Possible changes v North

saint patrick · Mon 01 Jun 2009 6:54pm

My gut feel is

Out:Gardiner[susp],R.Clarke

In:Milne,McEnvoy

If Gilbert is out .Max back in.

JABBER · Post: # 749773Post **JABBER** » Mon 01 Jun 2009 7:18pm

Gardiner, Clarke ,Mini out

Milne,McEvoy, Steven in

Mini needs a break and if gilbert is injured then Max

Hurricane · Post: # 749778Post **Hurricane** » Mon 01 Jun 2009 7:24pm

The only change should be a forced one

Out: Gardiner
In: McEvoy

Why exactly does Mini need a break? Is it time for his rostered day off or something?

BANG BANG

SainterK · Post: # 749782Post **SainterK** » Mon 01 Jun 2009 7:25pm

Hurricane wrote:The only change should be a forced one

Out: Gardiner
In: McEvoy

Why exactly does Mini need a break? Is it time for his rostered day off or something?

BANG BANG

What about Milne, we missed him on the weekend...

saint patrick · Mon 01 Jun 2009 7:26pm

Hurricane wrote:The only change should be a forced one

Out: Gardiner
In: McEvoy

Why exactly does Mini need a break? Is it time for his rostered day off or something?

BANG BANG

Milne will be a forced in if he is fit...someone has to make way...Raph may be the unlucky one.

Moorabbin Saints · Mon 01 Jun 2009 7:28pm

Milne, McEvoy --> R Clarke, Gardiner (susp)

Also need to look at getting Max in before the bye.

Hurricane · Post: # 749792Post **Hurricane** » Mon 01 Jun 2009 7:29pm

saint patrick wrote:
Hurricane wrote:The only change should be a forced one

Out: Gardiner
In: McEvoy

Why exactly does Mini need a break? Is it time for his rostered day off or something?

BANG BANG
Milne will be a forced in if he is fit...someone has to make way...Raph may be the unlucky one.

Who makes way?

Raph is a half back flanker and Milne is a foward pocket so it couldnt be a straight swap. Gwilt might go out for Milne as both are fowards.

BANG BANG

saint patrick · Mon 01 Jun 2009 7:37pm

Would just require a re jig of structure...gwilt can play back if required.

St Fidelius · Mon 01 Jun 2009 7:43pm

JABBER wrote:Gardiner, Clarke ,Mini out

Milne,McEvoy, Steven in

Mini needs a break and if gilbert is injured then Max

Why mini out??

This year Mini........

Averages 4 tackles a match

Has kicked 9:4 in ten matches

and has had 8 score assists.

Near half of his 153 disposals have been contested...

Thinline · Post: # 749842Post **Thinline** » Mon 01 Jun 2009 8:54pm

What's all this 'so and so' needs a break shite?

Fair dinkum...

plugger66 · Post: # 749844Post **plugger66** » Mon 01 Jun 2009 8:57pm

Thinline wrote:What's all this 'so and so' needs a break shite?

Fair dinkum...

Dont you understand. Some players get tired during the year but it seems its never Rooy, Hayes, Joey, Dal and Bally. Its only the bottom 6 who seem to get tired.

Devilhead · Post: # 749846Post **Devilhead** » Mon 01 Jun 2009 8:59pm

Ahhhhhh ..... the joys of having a very short injury list

Fingers crossed it stays that way

Bernard Shakey · Mon 01 Jun 2009 11:12pm

JABBER, suggesting Mini needs a rest, suggests to me that you are just jabbering.

Goose is king · Mon 01 Jun 2009 11:29pm

Anyone who thinks Mini will get dropped knows nothing about how the saints are going about things this year or even since Dal + Milney got dropped.

Effort is the key, playing your role and doing the team things. To borrow a Paganism "thats Mini in a nutshell".

Like most I think

In: Milne and Mc.
Out: Raph and Gards.

Still hoping my man goose get the nods though.

PJ · Post: # 749941Post PJ » Mon 01 Jun 2009 11:40pm

In: Milne
Out: Gardner

Kosi to do rucking, King resting in the square and rejig the forward line.

