Selwood offered 3 weeks

Moods · Post: # 1089561Post **Moods** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 6:07pm

Source - HS

Pwoit · Post: # 1089572Post **Pwoit** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 6:13pm

Given 4 can take 3

plugger66 · Post: # 1089573Post **plugger66** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 6:14pm

Second week in a row the AFL have stuffed up. Thomas not getting off last week and Selwood getting 3 next week. Cant wait till a player finally gets off and it will be the currupt AFL again.

jonesy · Post: # 1089574Post **jonesy** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 6:15pm

Ouch... someone must of seen it then

We couldn't beat them without him last time,see what happens this time
If we can pull one out of the hat we might scrape into the 8 yet

SainterK · Post: # 1089585Post **SainterK** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 6:24pm

I think he is lucky to get offered three.

Out of character for him, very good footballer, will be having a few sleepless nights I reckon.

Eastern · Post: # 1089588Post **Eastern** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 6:29pm

jonesy wrote:Ouch... someone must of seen it then

According to MMM it was a combination of what Guerra said and the medical report from the Hawthorn doctor !!

Junction Oval · Mon 13 Jun 2011 6:31pm

It might be out of character, but a Perforated Eardrum is a hefty crunch, whether retaliation or not.

Eastern · Post: # 1089601Post **Eastern** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 6:35pm

Junction Oval wrote:It might be out of character, but a Perforated Eardrum is a hefty crunch, whether retaliation or not.

Was it a fist or was it an elbow? !!

saintbrat · Post: # 1089611Post **saintbrat** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 6:42pm

SEN commentators appear to be viewing vision and Dermie said he is lucky to be only offered 4 and should NOT contest..

just as well he doesn't have carryover- or another 25-50% would have it around the 7 that bakes got.

suss · Post: # 1089632Post **suss** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 6:58pm

Junction Oval wrote:It might be out of character, but a Perforated Eardrum is a hefty crunch, whether retaliation or not.

I burst my eardrum playing footy and it's not much fun. It doesn't seem to take a hard hit to burst it - a cupped hand slap across the side of the head will do.

Thinline · Post: # 1089637Post **Thinline** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:04pm

suss wrote:
Junction Oval wrote:It might be out of character, but a Perforated Eardrum is a hefty crunch, whether retaliation or not.
I burst my eardrum playing footy and it's not much fun. It doesn't seem to take a hard hit to burst it - a cupped hand slap across the side of the head will do.

Did it surfing.

Horrible.

Ice Wolf · Post: # 1089645Post **Ice Wolf** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:12pm

I'd say hes lucky to be offered the 3. The MRP could easily have classed the impact as severe considering the injury to Guerra.

saintbrat · Post: # 1089651Post **saintbrat** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:19pm

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/ ... fault.aspx

Sainternist · Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:22pm

3 weeks for boxing someone's ears to point of causing deafness. Quite lenient when put into context.

Remember, Steven Baker was given 10 weeks for accidently running into Jeff Farmer.

Enrico_Misso · Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:25pm

Eastern wrote:
Junction Oval wrote:It might be out of character, but a Perforated Eardrum is a hefty crunch, whether retaliation or not.
Was it a fist or was it an elbow? !!

I imagine Duckhead would have used his head to ram Guerra's ear.

plugger66 · Post: # 1089656Post **plugger66** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:29pm

Sainternist wrote:3 weeks for boxing someone's ears to point of causing deafness. Quite lenient when put into context.

Remember, Steven Baker was given 10 weeks for accidently running into Jeff Farmer.

They both got 4 weeks and it was no accident.

Thinline · Post: # 1089661Post **Thinline** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:35pm

plugger66 wrote:
Sainternist wrote:3 weeks for boxing someone's ears to point of causing deafness. Quite lenient when put into context.

Remember, Steven Baker was given 10 weeks for accidently running into Jeff Farmer.
They both got 4 weeks and it was no accident.

How do you know re Baker?

If you saw it, what did you see?

