changes this week

saintjake · Post: # 610236Post **saintjake** » Sat 26 Jul 2008 9:06pm

obviously kosi comes in, and maxy goes out.
who gets cut, who gets brought up?

midas_touch · Sat 26 Jul 2008 9:07pm

Fiora, and Schneider at the moment. Gotta give Gardi another go, it was his first game back in 5 weeks.

fonz_#15 · Post: # 610244Post **fonz_#15** » Sat 26 Jul 2008 9:08pm

gardiner

fiora definate outs...

kosi

and Geary in if he plays or played well for casey.

i dont know if they have played or not.

i don't think armo is doing enough either.

borderbarry · Sat 26 Jul 2008 9:16pm

No Scorpions this weekend. Geary had 40 possessions last game, has been our best for the last 2 weeks, and should have played today before Fiora and Schneider. Birss has been amongst our best for the last 2 games as well. I would bring both of them in and Kosi, leaving out Max, Schneider and Fiora. Maybe Jummy Gwilt can come back in to help replace Max.

BigMart · Post: # 610300Post **BigMart** » Sat 26 Jul 2008 9:47pm

Ins....Koschitzke, Geary, Birss

Outs...Gardner, Armitage, and either Schnieder or Fiora..

adobe · Post: # 610314Post **adobe** » Sat 26 Jul 2008 10:01pm

BigMart wrote:Ins....Koschitzke, Geary, Birss

Outs...Gardner, Armitage, and either Schnieder or Fiora..

IN Rix least he can kick goals and takes marks around the ground and puts in an effort OUT M . Gardiner who cant do either
OUT Gilbert who gives away more frees than kicks he gets
In Geary

4ever_saint · Sat 26 Jul 2008 10:32pm

IN geary, kossi, birss
OUT schneider, maxxy, fiora

JohnE · Post: # 610350Post **JohnE** » Sat 26 Jul 2008 11:09pm

Surely Birss will be back!

saintsRrising · Sun 27 Jul 2008 12:06am

Poor Attitude and
Lousy Footskills both need to go out.

Unfortunately this week Lost Opportinity was a big in.

Ralphy · Post: # 610528Post **Ralphy** » Sun 27 Jul 2008 1:40pm

ins kosi,rix,birrs
out fiora,max,armo

Otiman · Post: # 610539Post **Otiman** » Sun 27 Jul 2008 1:54pm

Ins From: Koschitzke, Birss, Geary, Gardiner, Allen, Gwilt, Ferguson, Steven.
Outs From: Max, Gardiner, Armitage, Fiora, Schneider.

* Fiora to make way for someone who can kick goals. (Birss, Allen, C Gardiner, Ferguson)

* M Gardiner and Armitage to make way for those who can get more than 6 touches in a game. (Koschitzke, Geary)

* Also need to bring in those who can kick goals and give us a forward structure slightly more effective than "Kick it to Roo": Kosi, Gardiner, Birss, Allen.

* Someone to bolster the defense in place of Max: (Gwilt, Ferguson, Miles if fit.)

* Could also be an opportunity to bring Jack Steven in for his first AFL game, in place of the disappointing Schneider.

BallBanger · Post: # 610544Post **BallBanger** » Sun 27 Jul 2008 2:02pm

borderbarry wrote:No Scorpions this weekend. Geary had 40 possessions last game, has been our best for the last 2 weeks, and should have played today before Fiora and Schneider. Birss has been amongst our best for the last 2 games as well. I would bring both of them in and Kosi, leaving out Max, Schneider and Fiora. Maybe Jummy Gwilt can come back in to help replace Max.

Gwilt, your not serious?
we are in trouble. Best we start tanking and get some depth 14-39 on list struggling

Otiman · Post: # 610547Post **Otiman** » Sun 27 Jul 2008 2:09pm

BallBanger wrote:Gwilt, your not serious?
we are in trouble. Best we start tanking and get some depth 14-39 on list struggling

I'm serious about Gwilt. Don't be surprised if he's selected.

WayneJudson42 · Sun 27 Jul 2008 2:19pm

Either the match ups were wrong... but I have to admit that it's all over for Fiora. Lucky his opponent didn't kick straight.

Kosi back in. Amazing what the lack of a 2nd forward does to your team balance. Having him yesterday would have allowed Roo to run up more instead of being in the square.

MG had a dog day, but should stay as 2nd ruck.

If Rix gets a game, it's all over for me this year.

Geary and Rix... why is everyone so hung up on Scorps preformances?

Rix does well at VFL and is a dud in AFL. Geary still hasn;t done enough in the seniors.

C gardiner would have been a better option in the goal square yesterday.

