What has happened to the development of......
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
-
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 4243
- Joined: Thu 25 Mar 2004 2:47pm
- Location: incarnate
- Has thanked: 286 times
- Been thanked: 694 times
This is why Sam Gilbert sticks out like a sore thumb as a young recruit who has actually developed into a really good player....
he should be among a group of 5 or 6 good young players instead of being a lone soldier....
have a look at the development of West Coast...(or even Collingwood, Brisbane and Port...)....they seemed to be introducing another young gun every month or so...they have so much midfield depth because of this good development.
Most dissapointed in Mini who was a better player in his first year then he appears now...I remember thinking we had another Burkie when i first saw him.
he should be among a group of 5 or 6 good young players instead of being a lone soldier....
have a look at the development of West Coast...(or even Collingwood, Brisbane and Port...)....they seemed to be introducing another young gun every month or so...they have so much midfield depth because of this good development.
Most dissapointed in Mini who was a better player in his first year then he appears now...I remember thinking we had another Burkie when i first saw him.
Nee!
The interesting thing to mind is that I thought GTs biggest downfall was the continous selection of Blake, Thommo, Powell, Pecket, Fiora etc last year over the younger guys. In particular Fergusson and Mini however under the new administration the same names are basically going around, Blake hasnt missed a game or Fiora. Thommo has had a crack at least 50% of games and has been a revolving door with X Harvey and balls injuries. Mini Armo and Raph have had short goes at it and Fergusson still no games?
The question is then is it poor selection or do these guys not do enough to sell themselves as ready for senior footy? I dont feel like Ross Lyon has changed anything really, he has introduced 2 or 3 hard tags a week and accountability which has seen us reduce our points scored dramatically but end up in the same boat as last year. Hoping to scrape into finals.
Dont know that GT was the man for the job, but not sure that RL using this game plan is going to prove the right formula either. We have built a list around forwards, surely our game plan must suit that strength?
The question is then is it poor selection or do these guys not do enough to sell themselves as ready for senior footy? I dont feel like Ross Lyon has changed anything really, he has introduced 2 or 3 hard tags a week and accountability which has seen us reduce our points scored dramatically but end up in the same boat as last year. Hoping to scrape into finals.
Dont know that GT was the man for the job, but not sure that RL using this game plan is going to prove the right formula either. We have built a list around forwards, surely our game plan must suit that strength?
Maybe this year?
- Winmarvellous
- Club Player
- Posts: 1691
- Joined: Mon 25 Sep 2006 8:13pm
- Location: WA
Let's not forget Watts and Brooks were both at other clubs before joining the Saints, so we aren't the only club to get nothing out of them (I think, I've been drinking so excuse me if I'm wrong). Our talls aren't the problem at the moment, so even if they can play, they just jumped on the wrong boat. Look at WC midfield. They put each other under pressure, whereas our forwards are considered guns (G & Roo). Maybe there is room for a third option, but Ross prefers little tackilers to keep the ball in, so I think both have lost their chance (although Watts will be kept),
- Spinner
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 8502
- Joined: Sat 02 Dec 2006 3:40pm
- Location: Victoria
- Has thanked: 185 times
- Been thanked: 133 times
Great Post st.mart!!!!
But i really do think people need to relax. We have been a finals team for the last 3 years. That always means that there are going to be less opportunities for younger guys to strut their stuff.
Timing is everything. All of the above would be senior players at Carlton by now....But it just works differently while any club is successful.
There is talent there. No doubt. Hopefully we hold our nerve and these blokes have long lasting careers!!
But i really do think people need to relax. We have been a finals team for the last 3 years. That always means that there are going to be less opportunities for younger guys to strut their stuff.
Timing is everything. All of the above would be senior players at Carlton by now....But it just works differently while any club is successful.
There is talent there. No doubt. Hopefully we hold our nerve and these blokes have long lasting careers!!
