I liked L.Fisher, quite a handy player imo.

Really, who are we going to pick up with the picks we have?
They're all very high picks.

I'd rather keep L.Fisher than get someone with pick 62 or whatever it is, who gets delisted two years later imo....

Sign for a year with us Luke. If you don't like it after a year then you can head up GC17 or Collingwood can try again with a reasonable offer. It's up to you now Luke, make the right decision and prove your worth to us and the Pies. No point playing him next year if he's going to leave again at th...

yea right, josh fraser for ball.. good one.

give me pendlebury

Seems like Peake in for X out?

Happy or not happy?

X got me angry last year, but he seemed to be dominating in the reserves before injuring his knee :S

I wouldnt mind fev (as long as he doesn't be an idiot off the field).

I guess Gardiner had a similar/poor background and turned it around.

You'd have Fev at FF, then Kosi and Roo on the 50m arch each side of the oval, giving 2 options rather than always to Roo option.

for pick 16?

I think we got ripped...meh...

I'd get him over Lovett if we used a low draft pick, rather than giving 16 to Essendon for Lovett + a player.

Is this topic a joke? What if this, what if that, whinge whinge whinge, he did some good things, some things didnt work out. Get over it. Stop blaming everything past and present on GT. Post something useful or nothing at all. I'm sure there's plenty of clubs who should of picked Nick Dal Santo or J...

I dont think we need lovett, we got Ray, and X will be back from a reco, then you'd have those three fighting for the one spot, and Ray has been doing a fine job. Imo, we need another fast/tallish forward, not another thin speedster. I mean, even Geary can play on the wing, we do not need thin lovet...

Lovett?
I dont think I want him, I wouldnt give up Goose and pick 16 for him.

The question is now who will they bring from collingwood and will Dave be competing for the same spot with someone else. Personally I don't care. When he is here in two weeks I am going to give him the biggest G up to try and get motivated. I believe this HAS to be his year to step up. Time to get ...

cement your spot armo


your a gun

We train at Moorabbin. No roof. Geelong train at Kardinia Park. No roof. The weather had nothing to do with the fact that we missed 9 or 10 easy shots in front of goal. That's what cost us the game. As they say in the classics, bad kicking is bad football. "Train" and "Play" are...

:?: Max match up? see article,=R:- no naive article , he'd only played 7 games too much of a risk- Zac had been unwell - on a drip and two hour solids till he got through warm up. Max at his fittest yes BUT limited prep, Dempster other option in that position. Great write up. However more on this i...

Hrm I wouldnt mind Fev, but its up to the coaches. I dont think we could have 3 big forwards (although what a dilemma for other teams to have, lol) or we'd be too slow at ground level? I wouldnt trade Kosi or Meguire for him. Our list is pretty nice atm, doesn't need chopping, just tweaking, althoug...

No.

If one defender gets injury atm, the only real big backup atm is Matt Meguire that is solid/tall.

mark coghlan? (spelling..)

Ah give Milne a break, it was a miskick, he slipped sort of when he kicked it, maybe wasn't wearing the studded boots, if it wasnt wet, he would of ran to the goal square, but probably was too nervous to just touch it on the ground. He just needs to go back to square one, and learn how to kick a goa...

I think Milne should go. No point keeping players who can't perform in finals. I dont think so, the problem is we play at the Dome with a roof, so how many games did we actually play in the wet? Imo, its football and the roof should be open whether its rain, hail or shine, but the spectators dont w...

one of the players that i reckon plyed his last game is dempster. aint quick enough skillful enough or tall enought. he isnt out standing at anything and thats why he found it so hard today. normally a player stands out in a particular aspect of the game. another player which may of played his last...

1. Kicking for goal (So many easy shots got missed). 2. Luck (That turnover last quarter, dawson punches it off ablett, ball goes forward, rebounds off Rooke, straight to Ablett). 3. Weather We were the better team on the day, unfortunately we lost. Guess the only thing to remember for the guys is t...

Knew he'd choose Dempster, RL loves him, probably the right decision in the end I guess... he is fairly solid, can play alot of roles and kick goals. Still his last game was a shocker and did jack all, so its a worry picking someone with "experience" who hasn't had the "wow" fact...

er I dont think he has retired just yet....?? I think he could go on one more year, love max, best full back I've seen, Ive seen those spearing low passes with the full forward leading fast and max has been right there and punched it away, dont think I've seen any other fb do that consistantly.... u...

I think armo or dempster could come in, just love how armo goes in and under hard, and he knows how to kick goals, although having said that, RL loves dempster alot, so I wouldnt be suprised. Still have to sqeeze max in too but. If Jason Gram doesnt do anything this weekend, I'll crack it. Slack las...

Hrm tough week for selections, I thought a few players had average games.... Eddy, Ray, Gram... when the going gets hard, they dont seem to be able to "step up" unlike L.Hayes for example. They dont have enough influence to change the game in our favour. Schnider had a shocker, too much fl...