and others to complain about dropping one of our best, but is he performing up to his pay packet. No point in comparing apples with oranges. I'm sure Dal is being paid probably twice as much as Schneider (probably more). It's not just a matter of performing better ...

If this is true then Ross has got the wrong guy. try Gram or Monty first...Schneider very average too...

Not happy about this one...hope to be proven wrong!

All for giving kids a go, but at the expense of Dal Santo in a game that defines whether we have any hope left in 2008....sheesh.

What a great piece of management this is...Archie Fraser at the helm and its looking pretty messy! Surely we should have had things a little more locked in before we made an announcement. It really makes me wonder about the current admin!

We have been unlucky. Wat about the time we beat North by a point and a goal was paid to us which clearly hit the post or Aussies point which was out on the full or when we beat WCE by a couple of points and spider was paid a goal that clearly never went through the goals. Yes we are unlucky. Oh de...

Why were the MRP even involved in this? Please correct me if I'm mistaken, but in the Baker case, it was given to an 'Investigations Officer' who sent it straight to teh Tribunal, because THERE WAS NO VIDEO FOOTAGE OF THE INCIDENT. Here we have a case of a player leaving the ground bleeding and app...

Queue sarcastic Plugger66 comment.

That is one very scary group of field umpires!

SEN have said that the noises are coming from moorabin that fraser will not retire but be put onto the LTI, allowing the club to elevate a rookie. A decision on his future will be made down the track. Isn't that fiddling a trifle with the rules. He was good enough to play last week, suffered no inj...

thanks MM :) so thats why i reckon its more the players fault then the umps, we played good enough footy to win the game, it was only our own stupidity (and lets face it, some absolutely ridiculous goal kicking by Collingwood) that lost it for us I don't disagree with you Dud. I am going to archive...

[ It makes one not want to post...frustrating at times. Lack of respect for others opinions on here is a regular occurance. And it is often those with the highest post counts that perpetuate it. Anyway, we move on to next week. Good to see Big Mac do well today in tough conditions. Notice that you ...

St Byron, I'm at a loss to understand why you posted what you did about blaming the Umpires. I have just reread all 64 posts on this thread and apart from the op by Saints Premiers 2008, no other post has directly blamed the Umpires for our loss last night, if you discount MatrixCutters sarcastic p...