- BAM! (shhhh)
- SS Hall of Fame
- Posts: 2134
- Joined: Thu 24 May 2007 5:23pm
- Location: The little voice inside your head
Perhaps he seems a lone soldier because he hasn't been around very long and is now a regular...fugazi wrote:This is why Sam Gilbert sticks out like a sore thumb as a young recruit who has actually developed into a really good player....
he should be among a group of 5 or 6 good young players instead of being a lone soldier....
BUT
This year has also seen the rise of Leigh Montagna from 2nd tier player to core player (a prime example of patient development), and the development of Jayden Attard from reclamation to regular if unspectacular player.
Last year saw a similar rise from Brendan Goddard, saw Sam Fisher back up a strong finish to 2005 by cementing a spot as a rebounding machine, and saw the return of Leigh Fisher to back up GTs assessment that he'd been a "best 22" calibre player in spite of injuries.
2007 has also seen the blooding of Armitage (might be nice to have more than 3 games, but if the skills aren't there, throwing an 18 year old body to the wolves can do as much harm as good - look at Kennedy for Carlton, who has good - but not elite - skills, and plays intimidated. One could argue that Armitage is well placed to be another Gilbert.), significant game time for Gwilt, and Birss, and 5 games for overage rookie Clinton Jones. 2 games for Howard, 1 for Sweeney.
Factor in as well that the Saints have gotten 15 games from X and 17 from Kosi, who they haven't been able to regularly put on the park for a while, and this year has seen some significant list development.
We may not be blooding 30 possession midfielders ala West Coast, but lets keep in mind that Rosa is a 3rd year player, and not the overnight success he may seem. Priddis is a 22 year old rookie. Without taking away from either being excellent finds, both are playing at Subi sourounded by silk, a possession paradise. More importantly: they have not clearly made the Eagles being a stronger team this year.
"Everything comes to he who hustles while he waits"
- Henry Ford
- Henry Ford
-
- SS Hall of Fame
- Posts: 2190
- Joined: Sun 28 Mar 2004 1:59pm
- Location: by the seaside..
- Has thanked: 36 times
- Been thanked: 187 times
IMHO ..
Brooks - one thing they never tested for was heart. If they had, we never would have drafted him. Undeniably has talent but will never blossom at AFL level. Probably gets another year under RL because M Clarke wont go on, Rix is the opposite of Brooks (big heart but no talent) and Gardner is too injury prone. He could be another option for FF after Frase goes. How many years did Tim Elliott spend on the list before he got cut ? .. big guys get given opportunities that others dont. No wonder RL is losing his hair.
Ferguson - cruelled by injury - cant see him breaking into lineup next year either. Not tall enough to be a tall, not quick enough to be a small. Let him go.
Raph: worth a punt under the new fitness regime - has talent. GT clealry never got the right fitness team or regime in place (for whatever reason). Keep.
Watts - is he our FF after Frase ? Seems like he can take a mark and kick a goal, may blossom given game time at FF and an injury free run.
McQualter - Get super fit or get out. Needs to take a leaf out of Baker's book.
Armo - too early to call ..(what did Gilbo do in his first year ?). Lets see what he fronts up like in Round 1 next year - plenty of room in our midfield rotations for him if he gets himself fit.
Brooks - one thing they never tested for was heart. If they had, we never would have drafted him. Undeniably has talent but will never blossom at AFL level. Probably gets another year under RL because M Clarke wont go on, Rix is the opposite of Brooks (big heart but no talent) and Gardner is too injury prone. He could be another option for FF after Frase goes. How many years did Tim Elliott spend on the list before he got cut ? .. big guys get given opportunities that others dont. No wonder RL is losing his hair.
Ferguson - cruelled by injury - cant see him breaking into lineup next year either. Not tall enough to be a tall, not quick enough to be a small. Let him go.
Raph: worth a punt under the new fitness regime - has talent. GT clealry never got the right fitness team or regime in place (for whatever reason). Keep.
Watts - is he our FF after Frase ? Seems like he can take a mark and kick a goal, may blossom given game time at FF and an injury free run.
McQualter - Get super fit or get out. Needs to take a leaf out of Baker's book.
Armo - too early to call ..(what did Gilbo do in his first year ?). Lets see what he fronts up like in Round 1 next year - plenty of room in our midfield rotations for him if he gets himself fit.
