Team v Swans

[Dr Spaceman]

I don't like the dropping of Membrey.

ST KILDA v SYDNEY SWANS
ES , 3:20pm AEST Sunday, August 30, 2015

IN
Sean Dempster, Dylan Roberton, Adam Schneider, David Armitage, Tom Simpkin
OUT
Tim Membrey (Shoulder), Cameron Shenton (Omitted)
MILESTONES: Jason Holmes - Played 1st game

IN
Gary Rohan, Lance Franklin, Tom Mitchell
MILESTONES: Ted Richards - Playing 250th game, James Rose - Played 1st game

Cheers

No probs. I agree I see him as a big part of our future

[Junction Oval]

Simpkin has been a real tough nut, but not quite skilled enough. This could be his last game. I wish him well.

[matrix]

agree JO
times ive seen him play he goes in harda as hell and loves that type of stuff, busts his ass
yet i think its the disposal that lets him down

i reckon his papers are stamped

[HitTheBoundary]

From what I saw Simpkin played quite a bit of last weeks Sandy game on ball/tagging.

Could they use him as a tagger against Kennedy?
Or doesn't he have the tank?

[plugger66]

From what I saw Simpkin played quite a bit of last weeks Sandy game on ball/tagging.

Could they use him as a tagger against Kennedy?
Or doesn't he have the tank?

I think Kennedy would have a better tank and also be to smart for Tom. That is nothing against him but he hasn't ever really played as a tagger in AFL footy and its a huge ask to put him on a player like Kennedy. I doubt he is much chance of playing to be honest.

[kosifantutti]

@AFL_PKeane: St Kilda v Sydney Swans;
Interchange; Savage, Dunstan, Armitage, Murdoch.
Emergencies; Ray, Simpkin, Saunders.

[kosifantutti]

@AFL_PKeane: St Kilda v Syd Swans changes;
Schneider, Dempster, Armitage, Roberton in for Ray, Shenton, Membrey, Saunders.

[The Fireman]

Not sure about everyone else here but I would like to know why McCartin isn't playing should we start getting worried ?

[SemperFidelis]

Not sure about everyone else here but I would like to know why McCartin isn't playing should we start getting worried ?

How many games do you need to play at Sandy to be eligible to play finals?

[bergholt]

Not sure about everyone else here but I would like to know why McCartin isn't playing should we start getting worried ?

Nothing to gain and everything to lose in the last few round. An injury to spoil his pre season would be pretty bad.

[tony74]

Not sure about everyone else here but I would like to know why McCartin isn't playing should we start getting worried ?

Absolutely not. Most of the young boys are pretty spent. Be surprised if Dmac plays for Sandy as well. Hadn't passed his concussion test as of Tuesday.

[saynta]

Not sure about everyone else here but I would like to know why McCartin isn't playing should we start getting worried ?

Like White, he must have got injured last week.

[The Fireman]

Cool so nothing to worry about ........ok

[plugger66]

Not sure about everyone else here but I would like to know why McCartin isn't playing should we start getting worried ?

Absolutely not. Most of the young boys are pretty spent. Be surprised if Dmac plays for Sandy as well. Hadn't passed his concussion test as of Tuesday.

Thanks for that. What about SW? Still the best you have seen?

[tony74]

Not sure about everyone else here but I would like to know why McCartin isn't playing should we start getting worried ?

Absolutely not. Most of the young boys are pretty spent. Be surprised if Dmac plays for Sandy as well. Hadn't passed his concussion test as of Tuesday.

Thanks for that. What about SW? Still the best you have seen?

Geez, not much love.

[HitTheBoundary]

Not sure about everyone else here but I would like to know why McCartin isn't playing should we start getting worried ?

Absolutely not. Most of the young boys are pretty spent. Be surprised if Dmac plays for Sandy as well. Hadn't passed his concussion test as of Tuesday.

How long since he was concussed? Is that from the game two weeks ago?
Seems a bit of a worry.

[tony74]

Not sure about everyone else here but I would like to know why McCartin isn't playing should we start getting worried ?

Absolutely not. Most of the young boys are pretty spent. Be surprised if Dmac plays for Sandy as well. Hadn't passed his concussion test as of Tuesday.

How long since he was concussed? Is that from the game two weeks ago?
Seems a bit of a worry.

Yep. Has a real history of migraines. Reckon he will be really important in the coming years.

[elizabethr]

Why is Armo named on bench
Seems insulting considering the season he has had ??

[#gosaintas]

They should play Simpkin over Geary

[plugger66]

They should play Simpkin over Geary

NO they shouldn't. All that shows is your bias doesn't allow you to watch players and see how dood or bad they are. Pity.

[saintspremiers]

Not sure about everyone else here but I would like to know why McCartin isn't playing should we start getting worried ?

Absolutely not. Most of the young boys are pretty spent. Be surprised if Dmac plays for Sandy as well. Hadn't passed his concussion test as of Tuesday.

How long since he was concussed? Is that from the game two weeks ago?
Seems a bit of a worry.

Yep. Has a real history of migraines. Reckon he will be really important in the coming years.

Are migraines related to concussions at all?

[bergholt]

They should play Simpkin over Geary

Completely different positions, surely?

[saintbrat]

Ray would appear to be the game day emergency, cant see the other 2 at training which would indicate they are at Sandy
But half the team have hoodies on

[The Disch]

I don't like the dropping of Membrey.

ST KILDA v SYDNEY SWANS
ES , 3:20pm AEST Sunday, August 30, 2015

IN
Sean Dempster, Dylan Roberton, Adam Schneider, David Armitage, Tom Simpkin
OUT
Tim Membrey (Shoulder), Cameron Shenton (Omitted)
MILESTONES: Jason Holmes - Played 1st game

IN
Gary Rohan, Lance Franklin, Tom Mitchell
MILESTONES: Ted Richards - Playing 250th game, James Rose - Played 1st game

Hope it isn't ink poisoning

Cheers

No probs. I agree I see him as a big part of our future

[jamesmc]

Not sure about everyone else here but I would like to know why McCartin isn't playing should we start getting worried ?

Absolutely not. Most of the young boys are pretty spent. Be surprised if Dmac plays for Sandy as well. Hadn't passed his concussion test as of Tuesday.

Thanks for that. What about SW? Still the best you have seen?

Geez, not much love.

Some one just let a bit of air out of your tyres Tony, stop coming on here to get your jollies mate.
Throwing out your little teasers.
Full of s***. Who ever t f you are.