The free against Carlisle

[CURLY]

We have witnessed a new level of cheating. Takes a mark goes to kick then the umpire that continually cheats calls play on. Pins him for holding the ball.

Then to show us he is a complete cheat pins him for abuse and a double goal.

Blatant cheating and the umpire has history.

[saintkev]

Can Carlisle go on and be an inspirational match winner or will he revert to sulking?

[barneyboyz]

Can Carlisle go on and be an inspirational match winner or will he revert to sulking?

I actually reckon he was better after that free. Even Sideshow Bob thought it was funny

[St Lenny]

Disgusting umpiring, can't believe people would question him being pissed off.

[saintsRrising]

Should more likely have been a 50m to Carlisle for having the ball knocked out of his hands.

[Spinner]

Terrible decision.

Carlisle smashes brown in the end. Made up for the additional free.

[sunsaint]

Carlisle gets the ball
plays on to kick the ball
umpire calls play on
Carlisle slips over and gets tackled - doesnt attempt to get rid of it
gets pinged
so far cant see any umpire cheating

Carrying on like an idiot and being asked to stop swearing twice is entirely on carlisle

[B.M]

That’s not how it happened

[CURLY]

Carlisle gets the ball
plays on to kick the ball
umpire calls play on
Carlisle slips over and gets tackled - doesnt attempt to get rid of it
gets pinged
so far cant see any umpire cheating

Carrying on like an idiot and being asked to stop swearing twice is entirely on carlisle

Complete bulls***.

[CURLY]

Carlisle gets the ball
plays on to kick the ball
umpire calls play on
Carlisle slips over and gets tackled - doesnt attempt to get rid of it
gets pinged
so far cant see any umpire cheating

Carrying on like an idiot and being asked to stop swearing twice is entirely on carlisle

Complete bulls***.

[kosifantutti]

Carlisle gets the ball
plays on to kick the ball
umpire calls play on
Carlisle slips over and gets tackled - doesnt attempt to get rid of it
gets pinged
so far cant see any umpire cheating

Carrying on like an idiot and being asked to stop swearing twice is entirely on carlisle

Your first and last lines are correct. The rest is totally wrong IMHO.

He slipped but hadn’t moved off his mark. The tackle was high and caused the ball to spill. I thought when he blew the whistle a second time he was making up for his first mistake, but he was just doubling down.

[Devilhead]

Carlisle gets the ball
plays on to kick the ball
umpire calls play on
Carlisle slips over and gets tackled - doesnt attempt to get rid of it
gets pinged
so far cant see any umpire cheating

Carrying on like an idiot and being asked to stop swearing twice is entirely on carlisle

He went to take a step forward to kick it and slipped - never went over the mark or sideways then Cunnington knocked the ball out his hands when he came in to tackle

Ump was looking to give the free and couldn't blow his whistle quick enough

[kosifantutti]

Different incident but if you have the ball and take on the tackler, the tackle sticks and the ball spills out. That would be holding the ball wouldn’t it?

Apparently not if you’re Jack Ziebell and you cause your opponent to miss 20 minutes of the game.

[saint6709]

He looked to go and slipped BUT DId NOT GO OVER THE MARK - slipping is not an offence - then Cunnington took him high - look at the still shot if you have not seen it - it’s on here or big footy somewhere

Then giving a free 20 metres out for back chat — how often has that actually happened in the history of the game at afl level ??