- saintsRrising
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 30092
- Joined: Mon 15 Mar 2004 11:07am
- Location: Melbourne
- Has thanked: 711 times
- Been thanked: 1234 times
Well the new "thinner" and more "willing to adopt the coaches given roles" Mini is now thriving once again. Once not too kken on tagging...he is now doing well in that role when given the challenge. He shut down Mitchell beautifully.
Our less muscle bound players can now run out games and overun opposition teams with strong finishes....and yes the once pleantiful hammys are now a lot lot less frequent.
Our less muscle bound players can now run out games and overun opposition teams with strong finishes....and yes the once pleantiful hammys are now a lot lot less frequent.
Flying the World in comfort thanks to FF Points....
really interesting subject to look over nowst.mart wrote:That is my point with Ferg, Solar.......he is 2 inches and 10kg lighter than those players, why would he be a back up to them - he is set up to fail (like the prelim in 2005, playing on McGregor)......he is not getting a game as a key back, because he is not a Key Back.......
He should be a back up to (or in front of) L.Fisher, X, Raph, Voss, Goddard, Blake....as a medium utility....played on players a similar size or smaller, his marking would be a bonus, rather than basis of his game...
mini has rebuilt his career and is the big success right now. Has learnt how to run with and stop players now. Might never be in the class of a top form baker as a stopper but has the ability to hurt on the rebound.
we have had a great habit of destroying careers by playing players out of position but perhaps the mini story puts a different bent to this. Perhaps fergi never got a chance down forward not only because of the situation of our huge amount of key forwards but his lack of finishing. Had a chance to nail a HF lead up role and missed too many goals. That might be it.
Raph and X seem to just not have their heats in it right now. Have all the talent in the world but need to head back home and be with their family.
just looking at a similar list nearing august a year later
(brooks, watts already gone)
So of the earlier list, mini and armo are starting to become dependable first 22 players.
So I would change that list to, where are these players at:
1) Fergusson. Had some early season form down forward against weaker VFL teams. Came in against melbourne but missed too many chances. If he had not dropped his head and continued this form in the VFL he would have a spot by now. Will get the chop, shame because he could have been a beauty. The arguement will always be that he was 3-4 inches too short for this level.
2) raph clarke. I was happy with his early season form, showed that he could use his body well in important contests and wanted to run the lines to create (this was in a team that was scared to run and create at the time). Perhaps was a scape goat at the time because of a few bad errors that ended up costing a game. Since his fathers illness he just doesn't look like he wants to be out there from the reports. Postitives are that he continues to play and keep his body in good condition. Next year is make or break for the kid. Might be better for club and player to be traded.
3) L.Fisher. Lost a yard of pace, well the game has gained a yard and poor leigh was never a racehorse. Shame because he was such a good news story gettng drafted like he did and then coming back from a career ending hamstring. Will make a good career in the SAFL.
4) Rix. Suprised his name got bought up this week, is a good honest VFL standard ruckman. Gave good service but these days you need a ruckman that can create goals from either their taps or around the ground works.
5.) baker. Knee and suspensions mean that we might never see the best of baker again. Depending on how his knee goes in the next month and how attard comes along a decision might need to be made. ? mark over his head.
6) A week ago I would have had fizz in here. Thought his career was gone. Has done what the likes of fergi has not done, that is lift again and make a statement in the lower levels. Could still make the cut.
7) Howard. Personally I think is development has been good at the lower level and the club sees him as a longer term developing player. The fact that geary, eddy and CJ have developed so quickly means that we could afford to keep developing him for the rest of the year. But if he doesn't crack eniors by half way through next year the pressure on his spot will me massive.
8) gwilt. Started to show good things before his brain fades against the blues. Will be an interesting next 6 weeks to see if he can make a come back again. Spot open in the backline, which would release BJ. Gwilt needs to demand that spot again.
