Votes - Saints v Syd

[SemperFidelis]

Too soon?

Umpire Nicholls: - 1

[SemperFidelis]

5. Seb
4. Armo
3. BLacres
2. DMac
1. Joey

Wrighty's goal deserved its own vote.

[Scollop]

5 Acres
4 Armo
3 Joey
2 DMac
1 Hick

[Bluthy]

5 Armo - still far from his best which is a worry but worked his arse off inside trying to cover for Dunstan
4 Ross - wasn't as damaging as I would have liked but with Steven given no room he twas our main play making mid
3 Roo - 24 disposals, 6 marks, a goal - is thriving in his wing/midfield role - made some errors but who didn't
2 Blacres - ran hot in the first half. But as he's done a few times he seems to run out of gas until he got a second wind in the last quarter. Heres hoping he can become a 4 qtr player because then he'll be a genuine force
1 Weller - tried hard all night and tried to be physical to hurt the big swans players

[George27]

5. Joey
4. Acres
3. Armo
2. Roo
1. Seb

[bergsone]

5 Roo
4 Acres
3 joey
2Hickey
1 Ross

[saintbob]

5 Acres
4 Ross
3 Newnes
2 Weller
1 Riewoldt

[lintonstreet]

5 Roo
4 Mav
3 Armo
2 Acres
1 Newnes

[Con Gorozidis]

5 Armo - still far from his best which is a worry but worked his arse off inside trying to cover for Dunstan
4 Ross - wasn't as damaging as I would have liked but with Steven given no room he twas our main play making mid
3 Roo - 24 disposals, 6 marks, a goal - is thriving in his wing/midfield role - made some errors but who didn't
2 Blacres - ran hot in the first half. But as he's done a few times he seems to run out of gas until he got a second wind in the last quarter. Heres hoping he can become a 4 qtr player because then he'll be a genuine force
1 Weller - tried hard all night and tried to be physical to hurt the big swans players

Will take Acres a couple more pre-seasons to build a tank capable of moving that massive frame around.
But when he is 22-23. Look out.

[borderbarry]

5. Armo
4, Acres
3. Joey
2. Roo
1. Newnes

[lintonstreet]

Can someone please explain what I missed with Joey?
I was at the game and his defensive pressure was very poor as was a lot of his decision making (which is normally his strength).
I couldn't see him in our best 10 last night.
What did I miss?

[8856brother]

5 Acres
4 Seb
3 Armo
1 Roo
1 Hickey
1 Joey

3 average games on the trot for Jack may cost him AA selection. Big couple of weeks coming up for him.

Sent from my SM-T210 using Tapatalk

[The Fireman]

Ross
Gilbo
Armo
Roberton
Acres
Newnes

[saynta]

5. Ross
4. Acres
3. Gilbert
2. Joey
1. Roo.

[freely]

Hickey
Acres
Armitage
Ross
Montagna

[elizabethr]

Armo
Acres
Newnes
Gilbo
Mav

[Bernard Shakey]

Blacres
Seb
Newnes
Armo
Joey

[avid]

4 Acres
3 Montagna
3 Armo
2 Riewoldt
1 Newnes
1 Hickey
1 Gilbo

Sorry Sainter Dad -- I've been one of your loyalest 54321 sticklers -- but now I've caught '=15' the bug.

[kosifantutti]

Acres
Armitage
Ross
Riewoldt
Montagna

[MCG-Unit]

4 - Armitage
3 - Riewoldt
3 - Acres
3 - Montagna
2 - Ross

0 - Umpires

[Scollop]

Can someone please explain what I missed with Joey?
I was at the game and his defensive pressure was very poor as was a lot of his decision making (which is normally his strength).
I couldn't see him in our best 10 last night.
What did I miss?

Have another look. You couldn't fault the efort of Tom, or Dave or Jade or Seb Ross, Mav, Robbo, Newnes or Joey. I reckon even Gilbo was servicable

Before I watch the replay I usually vote with my heart and not my head. I have my favourite players that I'll be lenient on and then I'm usually harsher on a few of the older guys like Roo and Dempster and Joey. I didn't think Steven was in the best 10 either but when I watched the replay I could've easily changed my votes. He worked his arse off in the game as did most of the boys.

[Sainter_Dad]

64 Acres
51 Armitage
40 Ross
27 Montagna
27 Riewoldt
12 Newnes
10 Gilbert
10 Hickey
8 Weller
4 McKenzie
2 Roberton

Therefore:
5 Acres
4 Armitage
3 Ross
1.5 Montagna
1.5 Riewoldt