Saintsational Fan Forum

chook23

From the tribunal Tribunal chair Jeff Glesson said Caminiti did not intend to strike Murphy in the head but it was careless. “Murphy’s body lowers before impact and that appears to have significantly contributed to Caminiti’s forearm making contact with his head rather than his neck or shoulder,” he...

chook23

I think 3 weeks is a good result considering everything. Your opinion I think considering everything not a good result But it is only opinions The delusional theories going on here to try get him off were nothing more than that - delusions. Was always going to go, was talk of 5-6 weeks, so 3 is a g...

chook23

The_Dud wrote: ↑Tue 18 Apr 2023 8:44pm I think 3 weeks is a good result considering everything.

Your opinion

I think considering everything not a good result

But it is only opinions

chook23

WellardSaint wrote: ↑Tue 18 Apr 2023 8:37pm 3 matches.
Downgraded by tribunal to 'careless'

Other areas should have been downgraded based on video

But hammer did not help with his answers or advice answers

Following the Twitter our defence team and hammer himself did not handle it too well

Poorly prepared on face value

chook23

Given video

If argued a certain way I think he may have got a better result

chook23

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Tue 18 Apr 2023 8:32pm I reckon the Kangaroo court will give him 5 weeks. It's beyond ridiculous.

3 confirmed

Should have been 2 at the most

chook23

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Tue 18 Apr 2023 8:32pm I reckon the Kangaroo court will give him 5 weeks. It's beyond ridiculous.

3 confirmed

Should have been 2 at the most

chook23

3 weeks

chook23

AFL and AFLW Tribunals / Appeals Board Tribunal Chair: Jeffrey Gleeson KC. Tribunal Deputy Chair: Renee Enbom KC. Tribunal Jury Members: Michelle Dench, Wayne Henwood, Jason Johnson, Stephen Jurica, Richard Loveridge, Stewart Loewe, Shannon McFerran, David Neitz, Paul Williams and Shane Wakelin. Ap...

chook23

asiu wrote: ↑Tue 18 Apr 2023 8:04pm if
he didn't hit him
had no intent to hit him

then ipso facto
there can be no film of a non existent hit

actual or surmised

how can they possibly c**k that up

Hammer admitted hitting him to the head with forearm

Read through the Twitter of David zita

chook23

Argue not a strike but

then say 3 weeks would be appropriate if downgraded

THIS IS ST KILDA REP Saying THIS

chook23

Poor answers

Poor questioning by saints representative

Why???

chook23

The AFL says Caminiti is "retaliating" to Murphy, which Caminiti has denied in his evidence.

Amazing answers

chook23

Seems like some of hammers answers are at odds with st kilda submission.....

Hammers answers like he has had no advice

Amazing

We seem unprofessional

chook23

magnifisaint wrote: ↑Tue 18 Apr 2023 7:33pm St Kilda: Did you strike Murphy?

Caminiti: No.

St Kilda: Was it ever your intention to strike Murphy?

Caminiti: No.

This is laughable!

is that confirmed

If so we need a new mouthpiece to advise

chook23

Feedback from tribunal on Sen

Will get 5 if upheld

If downgraded will get 4

Way overs
2 weeks I think

chook23

Also a few of his hanballs have excellent

Correct player out of congestion creating goals

Appears to be a quick thinker...best option etc

He looks very promising

chook23

saynta wrote: ↑Mon 17 Apr 2023 9:12pm
chook23 wrote: ↑Mon 17 Apr 2023 9:07pm
tony74 wrote: ↑Mon 17 Apr 2023 8:12pm Will have a long run in the VFL.Very raw
But obviously showing something
Yep, Buddy mark 2. Sorry Isaac for putting pressure on you.

Paddy Ryder mark 2 will do

chook23

tony74 wrote: ↑Mon 17 Apr 2023 8:12pm Will have a long run in the VFL.Very raw

But obviously showing something

chook23

Understand that the retaliator does not get a reduction but if that is now a 4 to 6 week offence

The initiator deserves a penalty

chook23

I am still not convinced he hit him high

Unless there is other vision

Was this the incident that caused the concussion??

Can a hit in chest cause concussion via a head jolt

chook23

Life Long Saint wrote: ↑Mon 17 Apr 2023 7:24pm
chook23 wrote: ↑Mon 17 Apr 2023 7:20pm 4 weeks plus

You are kidding
Up to four weeks

Graded intentional....high contact....high impact

4 weeks plus according to Sen
Minimum 4

chook23

Life Long Saint wrote: ↑Mon 17 Apr 2023 7:24pm
chook23 wrote: ↑Mon 17 Apr 2023 7:20pm 4 weeks plus

You are kidding
Up to four weeks

Graded intentional....high contact....high impact

4 weeks plus according to Sen
Minimum 4

chook23

Life Long Saint wrote: ↑Mon 17 Apr 2023 7:24pm
chook23 wrote: ↑Mon 17 Apr 2023 7:20pm 4 weeks plus

You are kidding
Up to four weeks

Graded intentional....high contact....high impact

4 weeks plus according to Sen
Minimum 4

chook23

Life Long Saint wrote: ↑Mon 17 Apr 2023 7:24pm
chook23 wrote: ↑Mon 17 Apr 2023 7:20pm 4 weeks plus

You are kidding
Up to four weeks

Search found 4863 matches

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: The blind turn by Mattaes Phillipou

Re: Isaac Keeler

Re: Isaac Keeler

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?

Re: Is Caminiti in trouble?