9) charlie gardiner. Was given a one year contract. Will be interesting to see if he gets a game this week with kosi out. If not he might struggle to get another contract. Is in front of fergi currently and survives the cut IMO
My guesses for who will be cut
Harvey (retired, thanks banger)
Gehrig (retired)
fergi
leigh fisher
rix
one from left field
baker retires or delisting of attard
trades
raph
fish
baker
FQF
loyal in the good times and bad
In richo I trust
2013 trade/draft best ever?
Billings - future brownlow medallist Longer - future best ruck
Dunstan - future captain Eli - future cult hero
Acres - future norm smith
loyal in the good times and bad
In richo I trust
2013 trade/draft best ever?
Billings - future brownlow medallist Longer - future best ruck
Dunstan - future captain Eli - future cult hero
Acres - future norm smith
- WinnersOnly
- SS Life Member
- Posts: 3059
- Joined: Wed 10 Mar 2004 10:24pm
- Location: Canberra
Charlie GARDINER
Why cant we try Charlie across the HBF ? Why has he been pidgeon holed as a forward only. He strikes me as the sort of player who would fluriush playing the GODDARD role down back....
SAINTS another day older another day closer to the Holy Grail!
-
- Club Player
- Posts: 789
- Joined: Thu 25 Mar 2004 9:37pm
-
- SS Hall of Fame
- Posts: 2295
- Joined: Sun 27 Jan 2008 9:05am
- Has thanked: 769 times
- Been thanked: 207 times
Re: Charlie GARDINER
doesn't seem to be the creative type. His biggest strength is his ability to gut run to lead into space. Thus he is able to get into space and take easy marks. But doesn't have the creative flair to be able to make more of it and his kicking for goal is terrible.WinnersOnly wrote:Why cant we try Charlie across the HBF ? Why has he been pidgeon holed as a forward only. He strikes me as the sort of player who would fluriush playing the GODDARD role down back....
FQF
loyal in the good times and bad
In richo I trust
2013 trade/draft best ever?
Billings - future brownlow medallist Longer - future best ruck
Dunstan - future captain Eli - future cult hero
Acres - future norm smith
loyal in the good times and bad
In richo I trust
2013 trade/draft best ever?
Billings - future brownlow medallist Longer - future best ruck
Dunstan - future captain Eli - future cult hero
Acres - future norm smith
- Otiman
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 8627
- Joined: Thu 28 Jul 2005 11:09pm
- Location: Elsewhere
- Has thanked: 197 times
- Been thanked: 620 times
Gwilt may have to go at seasons end. We NEED the space.
For example, even if Harvey and Gehrig retire, we need 3 spots on the list for national draft players, and probably 2 for elevated rookies in McQualter and Eddy. More if we want to keep Attard and Miles by elevating them. I don't know if Miles is eligible for a 2 year rookie spot.
Out: Harvey, Gehrig, and three from (Rix, Gwilt, Fisher, Ferguson, C. Gardiner)
In: Round 1, Round 2, Round 3, Eddy, McQualter
For example, even if Harvey and Gehrig retire, we need 3 spots on the list for national draft players, and probably 2 for elevated rookies in McQualter and Eddy. More if we want to keep Attard and Miles by elevating them. I don't know if Miles is eligible for a 2 year rookie spot.
Out: Harvey, Gehrig, and three from (Rix, Gwilt, Fisher, Ferguson, C. Gardiner)
In: Round 1, Round 2, Round 3, Eddy, McQualter
- BAM! (shhhh)
- SS Hall of Fame
- Posts: 2134
- Joined: Thu 24 May 2007 5:23pm
- Location: The little voice inside your head
Still think Fiora's career is all but done with St Kilda. He has another year on his contract though, so maybe one more year.Otiman wrote:Gwilt may have to go at seasons end. We NEED the space.
For example, even if Harvey and Gehrig retire, we need 3 spots on the list for national draft players, and probably 2 for elevated rookies in McQualter and Eddy. More if we want to keep Attard and Miles by elevating them. I don't know if Miles is eligible for a 2 year rookie spot.
