The Conundrum of the Hannebery Trade

[satchmo]

Maybe they can throw Brett Kirk & Mike Pyke into the deal if lethers has connections to those blokes too?

Let's wait until we see their school ties. Pyke might be up against it though.

[The_President]

Nominated the Saints?

Yep, Hannebery on herald sun site nominates Saints for trade.
Just waiting on Daisy Thomas and Jarrod Waite to reverse retirement decisions and nominate joining us

Bit worried about you Joffa, first Cerra, now Thomas!!!!!

Yep, Thomas joining saints is the inside word.
Coming as a replacement for Mav who is going to North on $700k a year deal

Very nice Joffa!!!!!

[chico2001]

Almost a done deal with Hannebery and paying "ovvvvvveeerrrrrrssssss!!!!!

[dragit]

Who do you barrack for chico, ya cheeky kent?

[older saint]

Played cards way to early on this one. Hannebury played an ordinary final and wasn't great to finish the year , but had already been offered an excessive deal from StKilda.

2019 2nd round pick or later 2nd rounder if we trade for one this season AT MOST for an injury prone 28 year old former top liner. no way 1st rounder or even comp pick

[saintkid]

Nominated the Saints?

Yep, Hannebery on herald sun site nominates Saints for trade.
Just waiting on Daisy Thomas and Jarrod Waite to reverse retirement decisions and nominate joining us

They may as well bring Tom Lee back too. Another reactive, short-term decision at best and that's if Hannebery's body holds up. Obviously the last 5 years have taught them nothing. The club is being run by amateur fools that are fast-tracking it to oblivion.

[prwilkinson]

Send Plugger down with Hanners. We need a new goal kicking coach at Moorabbin.

[DJ Higgins]

Depends what he is offered and for how long but we are getting a busted player passed his prime. Dont get me wrong I hope he plays for the next 5 years and is a gun but I cant see him changing his game i.e. not going in hard at everything. Just think it is silly as well

[chico2001]

Who so you barrack for chico, ya cheeky kent?

Dont call me a kent dunt

[chico2001]

Depends what he is offered and for how long but we are getting a busted player passed his prime. Dont get me wrong I hope he plays for the next 5 years and is a gun but I cant see him changing his game i.e. not going in hard at everything. Just think it is silly as well

We all hope he goes fantastic but he has been down this year for sure. Most players coming in on his dough are at the top of their game and as fit as a buck rat but he doesnt look like that based on watching him on TV.

[dragit]

Who so you barrack for chico, ya cheeky kent?

Dont call me a kent dunt

Bombers?

[chico2001]

haha.....I might be old south melbourne too

[cwrcyn]

If we pick up Hanneberry, it will be a blunder even greater than any of the recent ones people on this forum have been howling about. This is a diabolical move. If he was a free agent, then fine, but to give up valuable draft picks for a busted up midfielder whose form has deteriorated significantly in the past two seasons is madness. This could be a defining moment, and not the positive variety. If this fails as I expect it will, it will send this club even further into the mire.

[satchmo]

Who so you barrack for chico, ya cheeky kent?

Dont call me a kent dunt

Bombers?

Usually only get filth. Bombres are way too smug to bother with us, unless it's prepubescent.

[chico2001]

If we pick up Hanneberry, it will be a blunder even greater than any of the recent ones people on this forum have been howling about. This is a diabolical move. If he was a free agent, then fine, but to give up valuable draft picks for a busted up midfielder whose form has deteriorated significantly in the past two seasons is madness. This could be a defining moment, and not the positive variety. If this fails as I expect it will, it will send this club even further into the mire.

It s about a done deal, but I am not sure how the picks to Sydney would work. We dont have a lot.

[derby Street]

Who so you barrack for chico, ya cheeky kent?

Dont call me a kent dunt

Bombers?

Usually only get filth. Bombres are way too smug to bother with us, unless it's prepubescent.

Chico is definite Filth - Scollop hit a nerve about the Filth and Chico came flying in all guns blazing. Read his posts and you will soon see filth oozing out.

[Sainternist]

If we pick up Hanneberry, it will be a blunder even greater than any of the recent ones people on this forum have been howling about. This is a diabolical move. If he was a free agent, then fine, but to give up valuable draft picks for a busted up midfielder whose form has deteriorated significantly in the past two seasons is madness. This could be a defining moment, and not the positive variety. If this fails as I expect it will, it will send this club even further into the mire.

It s about a done deal, but I am not sure how the picks to Sydney would work. We dont have a lot.

There's one rumour that says we're looking to trade Luke Dunstan to Port for a second round pick, which Sydney would ultimately get in exchange for Hannebery.

[stonecold]

Nominated the Saints?

Yep, Hannebery on herald sun site nominates Saints for trade.
Just waiting on Daisy Thomas and Jarrod Waite to reverse retirement decisions and nominate joining us

Bit worried about you Joffa, first Cerra, now Thomas!!!!!

Yep, Thomas joining saints is the inside word.
Coming as a replacement for Mav who is going to North on $700k a year deal

Even you would know what 'Rumour' means, maybe not!!!!!

[BackFromUSA]

Would prefer McCartin for Hannebery straight swap. Both have body issues. McCartin younger and can develop with his brother for the post Franklin era. Hannebery proven champ if his body gets right but only 3 - 5 years left.

[Sainternist]

Would prefer McCartin for Hannebery straight swap. Both have body issues. McCartin younger and can develop with his brother for the post Franklin era. Hannebery proven champ if his body gets right but only 3 - 5 years left.

Interesting hypothetical. With McCartin's brother already at Sydney, it actually seems plausible.

[The Recruit]

I imagine we will trade our priority pick for Hannebery

[bigcarl]

If we pick up Hanneberry, it will be a blunder even greater than any of the recent ones people on this forum have been howling about. This is a diabolical move. If he was a free agent, then fine, but to give up valuable draft picks for a busted up midfielder whose form has deteriorated significantly in the past two seasons is madness.

Banged up and 15 games with fewer than 20 possessions this season. He's contracted for another three years with the Swans and I'm not surprised they to want to move him on given this season's output.

This is not the big fish we are looking for.

[chico2001]

Who so you barrack for chico, ya cheeky kent?

Dont call me a kent dunt

Bombers?

Usually only get filth. Bombres are way too smug to bother with us, unless it's prepubescent.

Chico is definite Filth - Scollop hit a nerve about the Filth and Chico came flying in all guns blazing. Read his posts and you will soon see filth oozing out.

You should be definitely suspended for baiting, it is a wonder the administrator hasnt stepped in and straightened you out or should I ring one of my friends in Smith street to knock on your door late at night whilst you are abusing people on your keyboard?

[The_President]

Stevo reporting that Dunstan May be pushed out with Carlton a chance.

[chico2001]

Would prefer McCartin for Hannebery straight swap. Both have body issues. McCartin younger and can develop with his brother for the post Franklin era. Hannebery proven champ if his body gets right but only 3 - 5 years left.

He has played 208 games so far and he might not see out 5yrs. He has had a lot of tough games in that time.