McQualter's Return

[Spinner]

Thought McQualter committed himself physically from what I saw of the first quarter. 17 possessions overall.

How did people find his game? Missed pretty much everything from quarter time.....

Has he maintained his spot for next week?

[BigMart]

He worked hard......and had a crack.....

Should be played as a Small Fwd/Mid....get rid of either Milne or Schnieder.

[spert]

A good effort -earned his spot.

[JeffDunne]

He played well enough to ensure he gets dropped next week.

[happy feet]

I was at the game last night. After it was all over, my observations were as follows.

We were very disjointed, nothing flowed, and everything looked like hard work. Gardiner was very good in the ruck, hit outs hit our players, but it was all downhill from there. No structure in the forward line, Roo looked ordinary and got nothing from the umpires. Our back line was pushed off the ball far too easily. Against the Swans we looked physically weak. No one could keep up with Adam Goodes who looked like superman. Apart from a 10 minute spurt after half time, I would have to say it was a very disappointing effort. Again, O'Loughlin did some magical things with the footy, a pleasure to watch. Our so called superstars were missing again. Harves put in an effort, but he looks tired. Max, time to give it away. Milne - who can honestly see us lining up for a premiership with him in the line up.

I think I must now agree with what so many have said is that our list is nowhere near as good as we thought it was and we need to have a thorough clean out. However, having watched the Saints through the 70's and 80's and not win too many games, we had players that really had a red hot go and were hard at it. I mean the likes of Burns, Cunningham, Sarau, Elloitt,and Barker. Last night I did not see one of our players that even went near to comparing to these blokes. Harvs must be broken hearted this morning as are many supporters who witnessed an inciped StKilda side last night.

[mad saint guy]

Was he played as a tagger?

[St DAC]

Didn't look like it. He seemed to play as one of the midfield rotations. I thought he had a decent crack at it; clean hands, head over the pill, and his footskills were pretty good as well. Far from our worst on the night.

[bergsone]

Never been a big fan of him ,he had a crack and did allright good on him,whether he can follow up and improve on it is the big question

[jonesy]

Showed a bit,had a go. I wouldn't of redrafted him, but lasts night he was serviceable. Doubt whether he can do it on the fast tracks,a slippery bottled up SCG suited his style.

[saintsrus]

He played well enough to ensure he gets dropped next week.

[saintsrus]

I was at the game last night. After it was all over, my observations were as follows.

We were very disjointed, nothing flowed, and everything looked like hard work. Gardiner was very good in the ruck, hit outs hit our players, but it was all downhill from there. No structure in the forward line, Roo looked ordinary and got nothing from the umpires. Our back line was pushed off the ball far too easily. Our so called superstars were missing again. Harvs must be broken hearted this morning as are many supporters who witnessed an inciped StKilda side last night.

This summs up all our efforts this year win or loose

[BackFromUSA]

great game

played his role

the kind of player that plays well in the wet

a must for any MCG game

not saying he cannoy play well at Telstra Dome ... will wait and see

i think he is a good player who lost all confidence

now getting some back