Trade rumours - post them here

saint patrick · Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:26pm

Ellis is still young ..a premiership player and a beautiful kick..worth looking at !

gringo · Post: # 1159194Post **gringo** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:27pm

stkildathunda wrote:
Old Mate wrote:
stkildathunda wrote:
Old Mate wrote:
stkildathunda wrote:
AFL_LHolmesby Luke Holmesby
Crows say there is another team asking about Maric but wouldn't specify who. 10 mins earlier St Kilda said they're interested in a ruck.
Yep. Heard Pelchin say they were after someone to help out McEvoy in the ruck.
Must be why interested in Tom Lynch. Maybe straight swap or something. Adelaide want a first round pick for Maric, which is way overpriced.
Maric 26 next year and entering his peak as a ruckman. All in all I think it's a fair trade for both parties.
Lynch for Maric i do agree would be a fair trade, but noway would i want us to give them pick 20 for him...

Maric looks like he should be a good ruckman, just hasn't got there yet. His value is only in the fact that there are a few looking for one. I would prefer Hamish Mc intosh or Bellchambers.

St Ick · Post: # 1159199Post **St Ick** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:34pm

What is the go with Stanley? I'd be happy to move on Lynch, Stanley and 3rd rounder for Gunston and Maric. Considering they'd lost Davis, Bock and Gunston, one would think they'd need a couple of KPP's

plugger66 · Post: # 1159202Post **plugger66** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:37pm

St Ick wrote:What is the go with Stanley? I'd be happy to move on Lynch, Stanley and 3rd rounder for Gunston and Maric. Considering they'd lost Davis, Bock and Gunston, one would think they'd need a couple of KPP's

Id say this post tells us why trades dont happen. Of course we would be happy but Adelaide wouldnt even be close to happy.

SaintSimmo · Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:38pm

looks like zac and farren aint going anywhere

http://www.saints.com.au/news/newsartic ... fault.aspx

borderbarry · Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:38pm

Looks like no trades on the opening day.

saintlee · Post: # 1159207Post **saintlee** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:39pm

borderbarry wrote:Looks like no trades on the opening day.

There has already been one: http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/r ... 6163182624

#1GILL · Post: # 1159208Post **#1GILL** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 4:40pm

borderbarry wrote:Looks like no trades on the opening day.

Two trades

Collingwood- Clarke, Elliot, 67
GWS- 25

Richmond- Steven Morris, 15
GWS- 14

Rosco · Post: # 1159256Post **Rosco** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 5:30pm

gringo wrote:Maric looks like he should be a good ruckman, just hasn't got there yet. His value is only in the fact that there are a few looking for one. I would prefer Hamish Mc intosh or Bellchambers.

i've thought bellchambers before (22 and had a good year in 2011 - 21 ho per game and 8 goals) but realistically hille is now 30 and somewhat injury prone and i don't know if they really want all their eggs in the basket of ryder being their ruckman alone if hille goes down

SaintSimmo · Mon 10 Oct 2011 5:39pm

Media moment: Chris Pelchen, St Kilda Head of football will be on 3AW tonight at 6:15pm

Should be interesting

Old Mate · Post: # 1159294Post **Old Mate** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 6:01pm

Pelchin enquiring on Sam Sheldon from the Lions....

SaintSimmo · Mon 10 Oct 2011 6:03pm

Old Mate wrote:Pelchin enquiring on Sam Sheldon from the Lions....

sorry but did i just travel back in time a year??
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/s ... 5935694164

Dr Spaceman · Mon 10 Oct 2011 6:04pm

SaintSimmo wrote:
Old Mate wrote:Pelchin enquiring on Sam Sheldon from the Lions....
sorry but did i just travel back in time a year??

We'll get him one of these days

The Redeemer · Mon 10 Oct 2011 6:05pm

Dr Spaceman wrote:
SaintSimmo wrote:
Old Mate wrote:Pelchin enquiring on Sam Sheldon from the Lions....
sorry but did i just travel back in time a year??
We'll get him one of these days

But why? he is a below average nothing player?

Dr Spaceman · Mon 10 Oct 2011 6:06pm

The Redeemer wrote:
Dr Spaceman wrote:
SaintSimmo wrote:
Old Mate wrote:Pelchin enquiring on Sam Sheldon from the Lions....
sorry but did i just travel back in time a year??
We'll get him one of these days
But why? he is a below average nothing player?