Out: Harvey, Gehrig, and three from (Rix, Gwilt, Fisher, Ferguson, C. Gardiner)
In: Round 1, Round 2, Round 3, Eddy, McQualter
If he finishes the year strongly and has a good finals campaign, he may be able to get a chance elsewhere, either via PSD, or (if we're lucky) for a low draft pick. Leigh Fisher may be in the same boat, though the injury status of Baker may save him another year as Attard will spend another year on the rookie list, and I'd guess we'd be expecting Mini to develop beyond the pure tagging at some stage.
Gwilt I would guess is safe for the time being as the insurance policy on our key defenders to get him through this offseason. Gardiner, Ferguson and Rix would all have much more to worry about.
The other one I wonder about is Michael Gardiner. He's played 8 of 16 so far, and is questionable for this week.
"Everything comes to he who hustles while he waits"
- Henry Ford
- Henry Ford
- saintsRrising
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 30092
- Joined: Mon 15 Mar 2004 11:07am
- Location: Melbourne
- Has thanked: 711 times
- Been thanked: 1234 times
Though we assume is fit enough to play since he is in Perth, even if he does not make the final 22.BAM! (shhhh) wrote: and is questionable for this week.
With him and King both having stayed a bit injury prone I would very much want to keep both on the list next year, and indeed the year after two.
With Gardi I would have hopes that next year he would be less injury effected as he now has both foot operations out of the way.
Also I think ruckman ted to be an injury prone lot anyway...so you want more than two.
So till the end of 2010 I think it is good to have on the books..:
King, Gardi and Ben
with Kosi and Blake to play cameos/ No2..
By 2011 hopefully Ben will be hitting his straps witha mature body.
Flying the World in comfort thanks to FF Points....
- skeptic
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 16967
- Joined: Wed 10 Mar 2004 7:10pm
- Has thanked: 3612 times
- Been thanked: 2886 times
i'd hang onto Gwilt
would lose Rix, Fiora and Ferguson (on top of Harvey and Gehrig)
off the record I'd really shop X around and would snap up a 2nd rounder if I could get one (Gold Coast any1)
so 5-6 players out
onto the senior list comes Eddy, McQualter and Miles
that leaves us room to draft 3
pbly spells the end of Luke V'R too
would lose Rix, Fiora and Ferguson (on top of Harvey and Gehrig)
off the record I'd really shop X around and would snap up a 2nd rounder if I could get one (Gold Coast any1)
so 5-6 players out
onto the senior list comes Eddy, McQualter and Miles
that leaves us room to draft 3
pbly spells the end of Luke V'R too
Based on what? One practice games and 2 reserves games. By the way did you see those games? Talk about rose coloured glasses could probably be the best medium defender in the comp.Otiman wrote:While I like Miles, I think perhaps his interrupted '08 may keep him from gaining a spot on our list. Would play a half back role perfectly, and could probably be the best medium defender in the comp.skeptic wrote:onto the senior list comes Eddy, McQualter and Miles
oh no I agree with plugger66...
He can sit on the rookie list for another year, yes the coach rates him and thus he will get a second year.
fizz will survive through a contract next year. Next 6 weeks will see how he is looked at going into '09
He can sit on the rookie list for another year, yes the coach rates him and thus he will get a second year.
fizz will survive through a contract next year. Next 6 weeks will see how he is looked at going into '09
FQF
loyal in the good times and bad
In richo I trust
2013 trade/draft best ever?
Billings - future brownlow medallist Longer - future best ruck
Dunstan - future captain Eli - future cult hero
Acres - future norm smith
loyal in the good times and bad
In richo I trust
2013 trade/draft best ever?
Billings - future brownlow medallist Longer - future best ruck
Dunstan - future captain Eli - future cult hero
Acres - future norm smith
- Animal Enclosure
- SS Hall of Fame
- Posts: 2364
- Joined: Mon 04 Apr 2005 2:37pm
- Location: Saints Footy Central
You would have to think that Ferg's time is up.... pity that his body never allowed him to have a real crack at it but it's a brutal game, no room for sentiment.
I wouldn't be surprised if Rixy is kept as insurance (unless another ruckman is traded for). King & Gardiner have been great when they're on the ground but are a week to week proposition injury wise & Big Mac is at least 2 years away from being thrown the No.1 ruck spot. Obviously Rixy is under significant pressure despite his outstanding form at Casey (he's not just a good VFL player but a dominant one... there's been a fair few of them that couldn't make the step up though).
