Are we interested in any of these??

Saint4Eva · Wed 20 Oct 2010 10:24am

Beau Dowler, Rhan Hooper, Beau Muston, Simon Taylor, Wayde Skipper and Cameron Stokes??

From what i saw last year Beau Muston had a few great games and is a good size. Simon taylor is a fantastic tap ruckman and would be good insurance if Big Benny doesnt take another step forward..

ChicagoSaint · Wed 20 Oct 2010 10:27am

maybe muston

Con Gorozidis · Wed 20 Oct 2010 10:38am

stokes maybe (can he run?)

dunno why we didnt go after djekurra

dragit · Post: # 1017781Post **dragit** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 11:10am

Only Muston for mineâ€¦
Hasn't been given many opportunities but can playâ€¦
After a debut of 31 touches & 2 goals, has only played 12 more.

Quixote · Post: # 1017821Post **Quixote** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 12:59pm

ChicagoSaint wrote:maybe muston

Sounds more like a TV show.

dragit · Post: # 1017825Post **dragit** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 1:04pm

Quixote wrote:
ChicagoSaint wrote:maybe muston
Sounds more like a TV show.

tinker with taylor?

St. Luke · Post: # 1017836Post **St. Luke** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 1:37pm

The Hawks look like they are in damage control!

Richter · Post: # 1017837Post **Richter** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 1:41pm

Gary Moss is one that I remember playing a few decent games the year before last.... must be a reason that the Hawks didn't persist though....

Richter · Post: # 1017838Post **Richter** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 1:44pm

Wikipedia wrote:Garry Moss (born 5 July 1988) is an Australian rules footballer playing for the Hawthorn Football Club in the AFL. Attended Newman College in Churchlands, Perth, Class of 2005. Drafted by Hawthorn with 56th overall pick in the 2006 AFL Draft from East Perth in the WAFL, he is a midfielder who was on the Hawksâ€™ senior list for two seasons before being delisted, but then re-drafted at the end of the 2008 season.

After making his league debut in 2007, his 2008 season was wrecked by injuries, but he managed to play several games for Hawthorn's VFL affiliate Box Hill Hawks. He then played his second AFL game against the Sydney Swans in round 2 of the 2009 AFL season. In Round 5 he was awarded the AFL Rising Star nomination following his 4 goal and 24 possession performance against the West Coast Eagles.[1]

dragit · Post: # 1017842Post **dragit** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 2:00pm

St. Luke wrote:The Hawks look like they are in damage control!

It's great isn't it, I remember a few years back Kennett saying that they expected to win 2-3 flags in the next 5 years, they're recruiting in 05, 06 has turned out to be horrendous
2005
3 Xavier Ellis
6 Beau Dowler
14 Grant Birchall
18 Max Bailey
22 Beau Muston
2006
6 Mitchell Thorp
24 Brent Renouf

Bardon Saint · Wed 20 Oct 2010 2:03pm

Moss and Muston have shown glimpses. Worth a pick up? I'm unsure. A big no to the remainder.

dcstkfc · Post: # 1017844Post **dcstkfc** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 2:03pm

Having done a bit of research, none of their delisted guys would seem to be of much value.

All of have something but for a variety of reasons there are deficiencies in their games/lifestyles that mean they wouldn't be of much use.

dragit · Post: # 1017848Post **dragit** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 2:08pm

dcstkfc wrote:Having done a bit of research, none of their delisted guys would seem to be of much value.

All of have something but for a variety of reasons there are deficiencies in their games/lifestyles that mean they wouldn't be of much use.

What lifestyle choices are inhibiting them from good footy?

Dr Spaceman · Wed 20 Oct 2010 2:09pm

dcstkfc wrote:Having done a bit of research, none of their delisted guys would seem to be of much value.

All of have something but for a variety of reasons there are deficiencies in their games/lifestyles that mean they wouldn't be of much use.

Let's try and get some talented young kids into the club.

People bemoan our lack of young players. Why load up with more 22-23 year olds?

Your home's not gonna look too flash if you keep picking up the things that people leave out on their nature strips!

Quixote · Post: # 1017851Post **Quixote** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 2:15pm

dragit wrote:
dcstkfc wrote:Having done a bit of research, none of their delisted guys would seem to be of much value.

All of have something but for a variety of reasons there are deficiencies in their games/lifestyles that mean they wouldn't be of much use.
What lifestyle choices are inhibiting them from good footy?

They are all drug addicts.

saintly · Post: # 1017855Post **saintly** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 2:23pm

i thought cameron stokes was a good a good player. and could be worth a chance

dragit · Post: # 1017857Post **dragit** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 2:29pm

Dr Spaceman wrote:
dcstkfc wrote:Having done a bit of research, none of their delisted guys would seem to be of much value.

All of have something but for a variety of reasons there are deficiencies in their games/lifestyles that mean they wouldn't be of much use.
Let's try and get some talented young kids into the club.

People bemoan our lack of young players. Why load up with more 22-23 year olds?

Your home's not gonna look too flash if you keep picking up the things that people leave out on their nature strips!

no way!
next years line up

FF hooper miller medhusrt
HF gamble headland motlop
C lockyer carr slattery
HB eagleton polak mcmahon
FB wiggins croad dowler
Foll taylor mcdonald o'bree

nice.

GrumpyOne · Post: # 1017878Post **GrumpyOne** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 3:39pm

I'd be prepared in this compromised draft to use our 144th pick on Beau Dowler.

Might be a good pickup if he ever gets his body right.

gringo · Post: # 1017923Post **gringo** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 4:47pm

I am really surprised about muston. He was injured going into the draft and put him down the order from memory. Other wise there was talk of him being a very high pick.

It seemed like he should make it but his body let him down.

Gee the Hawks really didn't go so well in that era of recruiting after all. the were seen as geniuses for getting the drafting right, now they look like they are going for a rebuild.

#1GILL · Post: # 1017925Post **#1GILL** » Wed 20 Oct 2010 4:50pm

gringo wrote:I am really surprised about muston. He was injured going into the draft and put him down the order from memory. Other wise there was talk of him being a very high pick.

It seemed like he should make it but his body let him down.

Gee the Hawks really didn't go so well in that era of recruiting after all. the were seen as geniuses for getting the drafting right, now they look like they are going for a rebuild.

He's already had 3 knee reco's I think.

But you are definetly right about him sliding in the draft due to injury. Was expected to be top 5 I'm pretty sure.