Birrs for Fiora, and Kosi in. We will need another defender and it won't suprise to see Gwilt back.

derby Street · Sun 27 Jul 2008 10:06pm

Geez the cupboard looks pretty bare for replacing Max - he's the glue down there. I reckon Armo's needs a rest - he is just not getting enough of the pill at the moment (not that he racked up huge stats in any game yet) - & YES I accept that he will become a good player but isn't producing yet. His replacement Birss or Geary ( I hope Ross gives Geary a bit more of a free rein this time)

Fiora perhaps - but if left in for goodness sake please please don't play him in the backline. Schneider must have run out of chances surely and about time he went and had a game at Casey??

Gardi - Kosi - A given.

plugger66 · Post: # 610857Post **plugger66** » Sun 27 Jul 2008 10:09pm

I reckon plaing the 2 of King and MG makes us far less flexible as one of them must always be off the ground. we have 2 other back up ruckman in Kosi and Blake so I think the hard decision should be made and MG shouldnt play. Also gives the bench more rotations.

maverick · Post: # 610860Post **maverick** » Sun 27 Jul 2008 10:16pm

Agree on MG, only one of him or King can play.
I would bring in Allen and Birss and dump, which means

In Kosi, Allen, Birss
Out Max, Gardiner, Schneider

fonz_#15 · Post: # 610861Post **fonz_#15** » Sun 27 Jul 2008 10:17pm

maverick wrote:Agree on MG, only one of him or King can play.
I would bring in Allen and Birss and dump, which means

In Kosi, Allen, Birss
Out Max, Gardiner, Schneider

what has allen done to warrant selection?

and if you are looking for a mid, what about geary?

maverick · Post: # 610867Post **maverick** » Sun 27 Jul 2008 10:24pm

fonz_#15 wrote:
maverick wrote:Agree on MG, only one of him or King can play.
I would bring in Allen and Birss and dump, which means

In Kosi, Allen, Birss
Out Max, Gardiner, Schneider
what has allen done to warrant selection?

and if you are looking for a mid, what about geary?

Looking for a defensive forward to replace a loose forward in Schneider.

Allen provides a contest up forward, breaks open packs for our little men and is given development games in the 1's which (hopefully) fast tracks his development and just maybe, gives us the third tall option we need come finals time, especially when Kosi goes into the ruck and leaves Roo alone.

Speculative pick no doubt, but McEvoy is too much like Kosi and ferguson, the other option just can't kick for goal.

Armoooo · Post: # 610878Post **Armoooo** » Sun 27 Jul 2008 10:40pm

In: J.Koschitzke, S.Birss, J.Geary, B.McEvoy
Out: M.Gardiner, A.Fiora, A.Schneider, M.Hudghton

I don't believe we are going to go anywhere this year with Fiora, Schneider or Gardiner in our 22, I can see Birss, Geary and McEvoy being a part of our next premiership team.

FB: S.Fisher Blake Dempster
HB: Gram Gilbert Goddard
C: Montagna Dal Santo McQualter
HF: Jones Riewoldt Birss
FF: Milne Koschitzke Armitage
R: King Hayes Ball
I/C: McEvoy Harvey Eddy Geary

It is amazing what a diference one player can make, if Harvey wasn't around the team I would be hoping for would be

FB: Dempster Gilbert R.Clarke
HB: Goddard S.Fisher Geary
C: Gram Dal Santo Montagna
HF: Birss Riewoldt Jones
FF: Milne Koschitzke Steven
R: McEvoy Hayes Ball
I/C: Armitage Eddy Allen McQualter

saintjake · Post: # 610890Post **saintjake** » Sun 27 Jul 2008 10:59pm

we have to stop looking for "the future"and getting games into the young guys, i no its good, and if they play well enough to be selected.
then we pick them
but we need to pick players who have been playing well.
we cant pick players jsut because of their name.
or number they were drafted.

maverick · Post: # 610894Post **maverick** » Sun 27 Jul 2008 11:05pm

saintjake wrote:we have to stop looking for "the future"and getting games into the young guys, i no its good, and if they play well enough to be selected.
then we pick them
but we need to pick players who have been playing well.
we cant pick players jsut because of their name.
or number they were drafted.

Agree but we do need to play a forward in the forward line, who else do you suggest?

Allen needs to play for 2008 and our chances this year, it just so happens his development will be accelerated as well....

If Gehrig becomes match fit, would be more than happy for him to be the one, just don't expect it....

Mooksy · Post: # 610928Post **Mooksy** » Sun 27 Jul 2008 11:45pm

Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out
Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora out, Fiora Out Fiora Out Fiora Out