Votes vs North Melbourne

[BigMart]

5-Kosi
4-Hayes
3-Gram
2-McQualter
1-Montagna

[doggerel]

5. Kosi
4. Hayes
3. Dal
2. Ball
1. McQualter

[Kate]

5. S. Fisher
4. J. Koschitzke
3. L. Hayes
2. J. Gram
1. N. Riewoldt

Apologies to Dal, Mini & Joey.

[S.A Saint]

5. kosi
4. hayes
3. gram
2. mini
1. dal

[saint3d]

5. Hayes
4. Gram
3. Koschitzke
2. Riewoldt
1. Dal Santo

[The Sainter]

5 Kosi
4 Hayes
3 Roo
2 McQualter
1 Jones

[Winmar7Fan]

5. J. Koschitzke

4. L. Hayes

3. L. Montagna

2. N. Dal Santo

1. N. Riewoldt

Why am I not surprised you didn't include Gram. He only had 31 disposals but he did shank a couple which would have hurt his eff rating.

Actually I probably agree with your selections as well.

Come on just shut me up Fid and say you had him as a very close 6th

[St Fidelius]

5. J. Koschitzke

4. L. Hayes

3. L. Montagna

2. N. Dal Santo

1. N. Riewoldt

Why am I not surprised you didn't include Gram. He only had 31 disposals but he did shank a couple which would have hurt his eff rating.

Actually I probably agree with your selections as well.

Come on just shut me up Fid and say you had him as a very close 6th

L. Ball 6th

C. Jones 7th

A. McQualter 8th

Answer NO...

But he did play a better game

[saint vince]

5. Hayes
4. Kosi
3. Ball
2. Dal
1. Roo

[RoseInOz]

5. J. Koschitzke
4. L. Hayes
3. N. Dal Santo
2. J. Gram
1. L. Montagna

[Winmar7Fan]

5. J. Koschitzke

4. L. Hayes

3. L. Montagna

2. N. Dal Santo

1. N. Riewoldt

Why am I not surprised you didn't include Gram. He only had 31 disposals but he did shank a couple which would have hurt his eff rating.

Actually I probably agree with your selections as well.

Come on just shut me up Fid and say you had him as a very close 6th

L. Ball 6th

C. Jones 7th

A. McQualter 8th

Answer NO...

But he did play a better game

Gee your tough

[Brooksy_Babe_24]

5 Kosi
4 Ball
3Hayes
2 Montagna
1 Dal Santo

[JohnE]

5-Kosi
4-Hayes
3-McQualter
2-Gram
1-Gwilt

[Ghost Like]

5 Kosi

4 Lenny

3 Mini

2 CJ

1 Gwilt

[St Fidelius]

Gee your tough

Just why do you think that's tough??

L Ball 22 disposals and 6 tackles

C Jones 19 disposals 1 goal (against Wells 18 disposals no goals)

A McQualter 21 disposals and 7 tackles

Jason Gram 31 disposals at an effective disposal rate at 68%...

[plugger66]

Gee your tough

Just why do you think that's tough??

L Ball 22 disposals and 6 tackles

C Jones 19 disposals 1 goal (against Wells 18 disposals no goals)

A McQualter 21 disposals and 7 tackles

Jason Gram 31 disposals at an effective disposal rate at 68%...

So no mention of Grams tackles or the others effectiveness. Gram was in the best 5 today no doubt IMO of course.

[SainterK]

5 Kosi
4 Lenny
3 Dal
2 Ball
1 Gram

[St Fidelius]

Gee your tough

Just why do you think that's tough??

L Ball 22 disposals and 6 tackles

C Jones 19 disposals 1 goal (against Wells 18 disposals no goals)

A McQualter 21 disposals and 7 tackles

Jason Gram 31 disposals at an effective disposal rate at 68%...

So no mention of Grams tackles or the others effectiveness. Gram was in the best 5 today no doubt IMO of course.

Well out of your votes Joey, got the votes ahead of Gram. It seems that 27 disposals and 6 tackles just is so much better

5 Lenny
4 Kosi
3 Gram
2 Dal
1 Rooy

otherwise we are even on the other players you selected..

Luke Ball played a far better game than Gram IMO as well as CJ and Mini...

But hey, that's my opinion...

Gram for the record recorded 1 tackle on one site and 2 tackles on another...

Both Ball and Mini were far better than Gram IMO...

anyway Montagana had 27 disposals at 97% effectiveness and I fail to see why you have not included him in the best five..

But again, a matter of opinion....

[avid]

5 Justin Koschitzke
4 Jason Gram
3 Lenny Hayes
2 Nick Riewoldt
1 Nick Dal Santo

[sainter104]

1 Roo
2 Lenny
3 Kosi
4 CJ
5 Goddard ( had big disagreement with me good mate we were both at the game so from others not putting him in I guess I looked at his game diffrent ???? coments )

[claystreet]

1:Kosi

2:Roo

3:Lenny

4:Joey

5:Dal

again another tight field to try and pick out of

thought these players were good Zac Gwilt Blake Gram (but was spraying them everywhere)

[BigMart]

This is a votes thread, not everyones will be the same. Just list them. Argue the point on another, this does not need to be a 3 page argument between a couple.

[plugger66]

This is a votes thread, not everyones will be the same. Just list them. Argue the point on another, this does not need to be a 3 page argument between a couple.

Thanks Dad. I will take note in future.

[perfectionist]

5. Justin Koschitzke (5 CMs)
4. Nick Riewoldt (2 CMs)
3. Lenny Hayes
2. Luke Ball (2 CMs)
1. Zac Dawson (1 CM)

[Quixote]

5. Kosi
4. Hayes
3. Ball
2. Dal
1. James Gwilt you are INSTRUMENTAL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!