Blake out !!

[Middo]

Week after week caught holding & grabbing and giving away free kicks , really not up to it now please time for Tom Simpkin..!!!

[plugger66]

Week after week caught holding & grabbing and giving away free kicks , really not up to it now please time for Tom Simpkin..!!!

He wont whilst we need a second ruckman.

[Middo]

Hopefully Hickey is good to go , Blake really needs to be back up at best .

[Old Mate]

yep, he needs to go. i get that we don't want to disrupt stanley's game so we need someone else to give mac a chop out but surely we can go to maister...or hickey back in.

[Con Gorozidis]

In: Hickey Simpkin
Out: Blake Lee

(Newnes might fall out for Dunell or Siposs)

[saintsRrising]

Week after week caught holding & grabbing and giving away free kicks , really not up to it now please time for Tom Simpkin..!!!

He wont whilst we need a second ruckman.

Not enough reason any more.

Ben can ruck most of the game. Maister or Lee can jump for a few minutes a quarter to spell him.

[plugger66]

Week after week caught holding & grabbing and giving away free kicks , really not up to it now please time for Tom Simpkin..!!!

He wont whilst we need a second ruckman.

Not enough reason any more.

Ben can ruck most of the game. Maister or Lee can jump for a few minutes a quarter to spell him.

Well it obviously is at the moment oe wouldnt have played. I wish you were right.

[8856brother]

Love Blake but he's cooked. I can't cope with the frees he is giving away. One on one, my poodle would beat him ATM.

[kimberly saint]

few people think lee should be dropped also , surely give him 2 or three games before we chop him lee that is

[plugger66]

few people think lee should be dropped also , surely give him 2 or three games before we chop him lee that is

That may seem ok but im not sure you can drop Blake and not bring in Hickey and you certainly cant play Lee and Hickey in the same side.

[Toy Saint]

Hey Plugger, would you tolerate dropping Blake and bringing in Kosi as the backup ruckman?

And whilst we're 'retiring' some loyal servants, does anybody see an ongoing role for Clint Jones?

[kimberly saint]

few people think lee should be dropped also , surely give him 2 or three games before we chop him lee that is

That may seem ok but im not sure you can drop Blake and not bring in Hickey and you certainly cant play Lee and Hickey in the same side.

yer fair point makes us very top heavy with hicky in as insurance for ben. How maister fair today ???, just like to see lee backed in for couple games cant expect blokes to come in and tear it up first game. If not tuff love i guess, he will have to just go back and wait for his chance

[plugger66]

Hey Plugger, would you tolerate dropping Blake and bringing in Kosi as the backup ruckman?

And whilst we're 'retiring' some loyal servants, does anybody see an ongoing role for Clint Jones?

Kosi would want to be good tomorrow but he still cant play if Lee plays. CJ wasnt good today but has had 2 good games. Deserves to play next week.

[BigMart]

Blake had 5 kicked on him by three opponents.... Not sure if his quality back up ruck work can keep him in...

Maister is close to being a reasonable player.... Just doesnt quite cut it.... Trier but

My call
In Simpkin, Kosi
Out Maister, Blake

Or

Stanley backs up the ruck from the back half

[plugger66]

Blake had 5 kicked on him by three opponents.... Not sure if his quality back up ruck work can keep him in...

Maister is close to being a reasonable player.... Just doesnt quite cut it.... Trier but

My call
In Simpkin, Kosi
Out Maister, Blake

Or

Stanley backs up the ruck from the back half

There is no way maister will miss out. Not sure who will come in. It depends on tomorrow. Hope Hickey is good.

[bobmurray]

Hey Plugger, would you tolerate dropping Blake and bringing in Kosi as the backup ruckman?

And whilst we're 'retiring' some loyal servants, does anybody see an ongoing role for Clint Jones?

Ask the coach...he's the one who has the REAL answers....anything else is pure speculation

[plugger66]

Hey Plugger, would you tolerate dropping Blake and bringing in Kosi as the backup ruckman?

And whilst we're 'retiring' some loyal servants, does anybody see an ongoing role for Clint Jones?

Ask the coach...he's the one who has the REAL answers....anything else is pure speculation

Watters isnt around and I am clearly the next best option.

[bobmurray]

Hey Plugger, would you tolerate dropping Blake and bringing in Kosi as the backup ruckman?

And whilst we're 'retiring' some loyal servants, does anybody see an ongoing role for Clint Jones?

Ask the coach...he's the one who has the REAL answers....anything else is pure speculation

Watters isnt around and I am clearly the next best option.

Did you answer the question

[plugger66]

Ask the coach...he's the one who has the REAL answers....anything else is pure speculation

Watters isnt around and I am clearly the next best option.

Did you answer the question

No. The question was far to hard.

[BigMart]

Please Don't enter into discussion with me, or comment on my posts.....I have made a decision not to debate any issues with you.... At all

[joffaboy]

Please Don't enter into discussion with me, or comment on my posts.....I have made a decision not to debate any issues with you.... At all

This is an open forum. You cant demand that. You can choose not to respond to P66. Better still put him on ignore if you dont want to engage, but he has the right to comment on any post on an open forum.

[plugger66]

Please Don't enter into discussion with me, or comment on my posts.....I have made a decision not to debate any issues with you.... At all

This is an open forum. You cant demand that. You can choose not to respond to P66. Better still put him on ignore if you dont want to engage, but he has the right to comment on any post on an open forum.

Well said and I if anyone said maister should be dropped i would say the same. No idea why i wouldnt be on his for list. I will comment on anyones post if i disagree.

[bobmurray]

Please Don't enter into discussion with me, or comment on my posts.....I have made a decision not to debate any issues with you.... At all

This is an open forum. You cant demand that. You can choose not to respond to P66. Better still put him on ignore if you dont want to engage, but he has the right to comment on any post on an open forum.

Well said and I if anyone said maister should be dropped i would say the same. No idea why i wouldnt be on his for list. I will comment on anyones post if i disagree.

You are already on his for list........the option is the foe list

[Wrote for Luck]

Blake has to go. Poor in defence and cruelled in the ruck.

[BigMart]

Joffa

I didn't demand, I politely said...

I just want to save him the time of replying when I have no interest or comment to make in relation....