Aren't you embarrassed to even go there...after such a great game? I saw 4 or 5 dubious calls that went Geelong's way...so what!!? It happens. It evens out Lions were down by 4 goals early in the 3rd. They kicked the next 7 out of 8 goals to hit the lead. Nothing to do with umpire bias. Geelong had...

The_Dud wrote: ↑Sat 21 Sep 2024 9:18pm

CURLY wrote: ↑Sat 21 Sep 2024 9:06pm AFL umpires don’t even try to hide their agenda.

Geelong destroyed by some of the worst decisions you’ll see.

lol, good ol’ Curly, always cryin’!

Charlie Cameron’s head gets taken off in the dying minutes inside 50, play on

Called a free you twit and they played on and goaled.

AFL umpires don’t even try to hide their agenda. Geelong destroyed by some of the worst decisions you’ll see. Yeah... you're right. The umpire smothered the ball in the middle - not Daniher. The umpire kicked it forward to Cameron - not Answorth. The ump was composed and kicked it to Cal Ah Chee. A...

AFL umpires don’t even try to hide their agenda.

Geelong destroyed by some of the worst decisions you’ll see.

They got them all as First Round Picks They didn’t get the as well as first round picks Good talent identity (as kids) Good recruiting Good development Good culture We had gifts as well Pick 3 Pick 1 In those drafts Chose McCartin and Billings We finished last and third last that’s why. Would have ...

Was he a top 2 talent as a draftee??? Obviously now he’s a gun, and a good selection As was Daniel Kerr (pick 18) Why wasn’t he bid on earlier? Mills was pick 3 Blakey pick 9 They got Heeney after playing in a GF and Mills after finishing 5th the next year. Pretty easy to remain on top getting that...

I’m still pretty sure they gave up draft capital to secure those players Other clubs bid on them, then you need to match points. You then have to put them in the same cap as everyone else COLA was stopped a decade ago after the Franklin deal Yep giving up pick 18 to get top two rated talent must hu...

Don't want will push Dow or Byrnes out of the side.

Amazing how good your culture is when your gifted Heeney Mills Blakey and extra cash. Or homesick players like Dangerfield come home.

Who are all these elderly players we apparently keep picking up?

I'm sure if McCrae went to Collingwood next season and was getting 30 a week everyone would be whinging why we didn't grab him. Or asking why we can't attract players.

Biggest load of bulls*** of all time. Move on.

Scollop wrote: ↑Wed 18 Sep 2024 12:44pm Ok. There we have it.

In Mcrae

Out Dow

Yep if McCrae comes and is playing better footy.

Byrnes can go.

How does it stop the development of others? Ridiculous comment. Don't you like logical debate? What annoys me is the commentary regarding our 'centre clearances' early in the year...We were missing many of the regulars and there were injuries and suspensions. It took a while to get continuity. Was ...

How does it stop the development of others? Ridiculous comment. Don't you like logical debate? What annoys me is the commentary regarding our 'centre clearances' early in the year...We were missing many of the regulars and there were injuries and suspensions. It took a while to get continuity. Was ...

How does it stop the development of others? Ridiculous comment. Don't you like logical debate? What annoys me is the commentary regarding our 'centre clearances' early in the year...We were missing many of the regulars and there were injuries and suspensions. It took a while to get continuity. Was ...

See the amateur Under 19 game that was ruined by a over zealous umpire. Local footy with umpires sitting up in Grand stands with ear peace's in place calling free kicks from 200 meters away. Seriously a poor example set from the top is filtering down. Imagine calling free kicks from the stands, or ...

See the amateur Under 19 game that was ruined by a over zealous umpire.

Local footy with umpires sitting up in Grand stands with ear peace's in place calling free kicks from 200 meters away.

Seriously a poor example set from the top is filtering down.

What sort of support do you reckon Mcrae will provide? The kind that says, he'll try and get first hands on the footy and then he relies on everyone else to defend and chase and do the tagging? Dow and Clark can do that easily can't they? How did Jack Mcrae go this year when Bevo asked him to do th...

He lacks leg speed. That's why he's on the decline. Beveridge and the Dogs match committee aren't dumb. Mcrae may not have the body to play for the next 3 seasons. That's why they played him as a sub this year. That's why James Harmes was preferred. It didn't work but nothing really did against the...

I realise you make a lot of general comments and don't want to discuss specifics I know exactly how many games he's played. But won’t be of benefit There's a limit to how many listed players you can have on your list There's a limit to how many players you can have on the field There's a limit to e...

Scollop wrote: ↑Tue 17 Sep 2024 3:25pm I realise you make a lot of general comments and don't want to discuss specifics

I know exactly how many games he's played.

But won’t be of benefit

Gees you're good at generalising. ..."clearly he and Daniel are on the outer" Yeah....why? Let's just focus for a second on specifics. You're saying that Mcrae might have made the difference against the Hawks in the final....ok...look at the game in rnd 8 or 9 this year. Dogs v Hawks. Who...

CURLY knows better than Luke Beveridge Will just check the score of the final v Hawthorn. Beveridge has been widely criticized for doing everything other than what everyone can see is logical Yes ...if you want to make general statements, then I suppose you can conclude a lot of stuff about the sco...

Scollop wrote: ↑Tue 17 Sep 2024 1:54pm CURLY knows better than Luke Beveridge

Will just check the score of the final v Hawthorn.

Beveridge has been widely criticized for doing everything other than what everyone can see is logical

McCrae is an upgrade on Crouch Ross and even Byrnes.

He runs and links up. Beveridge not playing him through the middle was one of the most ridiculous things youll see.