Would you do it?

[Old Mate]

If they seriously wanted Fish, I'd say pick 2 & Tyson for Chips & pick 24.

Then pick 2, 13, 43 & a guarantee we wont go for Stevens if they are keen for Western Bullies for 5 & 6.

Give up Fisher, 13, 24 & 43
Receive Tyson, pick 5 & 6.

Its completely unrealistic but surely it makes you think about what could be if you were happy to entertain some out of left field trades!

Do you think Pelchen has nude photos of Sheedy and SOS doing naughty things to one another?

[stinger]

sos stated that they had offered a low first round pick for an established star but the club involved had turned the offer down..

....so someone did something...was it the saints and did it involve fish....who knows..???...not i.....

[felix]

by Old Mate » Thu 18 Oct 2012 4:42pm

St Ick wrote:
If they seriously wanted Fish, I'd say pick 2 & Tyson for Chips & pick 24.

Then pick 2, 13, 43 & a guarantee we wont go for Stevens if they are keen for Western Bullies for 5 & 6.

Give up Fisher, 13, 24 & 43
Receive Tyson, pick 5 & 6.

Its completely unrealistic but surely it makes you think about what could be if you were happy to entertain some out of left field trades!


Do you think Pelchen has nude photos of Sheedy and SOS doing naughty things to one another?


Ahhh that wouldn't be pretty

[Con Gorozidis]

Thats how long Pelchen would take to accept such an offer.

If it was offered from GWS to us for Fish we can only assume Sam said he didnt want to leave and that was that.

[SuperDuper]

I think someone over 30... you would think hard...
But we already are looking to bring in a key defender... that is why they will have rejected it
We would be scewed down back

[St Ick]

If they seriously wanted Fish, I'd say pick 2 & Tyson for Chips & pick 24.

Then pick 2, 13, 43 & a guarantee we wont go for Stevens if they are keen for Western Bullies for 5 & 6.

Give up Fisher, 13, 24 & 43
Receive Tyson, pick 5 & 6.

Its completely unrealistic but surely it makes you think about what could be if you were happy to entertain some out of left field trades!

Do you think Pelchen has nude photos of Sheedy and SOS doing naughty things to one another?

Not sure about Pelchen but Sammy Gilbert might have taken some! (still too soon??)

[Old Mate]

If they seriously wanted Fish, I'd say pick 2 & Tyson for Chips & pick 24.

Then pick 2, 13, 43 & a guarantee we wont go for Stevens if they are keen for Western Bullies for 5 & 6.

Give up Fisher, 13, 24 & 43
Receive Tyson, pick 5 & 6.

Its completely unrealistic but surely it makes you think about what could be if you were happy to entertain some out of left field trades!

Do you think Pelchen has nude photos of Sheedy and SOS doing naughty things to one another?

Not sure about Pelchen but Sammy Gilbert might have taken some! (still too soon??)

Not at all, love it!

[St Ick]

Its all just fallen into place for me. We have lost BJ and Fisher could leave (doubt it). The reprocussions (spelling?) of not getting a Caddy are only just starting to be felt... we don't have anyone else on the list keen on golf do we? If so, I'll put my hand up to carry the bags!

[plugger66]

Pick 2 for a 30 year old however good he is sounds like crap to me but if true the Saints certainly would have to think about it. The problem would be unless Chips got a huge wage increase I doubt he would want to go. Got his golf down here and all his racing contactts which will end up being his FT job I would think. Also getting rid of Chips as well as BJ wouldnt be fair on the oter older guys as they still would be thinking they could somehow win the GF. The club would obviously be thinking otherwise.

[Con Gorozidis]

I think someone over 30... you would think hard...
But we already are looking to bring in a key defender... that is why they will have rejected it
We would be scewed down back

They are looking at bringing in a defender because we dont have anyone to put on very large fwds. We could have 22 medium defenders and still have the same issue. So I reject that argument. With Gwilt, Dempster, Simpkin, Siposs and Gilbo we have 5 good medium sized defenders plus an emerging one in Ferguson making it 6. That is sufficient for that position. We will still recruit a big defender anyway. We can cover Fisher now.

[wally]

You'd reckon Sam would get a fair pay rise, he may be interested.
Who now wishes we traded Kosi when collingwood wanted him and were willing to pay?

[noob]

To be honest no one gets traded for #2 pick at the age of 30.

[plugger66]

To be honest no one gets traded for #2 pick at the age of 30.

And some think it isnt enough. It is nearly that much it should be done for sure. I still wouldnt do it though.

[saintbob]

No, but if Fish asked it would be a different matter.

But I'd put Roo up and see what they could come up with, then we may get 2, 5,6 and Dom Tyson!!

[mad saint guy]

You don't trade loyal star players who want to be at the club. Fisher is a gun, our best key defender and a fantastic leader to teach the next generation. Trading guys like him is how you ruin the morale of a club.

[Con Gorozidis]

You don't trade loyal star players who want to be at the club. Fisher is a gun, our best key defender and a fantastic leader to teach the next generation. Trading guys like him is how you ruin the morale of a club.

No one wants him traded...
I thought the post was - 'what if GWS offered us pick 2 and Sam said he wanted to go to get 2 final years on big coin?'

Its all hypothetical I think. In this (albeit unlikely) scenario - then I think wed agree and do the deal.

[Teflon]

Gee it's a bit like someone offering you 1m to sleep with your wife..... tough spot but sometimes you gotta take 1 for the team...

[plugger66]

As it looks like we will get Frawley then why not.

[CURLY]

Gee it's a bit like someone offering you 1m to sleep with your wife..... tough spot but sometimes you gotta take 1 for the team...

Cant see the tough desision to be honest.

[Dr Spaceman]

Gee it's a bit like someone offering you 1m to sleep with your wife..... tough spot but sometimes you gotta take 1 for the team...

I think I just won Powerball last night teffers.

Please PM piccy and I'll get back to you

[SaintPav]

Gee it's a bit like someone offering you 1m to sleep with your wife..... tough spot but sometimes you gotta take 1 for the team...

That comment says so much about you. You do come across as the type of bloke who would do anything for money and make his wife do that.

[bigcarl]

Since we're in total rebuild mode, why not throw Riewoldt, Dal and Lenny in with the deal. Throw them all out and start again.

No way.

[saintbrat]

I still hate October

[Dr Spaceman]

Since we're in total rebuild mode, why not throw Riewoldt, Dal and Lenny in with the deal. Throw them all out and start again.

No way.

Nick may be interested.

Is Sydney closer to Houston than Melbourne is?