What we miss is consistency, this is a team that beat Richmond and Port Adelaide and managed to lose to Fremantle and north Melbourne, there’s far too big a difference between individual best performances and worst performances. At a micro level we see it far too often in players play a couple of go...

CURLY wrote: ↑Sat 22 Aug 2020 7:34pm Don’t like Hunter being one of our best ball users.

Who would you prefer to be one of our best ball users ?

Technically we used the hawthorn pick on Clark, but still happy with the trade back in 2016.

Think about the logic for a moment Essendon down 7.5 to 2.0 completely outplayed trudging off at half time resigned to their fate. Take the time to look Up at the scoreboard which may or may not have the vision dermies worried about, if they do see it it’s this vision that turns them into avenging a...

Given Abbot was one of the emergencies I couldn’t understand not playing him. However thats water under the bridge, I think we do need a bigger body in the forward line to attract defenders and contest in packs. If it’s not one of the ruck men Ryder/Marshall/ Abbot, then maybe we need to bring clava...

Not sure what it is about this year but the entire competition is suffering from a lack of output from the tall forwards. The leading player in the Coleman only has 24 goals after 10 games hardly colemanesque.

Maybe not so much what’s wrong with membery, but what’s the go with key forwards.

Queensland’s current quarantine rules effectively put you in quarantine if in the previous 14 days you A) have been overseas; or B) been in a COVID-19 hotspot; or C) had contact with a person who is a confirmed case of COVID-19; D) had symptoms consistent with COVID-19 which is how we can play Frema...

If you miss the player update window your stuffed for 12 months we even have a player who has played for the club who doesn’t have a photo (Jonathon Marsh) and Jack Mayo been at the club for more than six months and doesn’t have a photo.

Think structurally King is very important only really tall forward option who if he’s not marking it will bring the ball to ground for likes of Lonie Butler and co. Also diverts attention from Membrey. If not in side Ryder/Marshall draw a better defender when playing forward. Forward alternatives Ma...

We kept them to just 12 scoring shots There will be a couple of very happy little kids who wear 21 on their backs And the Coach And we have a couple of players to come in Did anyone put their hands up in the VFL game yesterday? Stkilda website report said Marsh and Hind standouts for Sandringham ba...

With a nearly fully fit squad we do seem to have the opposite problem from last year with Carlisle, clavarino Robertson and Austin fit. The emergence of Battle and Wilkie. The form of Brown and the option of Joyce or Marsh and the recruiting of Howard we don’t lack options for KPD’s that can’t all p...

11 senior list and 1 rookie have been delisted/retired/traded. (including Paddy) 5 senior players added so far. I think Joyce will need to be upgraded. Wilkie may also be upgraded. That would leave 4 senior list and 3 rookie list vacancies. I think we have 3 National Draft selections at this stage?...

I think we need to delist 4 but you have forgotten Pierce and Mayo.

If you bundle up everything and equate a swap of picks within a round. I come up with the following.

IN
Hill
Howard
Ryder
Jones
Butler
2020 fourth round pick
Pick 51


OUT
Steven
Acres
Bruce
Pick 6
Pick 76
2020 second round pick
2020 third round pick

I suspect whatever we were going to get for Steven was going to be part of the Hill trade. So while I think the pick was unders does it matter, we only had if for moments before it was gone.

SANDRINGHAM v. WERRIBEE Round 11 – 16/06/2019 02:10 Wilson Storage Trevor Barker Beach Oval Sandringham B: 59. J. Noone, 39. D. Joyce, 37. B. Rice HB: 38. O. Clavarino, 2. J. Carlisle, 1. N. Coffield C: 53. K. Answerth, 10. D. Hannebery, 46. D. Langlands HF: 79. J. Mayo, 12. M. King, 50. N. Wright F...

Team balance ? White was an emergency his spot as an emergency has been taken by Hind.

Round 9 - 02/06/2019 12:30 Piranha Park Coburg Sandringham B: 69. J. Batchelor, 38. O. Clavarino, 52. J. Hille HB: 13. J. Noone, 31. B. White, 62. S. Tahana C: 53. K. Answerth, 20. D. Armitage, 33. B. Paton HF: 40. N. Hind, 78. S. Gilbert, 37. B. Rice F: 66. S. Fox, 12. M. King, 51. J. Haidon R: 55....

There are several posts on this site about picking injured players Bytel, King and Hannebery, It was that I was referring too.

Hope is injury concerns are behind him for all our sake this site will explode otherwise From hi draft year ..... Height 192cm Weight 81kg Birthday November 5 STRENGTHS: Marking, goalkicking, skills, vertical jump, speed IMPROVEMENTS: Durability SUMMARY: After missing two and a half years of footbal...

Sandringham B: 52. J. Hille, 43. J. Marsh, 31. B. White HB: 1. N. Coffield, 39. D. Joyce, 78. S. Gilbert C: 53. K. Answerth, 20. D. Armitage, 62. S. Tahana HF: 40. N. Hind, 47. S. Rowe, 50. N. Wright F: 66. S. Fox, 12. M. King, 41. R. Young R: 18. B. Longer, 11. H. Clark, 49. B. Seccull Int: 76. R. ...

Not eligible Rowe and Marsh brought in for Robertson and Bytel our two season long injuries.

All other longer term injuries are “indefinite “ so unless one of them very quickly turns into a season long injury no spots left.

Brandon’s not a like for like replacement for any of the outs this week, you could argue that he should have come in for Geary but his spot has been taken by Patton. (Mind you I don’t see any of the in’s being a replacement for Lonie either.) I think the smaller back four of Webster, Savage, McKenzi...

I think too you would find if we played an extra ruckman he would not give Marshall a chop out the roles would have to be reversed. That is Longer/Pierce would play 80-90% in the ruck with Marshall playing as a KPF giving them a chop out. Why because Longer and Pierce can only play ruck. With that s...

must have been a late inclusion because he did play. Saw a little of him on the telly and boy he’s tall but he makes longer look like a gazelle.

1 handball 1 mark 18 hit outs