If Pelchen is keen then obviously he's a damaging left footer with superb foot skills

gringo · Post: # 1159301Post **gringo** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 6:07pm

The Redeemer wrote:
Dr Spaceman wrote:
SaintSimmo wrote:
Old Mate wrote:Pelchin enquiring on Sam Sheldon from the Lions....
sorry but did i just travel back in time a year??
We'll get him one of these days
But why? he is a below average nothing player?

Well some have been looking at Goldsack, another average player, hope it's not us. Cornelius would be better, he was supposedly a saints fan.

SaintSimmo · Mon 10 Oct 2011 6:17pm

gringo wrote:
The Redeemer wrote:
Dr Spaceman wrote:
SaintSimmo wrote:
Old Mate wrote:Pelchin enquiring on Sam Sheldon from the Lions....
sorry but did i just travel back in time a year??
We'll get him one of these days
But why? he is a below average nothing player?
Well some have been looking at Goldsack, another average player, hope it's not us. Cornelius would be better, he was supposedly a saints fan.

IN PELCHEN WE TRUST

SainterK · Post: # 1159311Post **SainterK** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 6:18pm

Dr Spaceman wrote:
The Redeemer wrote:
Dr Spaceman wrote:
SaintSimmo wrote:
Old Mate wrote:Pelchin enquiring on Sam Sheldon from the Lions....
sorry but did i just travel back in time a year??
We'll get him one of these days
But why? he is a below average nothing player?
If Pelchen is keen then obviously he's a damaging left footer with superb foot skills

Not sure about that, but pretty sure he hasn't had opportunity because of health, rather than ability. Think he battled GF for a long time?

plugger66 · Post: # 1159312Post **plugger66** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 6:19pm

SainterK wrote:
Dr Spaceman wrote:
The Redeemer wrote:
Dr Spaceman wrote:
SaintSimmo wrote:
Old Mate wrote:Pelchin enquiring on Sam Sheldon from the Lions....
sorry but did i just travel back in time a year??
We'll get him one of these days
But why? he is a below average nothing player?
If Pelchen is keen then obviously he's a damaging left footer with superb foot skills
Not sure about that, but pretty sure he hasn't had opportunity because of health, rather than ability. Think he battled GF for a long time?

Well let him keep battling it up in Brisbane.

SainterK · Post: # 1159313Post **SainterK** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 6:20pm

plugger66 wrote:
SainterK wrote:
Dr Spaceman wrote:
The Redeemer wrote:
Dr Spaceman wrote:
SaintSimmo wrote:
Old Mate wrote:Pelchin enquiring on Sam Sheldon from the Lions....
sorry but did i just travel back in time a year??
We'll get him one of these days
But why? he is a below average nothing player?
If Pelchen is keen then obviously he's a damaging left footer with superb foot skills
Not sure about that, but pretty sure he hasn't had opportunity because of health, rather than ability. Think he battled GF for a long time?
Well let him keep battling it up in Brisbane.

Sure, wasn't saying we should get him, just that I think there has never been a knock on his ability or that he is below average.

Actually, why am I bothering

SaintSimmo · Mon 10 Oct 2011 6:25pm

Sam Sheldon for those who don't know him:
The silky skilled midfielder has endured a horror run with injuries since being drafted to the Club in 2006. The 183cm recruit from Victoria shows poise beyond his years, is creative in front of goals and is an excellent user of ball by hand or foot

yipper · Post: # 1159407Post **yipper** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 9:10pm

Sounds like Pelchin is already marking his territory - enquires about Sheldon. What/who is Sheldon?? A young, very highly skilled player.. The saints will from now on only be recrutiing blokes who can use the footy..
Thank goodness.

Saints94 · Post: # 1159411Post **Saints94** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 9:17pm

Wait who have/else have we enquired about?

demac · Post: # 1159412Post **demac** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 9:18pm

hey just read on another forum gilbert for gunston has anyone else heard this

Saints94 · Post: # 1159413Post **Saints94** » Mon 10 Oct 2011 9:18pm

Wait who have/else have we enquired about?