Coaches Votes 2011

saintbrat · Post: # 1083543Post **saintbrat** » Tue 31 May 2011 9:08pm

Fremantle vs St. Kilda

6 Montagna (St K)

5 Dal Santo (St K)

4 Gilbert (St K)

4 Jones (St K)

3 Fisher (St K)

3 Schneider (St K)

2 Steven (St K)

2 Dempster (St K)

1 Gwilt (St K)

rare for such a wide spread. and all from one team.. but interesting that not a vote for McPharlin- unlike the ' popular media awards who thought he blanketed Nick- .. one coach would know of Roo's role the other obviuosly suspected it.

#1GILL · Post: # 1083545Post **#1GILL** » Tue 31 May 2011 9:10pm

That is the strangest voting I've ever seen. Which coach gave Dal 5? And which gave him none?

saintbrat · Post: # 1083547Post **saintbrat** » Tue 31 May 2011 9:12pm

#1GILL wrote:That is the strangest voting I've ever seen. Which coach gave Dal 5? And which gave him none?

and one gave Joey 5 and the other gave him 1

#1GILL · Post: # 1083549Post **#1GILL** » Tue 31 May 2011 9:14pm

plugger66 wrote:
#1GILL wrote:That is the strangest voting I've ever seen. Which coach gave Dal 5? And which gave him none?
Maybe neither gave him 5. I want to know which coaches gave Gilbert and Jones 4 and none.

It is certain that one of them gave him 5.

plugger66 · Post: # 1083550Post **plugger66** » Tue 31 May 2011 9:15pm

#1GILL wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
#1GILL wrote:That is the strangest voting I've ever seen. Which coach gave Dal 5? And which gave him none?
Maybe neither gave him 5. I want to know which coaches gave Gilbert and Jones 4 and none.
It is certain that one of them gave him 5.

Please dont post so quickly before I delete it. makes me look dumber than normal.

#1GILL · Post: # 1083551Post **#1GILL** » Tue 31 May 2011 9:16pm

plugger66 wrote:
#1GILL wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
#1GILL wrote:That is the strangest voting I've ever seen. Which coach gave Dal 5? And which gave him none?
Maybe neither gave him 5. I want to know which coaches gave Gilbert and Jones 4 and none.
It is certain that one of them gave him 5.
Please dont post so quickly before I delete it. makes me look dumber than normal.

I'm like a bull at the gate. Gotta get up pretty early to sneak one past me.
Bad luck bud

saintbrat · Post: # 1083553Post **saintbrat** » Tue 31 May 2011 9:18pm

compared to media votes- ( shows how they don't see it as football departments do)

the Age
FREMANTLE v ST KILDA
Simon White
Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 8
Sam Fisher (St Kilda) 8
Sam Gilbert (St Kilda) 7
Clinton Jones (St Kilda) 7
Luke McPharlin (Fremantle) 7

did anyone see the herald sun - or Footy Show votes?

maverick · Post: # 1083564Post **maverick** » Tue 31 May 2011 9:34pm

plugger66 wrote:
#1GILL wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
#1GILL wrote:That is the strangest voting I've ever seen. Which coach gave Dal 5? And which gave him none?
Maybe neither gave him 5. I want to know which coaches gave Gilbert and Jones 4 and none.
It is certain that one of them gave him 5.
Please dont post so quickly before I delete it. makes me look dumber than normal.

Classic

bergholt · Post: # 1083852Post **bergholt** » Wed 01 Jun 2011 8:53pm

that gave us a lot more names on our vote list! something like this now then:

25 Leigh Montagna (votes in 3 games)
11 Sam Fisher (4)
10 Nick Dal Santo (3)
7 Brendon Goddard (1)
6 Nick Riewoldt (1)
5 David Armitage (2), Lenny Hayes (1)
4 Sam Gilbert (1), James Gwilt (2), Clinton Jones (1), Stephen Milne (1), Adam Schneider (2)
2 Zac Dawson (1), Sean Dempster (1), Jack Steven (1)
1 Jason Gram (1), Farren Ray (1)

17 players with votes of the 34 we've used so far.

saintbrat · Tue 07 Jun 2011 12:11am

Round 11
Collingwood vs St. Kilda

7 Cloke (Coll)

7 Davis (Coll)

7 Pendlebury (Coll)

6 Thomas (Coll)

2 Reid (Coll)

1 Dal Santo (St K)

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ ... 3d49b15297

odd sequence again.

