King
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
- meher baba
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 7211
- Joined: Mon 14 Aug 2006 6:49am
- Location: Tasmania
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 513 times
King
I thought King was good last night and made an important, and largely unsung, contribution to our win.
Sure, he gave away some free kicks (3 according to the match stats I saw, but he also got 2 awarded to him), but that's part and parcel of him doing his job in stopping the Freo monster from dominating in the rucks. Every time King went up against Sandilands, there was a genuine contest.
Sandilands beat both King and (more so) Gardi, but he was a long way short of being able to do whatever he liked, and our midfielders benefited accordingly.
King also had a few important possessions near the end.
If (as many on here would have preferred) McEvoy had played instead of King, Sandilands would have torn him up into tiny little pieces IMO and Freo would probably have won the game.
A lot of people on here have got to get over their obsession with "giving the kids a go". Experience counts for a lot, especially in the ruck.
Ruckmen take a long time to develop: five years ago, Sandilands was a lumbering oaf whose height was his main strong point. Now, at age 28, he's a first-rate AFL player. McEvoy might take that long as well.
Sure, he gave away some free kicks (3 according to the match stats I saw, but he also got 2 awarded to him), but that's part and parcel of him doing his job in stopping the Freo monster from dominating in the rucks. Every time King went up against Sandilands, there was a genuine contest.
Sandilands beat both King and (more so) Gardi, but he was a long way short of being able to do whatever he liked, and our midfielders benefited accordingly.
King also had a few important possessions near the end.
If (as many on here would have preferred) McEvoy had played instead of King, Sandilands would have torn him up into tiny little pieces IMO and Freo would probably have won the game.
A lot of people on here have got to get over their obsession with "giving the kids a go". Experience counts for a lot, especially in the ruck.
Ruckmen take a long time to develop: five years ago, Sandilands was a lumbering oaf whose height was his main strong point. Now, at age 28, he's a first-rate AFL player. McEvoy might take that long as well.
"It is useless to attempt to reason a man out of a thing he was never reasoned into."
- Jonathan Swift
- Jonathan Swift
He wasn't awful, but he could be better IMO meher baba.
It's the times I watch him spectate when he is in a position to go for the ball, he also needs to throw his body around more and be in a position to take some contested marks.
I am willing to admit Gardiner was quiet also, but I am more inclined to think he wasn't 100% right. There was a moment where he tried to sprint, and he didn't look comfortable at all.
Either one of them could make room for McEvoy based on last nights peformance, or Ross may decide to have Kosi ruck/rotating forward.
It's the times I watch him spectate when he is in a position to go for the ball, he also needs to throw his body around more and be in a position to take some contested marks.
I am willing to admit Gardiner was quiet also, but I am more inclined to think he wasn't 100% right. There was a moment where he tried to sprint, and he didn't look comfortable at all.
Either one of them could make room for McEvoy based on last nights peformance, or Ross may decide to have Kosi ruck/rotating forward.
King
Meha Baba said "Ruckmen take a long time to develop: five years ago, Sandilands was a lumbering oaf whose height was his main strong point ".
Too right - in the Sirengate game in 2006 Sandilands was comprehensively beaten by Blake in the ruck - centre bounce, boundary and around the ground. Nowdays it probably wouldn't be a coaching masterstroke to put Blakey up against Sandilands for the whole game .
Too right - in the Sirengate game in 2006 Sandilands was comprehensively beaten by Blake in the ruck - centre bounce, boundary and around the ground. Nowdays it probably wouldn't be a coaching masterstroke to put Blakey up against Sandilands for the whole game .
- saintsRrising
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 30092
- Joined: Mon 15 Mar 2004 11:07am
- Location: Melbourne
- Has thanked: 711 times
- Been thanked: 1234 times
I generally agree with MB.
Sandlilands is now truly awesome player..and absolute freak...and so the task of St Kilda rucks is just to restrict the damage.
In doing this King did quite well, and in doing so you are going to give away a few frees.