Leigh Fisher has been superseeded by Dempster, Eddy, Jones & the like. Another great clubman but his time may be up.
I know that they look on Howard as a project but a tough decision may have to be made on whether he will make the grade. He's vying for a spot that is probably our strong point (HBF/3rd string midfield rotation) & will have to be evaluated come draft time if we pick up a Jack Ziebell or similar type at the national draft.
Gwilt? Hard to say, he's obviously now depth at full back & we don't have much else there. Once again, if Michael Hurley falls into our laps on draft day then maybe it is time for the Fro to Go.
I would get rid of Fiora & eat the last year of his contract... talk about chances & output. I'd rather see Brad Howard get some games to see if he can cut it.
Out- Banger & G (retired), L.Fisher, Fiora, Ferguson, Gwilt or Rix.
In- McQualter, Eddy, 4 draft picks.
I would be surprised to see some action re: trade time this year. Focus on the National & Rookie drafts.
I wouldn't be surprised if Rixy is kept as insurance (unless another ruckman is traded for). King & Gardiner have been great when they're on the ground but are a week to week proposition injury wise & Big Mac is at least 2 years away from being thrown the No.1 ruck spot. Obviously Rixy is under significant pressure despite his outstanding form at Casey (he's not just a good VFL player but a dominant one... there's been a fair few of them that couldn't make the step up though).
Leigh Fisher has been superseeded by Dempster, Eddy, Jones & the like. Another great clubman but his time may be up.
I know that they look on Howard as a project but a tough decision may have to be made on whether he will make the grade. He's vying for a spot that is probably our strong point (HBF/3rd string midfield rotation) & will have to be evaluated come draft time if we pick up a Jack Ziebell or similar type at the national draft.
Gwilt? Hard to say, he's obviously now depth at full back & we don't have much else there. Once again, if Michael Hurley falls into our laps on draft day then maybe it is time for the Fro to Go.
I would get rid of Fiora & eat the last year of his contract... talk about chances & output. I'd rather see Brad Howard get some games to see if he can cut it.
Out- Banger & G (retired), L.Fisher, Fiora, Ferguson, Gwilt or Rix.
In- McQualter, Eddy, 4 draft picks.
I would be surprised to see some action re: trade time this year. Focus on the National & Rookie drafts.
-
- SS Life Member
- Posts: 3619
- Joined: Wed 21 May 2008 8:51pm
- Location: Tassie
- Has thanked: 486 times
- Been thanked: 315 times
GONE
Gwilt
Rix
L Fisher
Ferguson
Gehrig - Retired
Harvey - Retired (sadly)
MAYBE'S
McQualter
R Clarke
Baker
ELEVATE ROOKIES
Jones
Eddy
Definetly leaves a lot a holes in the list, none bigger than the one left by the "Great Man", but all of the above have had more than enough time in the system.
Will be our last chance for a couple of years to have a real crack at the draft as the following one will be heavily depleted by the inclusion of GC17.
It will also free up some room in the salary cap and we could have a crack at getting Daniel Kerr or maybe, dare I say it , a clean and rejuvenated Ben Cousins.
Gwilt
Rix
L Fisher
Ferguson
Gehrig - Retired
Harvey - Retired (sadly)
MAYBE'S
McQualter
R Clarke
Baker
ELEVATE ROOKIES
Jones
Eddy
Definetly leaves a lot a holes in the list, none bigger than the one left by the "Great Man", but all of the above have had more than enough time in the system.
Will be our last chance for a couple of years to have a real crack at the draft as the following one will be heavily depleted by the inclusion of GC17.
It will also free up some room in the salary cap and we could have a crack at getting Daniel Kerr or maybe, dare I say it , a clean and rejuvenated Ben Cousins.
- Animal Enclosure
- SS Hall of Fame
- Posts: 2364
- Joined: Mon 04 Apr 2005 2:37pm
- Location: Saints Footy Central