Guess this weeks ins and outs

plugger66 · Post: # 1083908Post **plugger66** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 8:21am

out
Winmar, siposs, Blake

In
Walsh, Kosi, Clarke

Quixote · Post: # 1083911Post **Quixote** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 9:26am

I'd take that.

Quixote · Post: # 1083912Post **Quixote** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 9:26am

I'd take that.

clarky449 · Post: # 1083913Post **clarky449** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 9:30am

I thought Walsh was miles away..

Anyways
Out: Winmar Blake
In: Kosi Clarke

InkerSaint · Thu 02 Jun 2011 9:37am

Out: Blake (knee) Lynch (finger) Winmar
In: Kosi Clarke Walsh

perfectionist · Thu 02 Jun 2011 10:01am

Out: Blokes who are injured
In: Next best blokes who aren't
Otherwise: No change.

dragit · Post: # 1083921Post **dragit** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 10:18am

Out: Blake(inj), dempster(inj), winmar

In: Kosi, baker, Raph

Johnson for siposs if he doesn't come up

Cairnsman · Thu 02 Jun 2011 10:47am

Sippos will definitely be out. Coach wonâ€™t want to risk him against the Pies especially if rumors are true about him being sore.

Winmar might be out. See Sippos

Rhys Stanley might get a look in especially if Kosi canâ€™t come in. Coach might be curious to see how he goes against the top team with a second tier ruckman in Woods.

Clarke to come in to replace Blake down back.

Dr Spaceman · Thu 02 Jun 2011 10:59am

clarky449 wrote:I thought Walsh was miles away..

He was before we recruited him

Richter · Post: # 1083938Post **Richter** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 11:14am

OUT: Blake (inj), Winmar (omitted)
IN: Kosi, Gram

St Chris · Post: # 1083940Post **St Chris** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 11:25am

Out: Blake, Lynch, Siposs, Dempster (All injured)
In: Walsh, Ledger, Kosi, Baker

Emerg: Gram, Clarke, Smith

SainterK · Post: # 1083945Post **SainterK** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 11:48am

Out Blake Dempster Winmar
In Kosi Mini Ledger

Ledger to sub

Emg Gram Clarke Walsh

Moccha · Post: # 1083948Post **Moccha** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 11:56am

Ins: Cowboy Neale, Barry Lawrence, Bob Murray, Brian Mynott
Outs: Zac Dawson, Nick Winmar, Arryn Siposs, Jason Blake

Moods · Post: # 1083950Post **Moods** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 12:00pm

Richter wrote:OUT: Blake (inj), Winmar (omitted)
IN: Kosi, Gram

Agreed. Obviously Raph has playing well in the two's for so many to be tipping him to come back in, but he was woefully out of form prior to his dropping. Gram wasn't as bad, and actually had some good games - just needs to be more accountable and go in a bit harder.

dragit · Post: # 1083956Post **dragit** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 12:19pm

SainterK wrote:Out Blake Dempster Winmar
In Kosi Mini Ledger

Ledger to sub

Emg Gram Clarke Walsh

Ledger could be a great sub,
He might not have the frame to get through a full game yet, but could maybe replicate what Cripps had been providing, for the last 45 minutes of the match?

defacto · Post: # 1083957Post **defacto** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 12:21pm

OUT: Blake, Lynch
IN: Kozi, Baker

Con Gorozidis · Thu 02 Jun 2011 12:46pm

thr raph revolving door.

How about ledger in?

Ice Wolf · Post: # 1083960Post **Ice Wolf** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 12:51pm

Out: Lynch (finger) Blake (knee) Dempster (concussion)
In: Kozitsche, Walsh, O'Dea (Collingwood fans would blow their tops)

AnythingsPossibleSaints · Thu 02 Jun 2011 1:02pm

Thought there was already a thread on this?
Anyway,
OUT- Blake, Winmar, Siposs
IN- Kosi, Baker, Walsh (if Brown is expected to play, otherwise Raph, or Johnson)

saint tash · Thu 02 Jun 2011 1:11pm

Hope no one is over looking the trip back from Subi as the weather that day looked quite taxing. I'd expect we would be alright and as to who it effects more whether it be the older bodies or the younger ones who knows.

Wouldnt surprise to see both Sean and BJ miss just due to the fact they were carried from the ground. BJ hadnt played many minutes so might have the advantage whereas Sean had played all but 2 mins of the match and his recover may not be as great.

Blakey is a certain out.

Wrote for Luck · Thu 02 Jun 2011 1:25pm

Out; Dempster, Goddard, Blake, Lynch
In; Baker, Clarke, Simpkin, Kosi

(I've aligned who I reckon will be replacing who directly underneath each name) ruck duties obviously Kosi for Blake

spert · Post: # 1083966Post **spert** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 1:29pm

If we're playing the best team, then we don't chuck in inexperienced players. Sounds like Dempster and Goddard may be OK
Out: Blake, Winmar
In: Baker, Kosi (purely to back up Macca)

Sub: Siposs

tony74 · Post: # 1083967Post **tony74** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 1:32pm

spert wrote:If we're playing the best team, then we don't chuck in inexperienced players. Sounds like Dempster and Goddard may be OK
Out: Blake, Winmar
In: Baker, Kosi (purely to back up Macca)

Sub: Siposs

Pretty close I reckon

Sobraz · Post: # 1083986Post **Sobraz** » Thu 02 Jun 2011 2:29pm

Really hope Raph isn't recalled...

No immediate need for him this week, and I'd prefer to see him string 4-6 very good games together in the 2's... Really get his confidence (and his body) bubbling...

Ideally i'd like to see the same with Kosi, but he may be a necassary in due to Blakes injury... Otherwise, 3 weeks at Sandi, getting his hands on the ball would do him the world of good...

Hope Sippos comes up...

Out: Blake, Winmar
In: Kosi, Mini/Raph

Is what I think Ross will do...

I'm hoping Winmar is ok, so it'd be Blake for Kosi/Walsh...

Dr Spaceman · Thu 02 Jun 2011 2:40pm

Hardest week of the season to pick it.

Blake out is the only certainty. Injury concerns to Goddard, Dempster, Lynch and Siposs. Probably concerns over Winmar's fitness, or at least his ability to keep playing at senior level at this stage of his development.

Add to all that the fact we're playing a battle hardened opponent at the top of their game and the fact Sandy had a great win last week with good contributions from players young and old, experienced and inexperienced.Â

And on top of that you've got RL's reluctance to make too many changes week to week.

Could be anything from one change to six changes and I really have no idea.