B.M wrote: ↑Sat 05 Oct 2019 10:51pm Of course you agree with Curly, hardly surprising?...

If Paddy was an academy of f/s selection. Would we have bid on him at pick 1 if we rated him there?

No idea if this is to me.

But if it is I agree with Curly because I believe he is right for the reasons I have explained above.

CURLY wrote: ↑Sat 05 Oct 2019 11:41pm

B.M wrote: ↑Sat 05 Oct 2019 10:51pm Of course you agree with Curly, hardly surprising?...

If Paddy was an academy of f/s selection. Would we have bid on him at pick 1 if we rated him there?

No why would you?

Ridiculous call by you and displaying you have no idea.

100% spot on.

Curly Give it a rest, seriously And if clubs did have him 1 or 2 Yes, they had it wrong. DeGoey, Brayshaw, Moore, Lever, Heeney, Wright ... in hindsight were easily better picks. I do realise Heeney and Moore were bid players, but we didn’t bid on them. As everyone knows, I had Christian at #1 Whic...

GC should’ve taken Max & Ben at 2 & 3 especially losing May & Lynch in the same off season. Nah I would prefer my club to back themselves in and draft on talent - especially if there are better rated players at 2 and 3 (which was obviously the opinion of the Suns and many other draft an...

They did do that?! A bid came in the first round for both players, and they matched. So now you’ve sort of got your head around it, let’s look at the original argument. Moore and Heeney were in a group of players who (with hindsight) could/should have gone as the number 1 selection as they have tur...

Curly Give it a rest, seriously And if clubs did have him 1 or 2 Yes, they had it wrong. DeGoey, Brayshaw, Moore, Lever, Heeney, Wright ... in hindsight were easily better picks. I do realise Heeney and Moore were bid players, but we didn’t bid on them. As everyone knows, I had Christian at #1 Whic...

GC should’ve taken Max & Ben at 2 & 3 especially losing May & Lynch in the same off season. Nah I would prefer my club to back themselves in and draft on talent - especially if there are better rated players at 2 and 3 (which was obviously the opinion of the Suns and many other draft an...

I find it slightly ironic that on one hand there is an outcry that GCS are getting helped out by the afl Yet on the other hand people want to rip the young players out of the club GCS make terrible decisions. Don't deserve a priority pick. Recruiting Ben King AFTER Max had been taken by the Saints ...

I find it slightly ironic that on one hand there is an outcry that GCS are getting helped out by the afl Yet on the other hand people want to rip the young players out of the club 100%. It’s what makes the outcry on the Suns package thread so so so stupid. Couldn’t have said it better myself.

jaxons wrote: ↑Fri 04 Oct 2019 10:39pm

CURLY wrote: ↑Fri 04 Oct 2019 10:26pm

jaxons wrote: ↑Fri 04 Oct 2019 10:25pm

Myron Gaines wrote: ↑Fri 04 Oct 2019 10:17pm My guess/hope: Ollie Wines.

Right club, different player.

Howard.

On the money.
Doesn't mean we will get him but we are keen at this stage.

He seems to be generating some interest!

good. We may have a pair of balls aftwr all. mental illness ... OMG give me strength. Worst excuse ever. Steven should visit a psyche ward and see REAL mental illness. homesick/depressed about a girl is NOT f****** MENTAL ILLNESS. We give in to this we are dumb c***s. GO SAINTS GIVE THOSE ARROGANT ...

Steven is threatening to retire if he doesn’t get traded to the Cats, we should just let him f****** retire if he’s going to start playing those games!!! f*** HIM That sort of comment wont go down well at the Cattery. It increases the risk associated with the player and how that might look as desta...

News from some ITK over at Big footy (where Jonny is now because people on this site are often negative and agressivly negative to those that share information) Is that Ratten and Lethelan went to SA today to meet with a player that could be interested in coming to the Saints. Matt Crouch Would be ...

Kelly is a massive potential loss for Geelong and Steven could perhaps make up for, what,.40% percent of this loss? And that’s in the first season. Don’t blame him if he is just motivated enough by the South coast/Geelong fairytale to get him over the line motivation wise. It would be a real bummer...

I can't believe some on here that just take media comment as gospel. I believe the following comment made on BF by a respected moderator, is much closer to the actual situation. Comment includes Bruce situation as well. I will be glad when the fantasy trade period ends and the real stuff begins nex...

diddley wrote: ↑Tue 24 Sep 2019 2:50pm

BarryGrogan wrote: ↑Tue 24 Sep 2019 10:32am Another terrible nickname.

We are an embarrassment when it comes to the this age old and time honoured skill.


Seriously, 'Jill'?? WTF?

It’s not that bad.
Jack and Jill.
We have enough Jack’s that they have to be identified somehow.

Nah, I think it’s terrible too.

If we had balls, we demand at least a second rounder... we don’t and will do what’s politically correct. I was thinking exactly the same thing regarding the decision and the club wanting to portray itself as doing what's politically correct After all, the CEO has a reputation for it The priority fo...

B.M wrote: ↑Tue 01 Oct 2019 9:23pm Western Bulldogs 2016?

Good decisions and good players win premierships

Good sample size.

If we had balls, we demand at least a second rounder... we don’t and will do what’s politically correct. I was thinking exactly the same thing regarding the decision and the club wanting to portray itself as doing what's politically correct After all, the CEO has a reputation for it The priority fo...

Sorta want Masten all of a sudden!

The sad thing is this package is 110% needed for the Suns. The amount of talent each and every year that they lose is incredible. This is an attempt to break the cycle. As mentioned above - we havent won a premiership for 53 years - we played them twice this year and 1 point separated the teams in ...

The sad thing is this package is 110% needed for the Suns.

The amount of talent each and every year that they lose is incredible. This is an attempt to break the cycle.

Speaking on nonsensical Barry, you weren’t even around then, so you don’t really know do you? The messiah complex has always been alive and well at Moorabbin, particularly with small minded supporters. Are you talking to me? You should quote me for two reasons: Unless I actually re-read a thread, I...

Amazing.

Some would have you think we should play a ruckman at all.

Great post Perfectionist!