saintbrat · Post: # 1090236Post **saintbrat** » Tue 14 Jun 2011 9:39pm

Round 12
St. Kilda vs Western Bulldogs

10 Boyd (WB)

5 Steven (St K)

4 C Jones (St K)

3 Goddard (St K)

3 Fisher (St K)

2 Picken (WB)

2 Ray (St K)

1 Higgins (WB)

well done Jack and CJ

gringo · Post: # 1090323Post **gringo** » Wed 15 Jun 2011 10:01am

You realise how important Montagna is when you see that. He is a run and carry player that is really hard to replace. Gram and Peake probably have the same output combined. It is a hard ask against the cats without him. He has missed a few this year so along with Lenny and Dal Santo down back, it makes us either unpredictable or undermanned. Combine the need for Armo and Steven to get the same clearance rate as Lenny and we are no wonder struggling more than last.

borderbarry · Wed 15 Jun 2011 10:09am

Jack Steven and Clint Jones have both snuck in front of Nick Riewoldt now!

bergholt · Post: # 1090521Post **bergholt** » Wed 15 Jun 2011 11:18pm

barry makes a good point. riewoldt a long way down on this list now...

25 Leigh Montagna (votes in 3 games)
14 Sam Fisher (5)
11 Nick Dal Santo (4)
10 Brendon Goddard (2)
8 Clinton Jones (2)
7 Jack Steven (2)
6 Nick Riewoldt (1)
5 David Armitage (2), Lenny Hayes (1)
4 Sam Gilbert (1), James Gwilt (2), Stephen Milne (1), Adam Schneider (2)
3 Farren Ray (2)
2 Zac Dawson (1), Sean Dempster (1)
1 Jason Gram (1)

saintbrat · Tue 21 Jun 2011 12:44am

Dals still Polling

St. Kilda vs Geelong

10 Corey (Geel)

6 Chapman (Geel)

5 Dal Santo (St K)

5 Menzel (Geel)

3 Stokes (Geel)

1 Lonergan (Geel)

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ ... b2bf69238c

saintbrat · Post: # 1099715Post **saintbrat** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 7:52pm

another really wide spread this week

Round 15
North Melbourne vs St. Kilda

8 Dal Santo (St K)

5 Goddard (St K)

4 Peake (St K)

4 Riewoldt (St K)

3 Goldstein (NM)

2 Adams (NM)

2 Dawson (St K)

1 Gwilt (St K)

1 Wells (NM)

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ ... 0d50053df8

plugger66 · Post: # 1099719Post **plugger66** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 7:55pm

Looks like Dawson got 2 off RL. Another shocking defensive effort.

SainterK · Post: # 1099721Post **SainterK** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 7:57pm

For once I reckon that matches up to the general vibe of SS votes

#1GILL · Post: # 1099725Post **#1GILL** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 8:03pm

Weird for only 1 player to recieve votes from both coaching panels.

saintbrat · Post: # 1099734Post **saintbrat** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 8:12pm

comparison to media award- the one I can find
Age Footballer of the Year - Round 15 votes July 4, 2011

NORTH MELBOURNE v ST KILDA
Martin Blake
Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) 8
Jack Steven (St Kilda) 7
Todd Goldstein (North Melbourne) 7
Brendon Goddard (St Kilda) 7
Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda) 7

Read more: http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/a ... z1R7oifFrf

Old Mate · Post: # 1099742Post **Old Mate** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 8:23pm

I was surprised not to see McEvoy in the votes. 23 touches and 11 marks (5 contested).

desertsaint · Mon 04 Jul 2011 8:30pm

Old Mate wrote:I was surprised not to see McEvoy in the votes. 23 touches and 11 marks (5 contested).

well beaten in ruckwork - that's his job. good around the ground though.

noob · Post: # 1099749Post **noob** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 8:34pm

how can all players get over 7 votes? is it a new system to the 5-4-3-2-1?

saintbrat · Post: # 1099751Post **saintbrat** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 8:37pm

noob wrote:how can all players get over 7 votes? is it a new system to the 5-4-3-2-1?

thats the age votes- not the coaches votes.

coaches votes remain 5-1

perfectionist · Mon 04 Jul 2011 10:12pm

One coach gave Brendon 5 and the other gave him nil. One coach gave Brett Peake 4 and the other gave him nil, the same one who gave Nick Riewoldt 4 (while the other gave him nil). They did agree a bit more on Nick Dal Santo (5 & 3).

So it was:

5. Brendon Goddard
4. Nick Riewoldt
3. Nick Dal Santo
2. Zac Dawson
1. James Gwilt

AND

5. Nick Dal Santo
4. Brett Peake
3. Todd Goldstein
2. Leigh Adams
1. Daniel Wells

where the 4s, 2s and 1s could all swap.