CaptainRiewoldt · Tue 02 Jun 2009 12:18am

Out: gardiner, blake (omit)
In: McEvoy, Maguire

Giuve Milne another week, why rush back?
Gilbert will be fine only a little sprained ankle - with rest and oxygen chamber easily done.

If the above happens as it should, ill be stoked!!
GO SAINTS!!

As for Raph out?? get off it he has just come back to AFL give him a chance FFS

SainterK · Post: # 749952Post **SainterK** » Tue 02 Jun 2009 12:20am

PJ wrote:In: Milne
Out: Gardner

Kosi to do rucking, King resting in the square and rejig the forward line.

Kosi rucking, I hope not...I would be more inclined to let Blake have a go.

St Fidelius · Tue 02 Jun 2009 12:57am

Bernard Shakey wrote:JABBER, suggesting Mini needs a rest, suggests to me that you are just jabbering.

Agreed...

To me it suggest that he does not attend matches and or know F*** all about the game...

he needs a break

Again....

Mini...

Averages 4 tackles a match

Has kicked 9:4 in ten matches

and has had 8 score assists.

Near half of his 153 disposals have been contested...

So jabber, in your opinion Steven can do better

Clue...

Watch a game and if you do, well that says enough for me....

You know very little IMO

saint3d · Post: # 749967Post **saint3d** » Tue 02 Jun 2009 1:22am

Getting Milne into the side is this week's conundrum. I can't see Ross dropping Gwilt or McQualter (hint: not everyone's role requires them to take 10 marks and kick 4 goals like Riewoldt). The two competing forces are structure (i.e. like for like replacement) and stability (i.e. minimal changes). I think the latter will win out and tentatively tip the following:

Out: Gardiner
In: Milne

plugger66 · Post: # 749984Post **plugger66** » Tue 02 Jun 2009 8:12am

RL obviously likes 2 ruckman so Ben if fit plays for sure. Milney if fit comes in for Raph. No other changes as I see it.

starsign · Post: # 749989Post **starsign** » Tue 02 Jun 2009 8:39am

Hurricane wrote:
saint patrick wrote:
Hurricane wrote:The only change should be a forced one

Out: Gardiner
In: McEvoy

Why exactly does Mini need a break? Is it time for his rostered day off or something?

BANG BANG
Milne will be a forced in if he is fit...someone has to make way...Raph may be the unlucky one.
Who makes way?

Raph is a half back flanker and Milne is a foward pocket so it couldnt be a straight swap. Gwilt might go out for Milne as both are fowards.

BANG BANG

Raph came in for Gram OK?
then Gram came in for Milne
so surely Gram or Raph could go back out for Milne !!!

BANG BANG F"N BANG!

saint66au · Post: # 749995Post **saint66au** » Tue 02 Jun 2009 9:02am

plugger66 wrote:RL obviously likes 2 ruckman so Ben if fit plays for sure. Milney if fit comes in for Raph. No other changes as I see it.

Agree. Raph keeps his spot if Gilbo doesnt come up tho

spert · Post: # 750010Post **spert** » Tue 02 Jun 2009 10:17am

Raph an automatic out as far as I'm concerned.

saintspremiers · Tue 02 Jun 2009 10:30am

spert wrote:Raph an automatic out as far as I'm concerned.

IMO Raph needs another chance - he needs confidence - with confidence to back himself he is a great player.

Silly move to drop him IMO.

Milney if fit is a definite in.

Perhaps out Gardy in Milne and one less ruck (ie. Kosi in the ruck??).

My gut feel is Gilbo won't come up, so it will be:

OUT: Gardy & Gilbo

IN: McEvoy & Milne

bergholt · Post: # 750020Post **bergholt** » Tue 02 Jun 2009 10:42am

CaptainReiwoldt wrote:Giuve Milne another week, why rush back?

probably because 20 goals 9 behinds in 9 games suggests he's a very important player for us.

obviously mcevoy in for gardiner.

if milne is fit then he has to come in. probably gram back out or else gwilt. raph deserves a bit more time to play into some form - gwilt's had 10 rounds.

IN: McEvoy, Milne
OUT: Gardiner, Gram

Possible changes v North

Possible changes v North

possible changes against north

Re: possible changes against north