Coaches Votes 2015

[saintbrat]

Armo has polled in 4 out of five weeks

Congrats David on a perfect 10 in Round 5
St Kilda v Essendon

10 – David Armitage (Stk)
7 – Josh Bruce (StK)
4 – Brendon Goddard (Ess)
4 – Brent Stanton (Ess)
3 – Jack Steven (StK)
1 – Sean Dempster (StK)
1 – Michael Hurley (Ess)


from rd 4 St Kilda v Carlton

8 – Patrick Cripps (Carl)

8 – Marc Murphy (Carl)

5 – Tom Bell (Carl)

4 – Lachie Henderson (Carl)

2 – Ed Curnow (Carl)

2 – Zach Tuohy (Carl)

1 – David Armitage (St K)


Round 3
Collingwood v St Kilda

10 – Dane Swan (Coll)

7 – Brodie Grundy (Coll)

7 – Scott Pendlebury (Coll)

4 – Travis Cloke (Coll)

1 – David Armitage (St K)

1 – Travis Varcoe (Coll)


Rd 2
Gold Coast Suns v St Kilda

9 – David Armitage (StK)

9 – Josh Bruce (StK)

5 – Sam Fisher (StK)

3 – Jack Steven (StK)

2 – Nick Riewoldt (StK)

1 – Jarryn Geary (StK)

1 – Shane Savage (StK)

Round 1
St. Kilda vs GWS
10 Shiel (GWS)
4 Geary (StK)
4 Steven (StK)
4 Treloar (GWS)
3 Whitfield (GWS)
2 Savage (StK)
2 Weller (StK)
1 McCarthy (GWS)

[skeptic]

Interesting that a week ago he was overrated and under performing...

see what difference a bit of support makes

[bergholt]

Thanks saintbrat. Here's the running total for Saints:

21: Armitage (4)
16: Bruce (2)
10: Steven (3)
5: Fisher, Geary (2)
3: Savage (2)
2: Riewoldt, Weller
1: Dempster

Personally I'm pretty happy with 6 of our 7 top vote getters, all of them except Fisher should still be around in a few years.

[saintbrat]

http://www.aflplayers.com.au/article/af ... s-round-6/
Armo up to second
WESTERN BULLDOGS V ST KILDA

10 – David Armitage (StK)

7 – Jack Billings (StK)

4 – Jack Steven (StK)

4 – Easton Wood (WB)

2 – Sam Fisher (StK)

2 – Liam Picken (WB)

1 – Jason Johannisen (WB)

[bergholt]

31: Armitage (5)
16: Bruce (2)
14: Steven (4)
7: Billings, Fisher (2)
5: Geary (2)
3: Savage (2)
2: Riewoldt, Weller
1: Dempster

Armo has votes in 5 out of 6 games. That's definitely a Lenny-like voting tally.

[saintbrat]

Round 7 Vs Crows
ADELAIDE CROWS V ST KILDA
10 – Eddie Betts (Adel)
6 – Josh Bruce (StK)
4 – David Mackay (Adel)
4 – Scott Thompson (Adel)
3 – Sam Jacobs (Adel)
2 – Rory Laird (Adel)
1 – David Armitage (StK)



Round 8 vs Eagles
ST KILDA V WEST COAST EAGLES
10 – Luke Shuey (WCE)
8 – Andrew Gaff (WCE)
5 – Matthew Priddis (WCE)
5 – Jack Steven (StK)
1 – Leigh Montagna (StK)
1 – Elliot Yeo (WCE)

[bergholt]

32: Armitage (6)
22: Bruce (3)
19: Steven (5)
7: Billings, Fisher (2)
5: Geary (2)
3: Savage (2)
2: Riewoldt, Weller
1: Dempster, Montagna

[saintbrat]

http://www.aflplayers.com.au/article/af ... s-round-9/
Brisbane vs StKilda
10 -David Armitage (StK)
7 – Dayne Beams (BL)
5 – Nick Riewoldt (StK)
3 – Adam Schneider (StK)
2 – Ryan Lester (BL)
2 – Stefan Martin (BL)
1 – Jack Newnes (StK)

[bergholt]

42: Armitage (7)
22: Bruce (3)
19: Steven (5)
7: Billings, Fisher (2), Riewoldt (2)
5: Geary (2)
3: Savage (2), Schneider
2: Weller
1: Dempster, Montagna, Newnes

[kosifantutti]

I know Geary had a couple of clangers, but this is a bit harsh.

KILDA V HAWTHORN
10 – Sam Mitchell (Haw)
8 – Jack Steven (StK)
6 – Billy Hartung (Haw)
2 – Jarryn Geary (Haw)
1 – Jack Gunston (Haw)
1 – Jarryd Roughead

http://www.aflplayers.com.au/article/af ... -round-10/

[karnaby]

2 votes are missing. I checked the link and they're not there either.

