FB is a bit of a waste of riewoldts running capacity; however at CHB he could domonate, pushing forward and delivering it with precision. He really hasnt done a great deal this year so it wouldnt leave a masive hole; which could be filled with a fit Kosi, Goddard, Lynch, Will or even Tommy Walsh. Le...

I believe that lynch is a must as he is a versitale and up and coming young player, and the inclusion of Winmar and Siposs would incease our skills level dramatically B: Gwilt, Dawson, Smith HB: Clarke, Riewoldt, Fisher C: Winmar, Armitage, Montagna HF: Ledger, Goddard, lynch F: Milne, Koschitzke, S...

Glibert has seemed a little lost up forward, however he appeared to provide a lot of drive out of the middle after lenny went off last week. It is a must that he rotates through there, and Armitage needs to start in the middle on the wknd!!!

Nathan Djerrkura could provide the leg speed and added flair that we need to add to our team. He also looks like he will develop into a quality play that could rotate through our midfield.

If my assumptions are correct we should have a fair amount of space in our cap next season. This will be created by the departure of Andrew Lovett as well as possible retirement of Gardner and Baker. Therefore we should be able to go after a bigger name during trade week (assuming that everyone hasn...

I think he looks like exactly the type of player we are looking for. Could play HHF, and if he proves himself to be an effective line breaker or ball magnet with goot skills could push into the mid field. We should offer Geelong a second round pick 4 him. I think they will let him go, to benifit him...

Sorry, Zac, Im a fan but I think you should forget about the rest of this year and go back into the gym and put on as much weight as possible! and focus on next 2011. It's sad to say but our backline has looked more stable this year when Zac has not been apart of it. Good luck Zac, I hope y9ou get b...

Yes, ended up with Goddard instead. However couldnt we have also selected did Salopek at pick 6 but we decided to trade it to Port as part of the Brooks deal???

He would be great on our list, as long as we dont have to give up to much for him!!

Missed the game, and probably a good one to miss. However was wondering how Tommy went Friday night and if he looks like a likely type

Against the Hawks Dempster looked like he was getting back to the form he had before he injured his knee. He was strong and dependable, and as long as the coaches remember he's a backman and not a forward I believe his form can continue to improve.

Good to see Jammar giving Gardiner a good old grope

We currently have 8 rookies, and from what I've read heard and seen Jarryd Allen and Leigh Fisher are finished and wont play for the st.kilda football club again. I think Gaertner is realling promising and will be a very versitile AFL player. Simpkin and Tommy Walsh also looked like they have someth...

I think Eddy is in Trouble, who comes in will all depend on match ups. I think It will be either gram, Zac or miles. After finally going back to our structure, why would you take out a forward (Stanley) for a backman (Zac). That is not a winning formular!!! Out: Raph (inj) Eddy (omitted) In: Gram (i...

I think they will push Sandilands forward, and this may cause us some trouble. Now we all know that Kosi isnt in the best form so this may be our opportunity to send him dowm back. Leaving the young gungs Big Mac and Stanley in attack to compliment the 200 gamer.

where has A.Smith gone? I thought he'd be up and flying by this stage

Geelong have build an awesome team based around some very good father son picks. I am interested to know if there are any promising boy coming up through the system that would qualify for a father / son pick for St. Kilda.

So how did Gaertner go today? Did he continue his good form?

Sorry joffa let me rephase that 'I've never seen him play live'.

I've personal never seen him play, however it appears as if he has really come on this year. He has been in the best for Sandy in the Past 3 games. Looked alright in the NAB cup; is 199cm, quick, fairly agile (no less than Zac) and can play in a variety of positions. I think he would be a great incl...

Thanks for letting me know... i was wondering where he was last night. We have 12+ weeks with out him, and therefore we NEED to find some solutions to this problem

It's all well and good to have a defensive mind set, but we need to regain some of our attacking flare! Where has it gone? and how can we get it back?

U simply cannot consistantly beat good teams with 7-8 goals!

Not sure who is worse the saints players or the umpires

It is simple he has once again demonstrated that he is simply not good enough!

Numerous people have mentioned it before and have always thought that he has a lot of potential. However enough is enough, ash he does not learn!

When it comes to it seems as certain rules come and go as the umpires / afl see fit!

Neither here nor there. He didnt make many obvious mistakes, however did nothing exceptional (apart from a very nice hit). I think he will improve as his confidence grows as long as the saints does.