Are the doubters on this thread really saying that the published membership tally (nudging 39,000) is false.?

In the last two games Gilbert has picked out opposition players on several oocasions in a row early in the game, then he seems to settle down. A bit like Raph last season, early errors, then a good game. Exactly the way I have been seeing it. He will improve generally and is one of our best each we...

The Dogs have only themselves to blame for losing it.
They brought the game into disrepute with all that chipping back and forth and yet we have got the tag "Ugly Saints".
Eade will never coach a premiership team.

mick13 wrote:Amazing transformation. I...don't know where he's come from.

But I'm not complaining!

Produced in Rabaul, honed in Noble Park , polished and seasoned at Moorabbin.
A fine gentleman to talk to.
A word of advice to all those posters who are lining up now to buy you a drink : Stay Cool.

Apology to Manangatan Thirds

I said at half time that Jones should go to him.. Not sure who was on him.. I said before the game started he was a danger. After he did damage for three quarters he was then switched on to BG and wore him like a glove. In summary, the worst game I have seen for years and that is not sour grapes. T...

Yes he did well against the arguably best ruckman going around at present

In: McEvoy
Out: Dawson
I have excluded Rooey-- he will be there in spirit.

Plays like he talks-- straight from the shoulder.
But it gripes me when the commentators always like to hark back to his friendship with Cousins as though it is a black mark against him.

[quote="i_luv_nick_riewoldt"]I thought joey clarified it last year by saying it is Mon-tag-nah?

Because i remember thinking how i had pronounced his name differently for years![/quote
I personally asked him two years ago and he told me Montagna (ie no "nya".).

How long will it take for the Filth to wake up to the fact that Cloke kicks for goal like he is wearing one?

saintspremiers wrote:I'm going to give the whole team 10 out 10 tonight.

I reckon in your votes Milney should be factored in.

He was very creative and did a top job keeping the forward line open in it's restructured form without Roo.

How do you rate Zac Dawson?

[quote="saintspremiers"]I'm going to give the whole team 10 out 10 tonight. I reckon in your votes Milney should be factored in. He was very creative and did a top job keeping the forward line open in it's restructured form without Roo.[/quote You are gratuitous toward Zac Dawson by naming...

Ironically, one their best last night which I regard as a further tick in our favour.

There is a big hole to be filled and I hope McEvoy steps up. Dont know much about Stanley. One thing is for sure IMHO-- Zac has to go. He is the first scalp I have ever called for. Indecisive, waits for his opponent to move, gives away too many frees ( four last night) and his handball to nobody in ...

The official count was Filth 23; Saints 16.
I was almost hoarse by half time at the blatant bias against us.
Two attempts to behead Schnieder in recent games have not just gone unheeded but the other way!

The article on Ball was written by a "Staff Writer"-- one of the HS faceless reporters, so, more empty talk!

Sure looked well on the telly

The first name I look for every week is GWILT.
You guys have not let up yet.

I thought he missed a big opportunity to impress.

He did not set the world on fire against the Demons

Interesting Bergo. Obviously you have done your homework.
Whether or not it is- as you infer-prudent for the club to go to print, it gives supporters like me some background to the espionage involved in the game. Not that anything has changed there of course.

Looks like another very contoversial season ahesd. Heads will roll.

[quote="Enrico_Misso"]Serviceable.
Couple of very costly turnovers.

Will he hold his place when Sam and Raph come back?[/quote

Give it a break. Was every other player error free.?
He cops it every week from some of you perfectionists!

Why would the Swines gripe about the umpiring?
The count was 28-19 in their favour.