Kings games against both the Pies and now Freo have been solid contributions.
On Sandlilands,..just imagine what he would go with either the St Kilda or Geelong midfields!!
Also hopefully next time we play Freo we will not kick it as many times to marking cintests that he is in, as that is a low % play now.
Sandlilands is now truly awesome player..and absolute freak...and so the task of St Kilda rucks is just to restrict the damage.
In doing this King did quite well, and in doing so you are going to give away a few frees.
Kings games against both the Pies and now Freo have been solid contributions.
On Sandlilands,..just imagine what he would go with either the St Kilda or Geelong midfields!!
Also hopefully next time we play Freo we will not kick it as many times to marking cintests that he is in, as that is a low % play now.
Last edited by saintsRrising on Mon 19 Apr 2010 11:27am, edited 1 time in total.
Flying the World in comfort thanks to FF Points....
- meher baba
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 7211
- Joined: Mon 14 Aug 2006 6:49am
- Location: Tasmania
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 513 times
Yes, at times I thought Sandilands was exercising some sort of magnetic attraction for our players when they were kicking the ball.saintsRrising wrote:Also hopefully next time we play Freo we will not kick it as many times to marking cointests that he is in, as that is alow % play now.
It could be that old golfer's problem of worrying so much about a sandtrap/water hazard/tree that, when you try to do everything to avoid it, you somehow end up hitting the ball straight at it (dreadful game: far prefer to lie in bed with a good book, or someone who's read one recently).
"It is useless to attempt to reason a man out of a thing he was never reasoned into."
- Jonathan Swift
- Jonathan Swift
- saintsRrising
- Saintsational Legend
- Posts: 30092
- Joined: Mon 15 Mar 2004 11:07am
- Location: Melbourne
- Has thanked: 711 times
- Been thanked: 1234 times
I think it is more that Sandlilands with expoerience has really worked out where to run too.meher baba wrote:Yes, at times I thought Sandilands was exercising some sort of magnetic attraction for our players when they were kicking the ball.saintsRrising wrote:Also hopefully next time we play Freo we will not kick it as many times to marking cointests that he is in, as that is alow % play now.
It could be that old golfer's problem of worrying so much about a sandtrap/water hazard/tree that, when you try to do everything to avoid it, you somehow end up hitting the ball straight at it (dreadful game: far prefer to lie in bed with a good book, or someone who's read one recently).
He often positioned himself so that if the saints tooka long clearing kick along the boundary that he was in that zone..
Noticed in the last quarter that a Saints player want to do this, as we had done quite often in the game, then hesitate and instrad kick the ball much shorter into space near the line which was then forced over the boundary instead.
ie he scarificed gaining say an extra 20 m to avoid kicking it to a contest that Sandlinds was in.
Flying the World in comfort thanks to FF Points....
- Milton66
- SS Life Member
- Posts: 3521
- Joined: Tue 19 May 2009 9:53pm
- Location: None of your goddam business
Agree with this view, and Sandi was also drifting back to great effect.saintsRrising wrote:I think it is more that Sandlilands with expoerience has really worked out where to run too.meher baba wrote:Yes, at times I thought Sandilands was exercising some sort of magnetic attraction for our players when they were kicking the ball.saintsRrising wrote:Also hopefully next time we play Freo we will not kick it as many times to marking cointests that he is in, as that is alow % play now.
It could be that old golfer's problem of worrying so much about a sandtrap/water hazard/tree that, when you try to do everything to avoid it, you somehow end up hitting the ball straight at it (dreadful game: far prefer to lie in bed with a good book, or someone who's read one recently).
He often positioned himself so that if the saints tooka long clearing kick along the boundary that he was in that zone..
Noticed in the last quarter that a Saints player want to do this, as we had done quite often in the game, then hesitate and instrad kick the ball much shorter into space near the line which was then forced over the boundary instead.
ie he scarificed gaining say an extra 20 m to avoid kicking it to a contest that Sandlinds was in.
Hotel De Los Muertos: Your room is ready... Care to step inside?