I will welcome Harvey when two conditions are met

1. All those who played with him have either retired or joined other clubs and

2. He is the best available candidate

SaintPav wrote:These are the realistic choices.


Mark Williams

John Worsfold

Alan Richardson

Peter Sumich

Some one please refresh my memory, why and how did Mark Williams leave port Adelaide?

Longer and pick 48 to St Kilda in return for picks 25 & 41. That pretty well wrecks any chance of Buce coming to St Kilda in excahnge for a pick. If GWS would not release him for pick 41 they wont release him for pick 48. It would seem that St Kilda recognised GWS was not going to play ball on ...

Eastern wrote:Yippee,

An extra Interstate trip to play North Hobart in Tassie !!

Yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If true....

One part of the rumour has beared fruit so far... Yup - kudo's to jaxons. He doesn't post often, but a couple have been absolute gems, a couple of others where he told me off so he is obviously very astute and a good judge of character jaxons... where art thy.........we implore you....give us a sig...

All year Scott has been saying we will be AGGRESSIVE in trading this year......maybe i'm missing something but I aint seeing it, apart from Delaney & Bruce we have not been linked to any player with some Talent, why are we not persuing Savage from Hawthorn or have i missed that part, am very fr...

whiskers3614 wrote:

santazzi wrote:Yea Me...I still have a soft spot for the "Traitor".....In my book once a saint you are always a saint.........I wish success to all who have once served our club....

OK then.
Go Brent Guerra!

I am with your logic...........and the same goes to "Go Zac Dawson"....

Yea Me...I still have a soft spot for the "Traitor".....In my book once a saint you are always a saint.........I wish success to all who have once served our club....

I will welcome him back with an open arm...but I am only a member of the club and I will not have day to day dealings with him...therefore there must be an open discussion involving all players and coaches (people who will have to interact with him) and a consensus reached before his return..

Mullet....I hear you loud and clear!!! Big Mart I think, with respect, you may be missing Mullet's point.....He is saying "culture" does not exist....it is a fiction created by the media to sell papers....so if you accept this premise there is no point in asking whether Port has bad or goo...

BigMart wrote:I've heard he has a good attitude and is very fit.... Works hard and is tough.... But that's just from people who know him...

Thanks BM for standing up for a Tassie boy. Let me state a truth that is self evident..."No one born under the Tasmanian sky has attitude issues"

Please be true. Please, please be true. I wonder what extent of redevelopment will be involved. Plenty, with plenty of AFL & Government money to make it happen !! Love the AFL to help but why would they? P66....because they are nostalgic about our scandals.....and they want to reward us for hav...

If there is a good stream and you have the time please PM me.....Thank you.

Any Scores?

Eastern wrote:I watched that game today and they aren't that good. They will be flat because their finals race now is over and we should BOUNCE BACK from last night's performance.
I'll be screaming at the TV, hoping for a win. GO SAINTS !!

I hope Not

I would offer Big boy and Armo to GWS for pick 1. Armo will never be an A grader and Big boy, while I like him, is neither a top ruckman or a KPP. He could easily captain GWS and would do a great job. Maybe that wouldn't be enough to tempt them though it would sure as hell improve their team. Are y...

Can I now get excited about the "mathematical possibility" that we may play finals?

St Pav...I can assure you that I am not being precious about the term juggernaut. I think WW got my meaning. Juggernaut is one of those words often used to devalue victory by an opposing force. The term was regularly used by the media to devalue successive victories by the club 2009. That is the poi...

WW I pay a great deal of attention to your posts. I think you make a lot of sense and I also believe you have avenues to be reasonably informed on matters STK. I have no issues with your proposals in this post. However, I have a problem with the term "Juggernaut". In the heady days of 2009...

Bernard Shakey wrote:Clint Jones and Beau whatever he calls himself should never play AFL again.

Finish the year at Sandy and back to the WAFL for both.

I did not have the chance to follow this game on TV or radio. i know we lost. Are Clint and Beau responsible for our loss?

Don't know if this has ever been posted, but a short video of the last game at Moorabbin. How many were there? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K61If5Z6aKs Incidentally, that little old lady interviewed at the end, That was my mom. Thanks 3GS...moistens the eyes.......I envy those of you who were the...

It just came to my "conscious" self that some clubs have presidents and others chairmen. Why? Is it just a matter of choice? (like we can call our president chairman if we want to)....Is it historical and significant some have chairmen and others presidents?....is it written in the article...

Ok so it would appear that more and more supporters and posters on here are making the same observation that Dal is just doing enough this season. Stats for the Swans game would suggest he had an ok game but really if you break them down he was missing for almost 3 qtrs and probably his best being ...

No....any unhappiness I have about our losses is compensated by the willingness of the coaches to give our youth a go...........I like this because it tells me that the coaches are not putting their own interest (KPIs such as win loss ratio) infront of the club's medium to long term interest.......

Ray again seems to be out of watter's thinking. Think we need a bit more experience in that team myself. Glad Kosi gets a chance, possibly his last, so hope he stands up. I hope not. I believe this is his 196th game. He needs to make it to 200. Unlike us, quite a few clubs have prospered from the f...