What do you call 6 Collingwood players holding hands in a circle? A DOPE RING Why do they bury Collingwood supporters upside down whey they die? IN CASE THEY TRY TO DID THEIR WAY BACK UP AGAIN

Regardless of our poor effort today there were some worrying signs with the finals coming up.Yes I know our 2 small forwards will make a big difference but our skills are terrible at times . Gilbert is a good player but a very poor kick as is Jones often missing easy targets and neither has a right ...

5 Goddard
4 Hayes
3 Gardiner
2 Montagna
1 Peake

Hayes should be appointed All Australian captain this year. Mccloud was appointed captain one year when he was not even his club captain so the precedent has been set already. Hayes is a certain selection on his superb form this year and judging by comments from other teams top players he is the mos...

5 Montagna
4 Goddard
3 Kosi
4 Dal Santo
1 Roo
Dal let himself down at time with some ordinary passes
although his game overall was excellent, Miles showed promise but again Mcqualter was just so so.

5 Roo
4 Goddard
3 Hayes
2 Gram
1 Schneider
I know it's only people's opinion but how anyone at the game would not give Goddard a vote on this forum is laughable. A North supporter next to me said only Roo's great effort in kicking 7 goals stopped him saying Goddard was our best player today.

5 Hayes
4 Goddard
3 Schneider
2 Milne
1 Roo

I certainly was not blaming our loss on the umpires, far from it. What is amazing is how we cannot get free kicks that other teams receive for the same holding the ball contest. Watching the Pies today Luke Ball has now joined those other 4 players ( who are top class footballers ) who get a charmed...

5 hayes
4 goddard
3 roo
2 montagna
1 schneider
waste of time putting in only one person for votes
why bother.

We were very poor but we only received 3 free kicks for the whole second half. Are the umpires betting in games against us? We cannot buy a free kick, often when they are so obvious to everyone. Opposition players never get penalised against us when caught. I'm not blaming them for our loss as we ha...

When I selected my best ever Saint team on this forum after watching them play since about 1954 I put both in my side leaving out Brownlow winner Ross Smith for Hayes, that's how i rate Lenny but Winmar in my humble opinion was the better as he had everything including being able to play full forwar...

5 Hayes
4 Goddard
3 Schneider
2 Ray
1 Fisher

Fingers is right. These players who are so poor on their opposite foot should be kicking all the time on them at training. What are Peake and Gilbert learning at training? There should be someone ready to throw the ball to them on their opposite kicking foot over and over as they run past until it b...

5 Goddard 4 Fisher 3 Montagna 2 Geary 1 Gardiner Very hard to give votes today as we had so many passengers yet we still nearly had the same scoring shots as them. Gilbert's disposal lets him down badly at times as did Fisher's in the first half but Sam still put in a top effort. Gardiner got in bec...

The umpires kept paying frees against us yet the same things against the Pies were never paid. The one not paid against Ball was just plain cheating. makes you wonder if umpires are getting people to lay bets for them :oops: Saying that we did not deserve to win with the brand of football we play. W...

5 Gilbert
4 Ray
3 Gwilt
2 Fisher
1 Dal
Put Fisher in as he was excellent all night but Hayes and Montagna were unlucky to miss out

Anyone on this forum who rubbishes John Greening as a footballer is a moron. He was a superb player ( Goddard reminds me of him at times) and that is very high praise from me. He probably would have won the Brownlow as i think he was leading at the time that year. Your comments Thinline about him we...

5 Goddard
4 Montagna
3 Dal Santo
2 Jones
1 Hayes

I see you can't squeeze Goddard into your best 22 ????

5 Gwilt 4 Schneider 3 Goddard 2 monty 1 Dal So hard to give votes as we had many top efforts on the night Steven, Hayes, Gardiner, Fisher and Gilbert just to name another 5. Gilbert lets himself down at times with his kicking especially his short passes back across goal which has caused turnover goa...

McLachlan is an idiot. He said in today's paper that football fans loved tradition. This coming from the dill who brought in our ridiculous draw where teams play some teams twice before playing every other team once. Get rid of him for God's sake. He is stuffing up what was once an excellent competi...

Solar, was our back line 50% more efficient against the Dons when Dawson was there????? He gave away about 6 goals with his pathetic display that game. Make him earn his spot back through Sandringham, it's not about structure, it's about putting in when the contest gets hard, something Max did at fu...

Why should Peake be dropped? I put him as my fifth best in the votes plus a few others also gave him a vote. If you went on last week's form Baker should be out as his lack of pace was shown often. Yes, i realize he won't be dropped but if it is a dry night the Cats forwards could run rings around h...

I noticed Geelong do it a few times against the Dons. When kicking to a one on one contest they kicked it over their heads with the Cat's player ready to recover quicker and pounce on the ball resulting in him breaking away into the open. It certainly gets the ball down to their forwards much quicker.

5 Goddard
4 Gilbert
3 Milne
2 Ray
1 Peake