I've always wanted to know myself...

plugger66 · Post: # 1089665Post **plugger66** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:37pm

Thinline wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Sainternist wrote:3 weeks for boxing someone's ears to point of causing deafness. Quite lenient when put into context.

Remember, Steven Baker was given 10 weeks for accidently running into Jeff Farmer.
They both got 4 weeks and it was no accident.
How do you know re Baker?

If you saw it, what did you see?

I've always wanted to know myself...

No I never saw it. Wish i had of. He actually told me one night.

Thinline · Post: # 1089666Post **Thinline** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:37pm

plugger66 wrote:
Thinline wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Sainternist wrote:3 weeks for boxing someone's ears to point of causing deafness. Quite lenient when put into context.

Remember, Steven Baker was given 10 weeks for accidently running into Jeff Farmer.
They both got 4 weeks and it was no accident.
How do you know re Baker?

If you saw it, what did you see?

I've always wanted to know myself...
No I never saw it. Wish i had of. He actually told me one night.

And what did he tell you?

plugger66 · Post: # 1089671Post **plugger66** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:39pm

Thinline wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Thinline wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Sainternist wrote:3 weeks for boxing someone's ears to point of causing deafness. Quite lenient when put into context.

Remember, Steven Baker was given 10 weeks for accidently running into Jeff Farmer.
They both got 4 weeks and it was no accident.
How do you know re Baker?

If you saw it, what did you see?

I've always wanted to know myself...
No I never saw it. Wish i had of. He actually told me one night.
And what did he tell you?

I think his exact words was 7 weeks seems about right but he as still pissed off with what the club told him to say. He thought he would get off. I never asked what he actually did.

degruch · Post: # 1089680Post **degruch** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:45pm

plugger66 wrote:
Thinline wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Thinline wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Sainternist wrote:3 weeks for boxing someone's ears to point of causing deafness. Quite lenient when put into context.

Remember, Steven Baker was given 10 weeks for accidently running into Jeff Farmer.
They both got 4 weeks and it was no accident.
How do you know re Baker?

If you saw it, what did you see?

I've always wanted to know myself...
No I never saw it. Wish i had of. He actually told me one night.
And what did he tell you?
I think his exact words was 7 weeks seems about right but he as still pissed off with what the club told him to say. He thought he would get off. I never asked what he actually did.

I didn't think there was any doubt Bakes did something, deliberately, it was just the audacity of the tribunal to give him 7 weeks with no evidence to charge him with!

plugger66 · Post: # 1089681Post **plugger66** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:46pm

degruch wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Thinline wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Thinline wrote:
plugger66 wrote:
Sainternist wrote:3 weeks for boxing someone's ears to point of causing deafness. Quite lenient when put into context.

Remember, Steven Baker was given 10 weeks for accidently running into Jeff Farmer.
They both got 4 weeks and it was no accident.
How do you know re Baker?

If you saw it, what did you see?

I've always wanted to know myself...
No I never saw it. Wish i had of. He actually told me one night.
And what did he tell you?
I think his exact words was 7 weeks seems about right but he as still pissed off with what the club told him to say. He thought he would get off. I never asked what he actually did.
I didn't think there was any doubt Bakes did something, deliberately, it was just the audacity of the tribunal to give him 7 weeks with no evidence to charge him with!

As i said he was pissed off with our defence.

jonesy · Post: # 1089684Post **jonesy** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:49pm

use your 'head' and you might figure out what he did...

Eastern · Post: # 1089690Post **Eastern** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:55pm

plugger66 wrote:
As i said he was pissed off with our defence.

And he wasn't the ONLY one who was pissed off with what hapened before and during that Tribunal Hearing. From what I have heard & read there were two ways they could have gone. They chose the defence they did and the rest is history !!

saintbrat · Post: # 1089691Post **saintbrat** » Mon 13 Jun 2011 7:55pm

Complete this conversation

AFL; "Brent can you tel us about Saturday night?"

Brent:

maybe Brent: "you want me to turn out the light."