[bergholt]

42: Armitage (7)
27: Steven (6)
22: Bruce (3)
7: Billings, Fisher (2), Geary (3), Riewoldt (2)
3: Savage (2), Schneider
2: Weller
1: Dempster, Montagna, Newnes

[saintbrat]

Round 11

ST KILDA V MELBOURNE
10 – Bernie Vince (Melb)
8 – Leigh Montagna (StK)
5 – Jesse Hogan (Melb)
5 – Nick Riewoldt (StK)
2 – Sean Dempster (StK)

[plugger66]

Round 11

ST KILDA V MELBOURNE
10 – Bernie Vince (Melb)
8 – Leigh Montagna (StK)
5 – Jesse Hogan (Melb)
5 – Nick Riewoldt (StK)
2 – Sean Dempster (StK)

That's nearly as close as the coaches can vote. Never seen that before.

[bergholt]

42: Armitage (7)
27: Steven (6)
22: Bruce (3)
12: Riewoldt (3)
9: Montagna (2)
7: Billings, Fisher (2), Geary (3)
3: Dempster (2), Savage (2), Schneider
2: Weller
1: Montagna, Newnes

[saintbrat]

Rd 13
ST KILDA V WESTERN BULLDOGS
10 – Easton Wood (WB)

7 – Robert Murphy (WB)

4 – Sean Dempster (StK)

3 – Leigh Montagna (StK)

2 – Matthew Boyd (WB)

2 – Jack Newnes (StK)

1 – Jarryn Geary (StK)

1 – Nick Riewoldt (StK)

[bergholt]

42: Armitage (7)
27: Steven (6)
22: Bruce (3)
13: Riewoldt (4)
12: Montagna (3)
8: Geary (4)
7: Billings, Dempster (3), Fisher (2)
3: Newnes (2), Savage (2), Schneider
2: Weller
1: Montagna

[saintbrat]

Armo's back in the votes
ESSENDON V ST KILDA
10 – David Armitage (StK)

7 – Josh Bruce (StK)

6 – Jack Steven (StK)

3 – Sean Dempster (StK)

2 – Dyson Heppell (Ess)

1 – Leigh Montagna (StK)

1 – Dylan Roberton (StK)

http://www.aflplayers.com.au/article/af ... -round-14/

[bergholt]

52: Armitage (8)
33: Steven (7)
29: Bruce (4)
13: Riewoldt (4)
12: Montagna (3)
10: Dempster (4)
8: Geary (4)
7: Billings, Fisher (2)
3: Newnes (2), Savage (2), Schneider
2: Montagna (2), Weller
1: Roberton

[saintbrat]

http://www.aflplayers.com.au/article/af ... -round-15/
GWS GIANTS V ST KILDA
9 – Jeremy Cameron (GWS)

9 – Callan Ward (GWS)

5 – Heath Shaw (GWS)

3 – Leigh Montagna (StK)

2 – Jack Steven (StK)

1 – Stephen Coniglio (GWS)

1 – Adam Treloar (GWS)

[bergholt]

52: Armitage (8)
35: Steven (8)
29: Bruce (4)
15: Montagna (4)
13: Riewoldt (4)
10: Dempster (4)
8: Geary (4)
7: Billings, Fisher (2)
3: Newnes (2), Savage (2), Schneider
2: Montagna (2), Weller
1: Roberton

[mad saint guy]

Interesting that Roberton has just the one vote when he's almost certainly top 5 in our B&F

[bergholt]

Interesting that Roberton has just the one vote when he's almost certainly top 5 in our B&F

I would say top 5 in our B&F is basically the same as top 5 in the coaches votes: Steven, Armo, Joey, Rooey, Bruce. Which would Robbo displace?

[plugger66]

Interesting that Roberton has just the one vote when he's almost certainly top 5 in our B&F

I would say top 5 in our B&F is basically the same as top 5 in the coaches votes: Steven, Armo, Joey, Rooey, Bruce. Which would Robbo displace?

Depends on the voting structure. I know that how it was voted when it was just about everyone voting, missing more than about 2 games meant you were stuffed. Cant remember the voting system last year. I know they didn't get as many votes as previously so missing games may not matter as much.

[mad saint guy]

Interesting that Roberton has just the one vote when he's almost certainly top 5 in our B&F

I would say top 5 in our B&F is basically the same as top 5 in the coaches votes: Steven, Armo, Joey, Rooey, Bruce. Which would Robbo displace?

I think Roo has missed too much footy to be in the top 5 of the B&F. Missed 4 full games and was out early in another, effectively 5 games behind Robbo. Same goes for Joey actually, only played 9 of a possible 14 games.