should be able to play for 5 years as well, which is good

samoht wrote:I reckon Hall is the red herring and he is being used - to draw attention away from the real play.

I wouldn't be surprised if all the attention turns and there is a last minute scramble/stampede for Fev.

no chance

If there is no trade by the cut-off on Friday I think he can choose the PSD or to re-sign with us, or possibly nominate for the real draft too. If he chose to risk going anywhere rather than stay with us, then he really has fallen out of love with St Kilda agree, however how all this has unfolded l...

+ 1

he has cut ties with the club so why should the saints do any favours for him to their own detriment

no, there is no place for him in our team. imo better to take a late draft pick with pace and see what happens.

we dont want to get fev and lose lynch. Lynch will be a good player for a numer of years to come, whereas fevs time is seriously limited and will not be playing in another 5 years.

mabe part of his reasoning was seeing the closing gap between him and our developing players

i think and hope armo will have a better year then ball in 2010, he showed what he can do in tassie lets hope he will be a better player filling the free spot

this may of been covered but what do you rekon the filth will offer us?

Football is a 'business' people aresaying well it's time for the club to play hardball like a million dollar business. Luke we don't give a damn where you want to go you have put us in an awkward position nominating because now Collingwood will try and screw us over royally. * Weak draft * Gibson g...

bitterly dissapointed if i may say so, he is leaving a team with genuine premiership chance to the filth. This decision is mafe all the worse by the fact he is going to the filth. It will be a sad day when he leaves all i can say is that the deal better be effing sweet for st. kilda.

SainterK wrote:Well done Roo, anyone have the top 10?

had a look after i posted lol

2009 Trevor Barker Award Top 10
Nick Riewoldt 642
Brendon Goddard 638
Leigh Montagna 635
Nick Dal Santo 618
Lenny Hayes 603
Clint Jones 587
Sam Fisher 531
Sam Gilbert 521
Jason Blake 487


well done to these guys

Fitting result for the best player that I have ever seen. Yes, I'll say it again. Nick Riewoldt is the best player I have ever seen. Goodnight That is a huge call, he did deserve his 5th B&F, congrats roo. Surprised hayes wasnt top 3 though, however i am not suggesting BJ and Montagna didnt des...

Eddie is has a great knowledge about football and summed up the saints season perfectly. Where as the chief football writter Caroline "feminist" Wilson is more concerned with attacks on her 'reputation' like Newmans efforts (which while stupid were not as bad as they were made out to be in...

cant believe that they sacked fev, back to the bottom 8 for carlton now. If we could get fev for the right price and trade i would be happy to take him. But paying 650-700k for someone who might very well not make it into the side for failing the trademark is just not work it. However with fev and r...

West ham

will we see the start of the decline in geelong next year?

matrixcutter wrote:worst part of the aftermath??
waiting another 5 months for the footy to start

EPL will have to do till then

hmmm, i have been a blake critic in the past but i think he is in our best 22 now he has earned his spot.

Max Hudgton couldnt get a game in our backline. Hes a far better backman than Goos will ever be. Who is Goose gonna push out? Raph? - is Goose as mobile.....could he have taken a Burns? Gilbert? Fisher? Dawson? Baker? Is he a fwd now? I dont like the chances of hanging on to him and if the right tr...

Monday experts are pathetic, shouting off what they heard on the telly or something they may off read.

The Fireman wrote:Suicide is Painless

a MASH fan are we

i found that the geelong supporters i knew were generally fairly good understanding the bitter dissapointment experienced by all St. Kilda fans. The worst and most infuriating thing was the idiots i knew that do not follow football and would barely know the final was on (some who have never even bee...

all i can say is that we better play more then 1 game at the MCG before finals, so we dont head into a final as we did with the pies which was virtually a home game for them due to our lack of experience on the ground

i would be very surprised if carlton traded fev, he is to important to their structure. the blues wouldnt make the finals next year if they do trade him in my opinion. I wouldnt want fev either, if things dont go his way he sooks and doesnt try, we have no room for senior players with this attitude ...

resorted to watching the grand final marathon, it is the 71 grand final atm featuring the saints. way before my time