If GWS said they wanted.....

[citywest]

Joey and Dal plus our second pick (probably pick 23), in exchange for their pick 1, would you do it?
Discuss.

[plugger66]

id throw in TDL as well.

[citywest]

id throw in TDL as well.

You obviously don't think GWS would go for it, or you would not do it?

[citywest]

correction, our second pick would be 21 not 23.

[8856brother]

I would have thought Crocker and Raf would get it done. Maybe throw in Charlie Gardiner as a sweetener. Dal and Monty are too old and have little currency.

[plugger66]

I would have thought Crocker and Raf would get it done. Maybe throw in Charlie Gardiner as a sweetener. Dal and Monty are too old and have little currency.

Well if they are to hard surely gardiner and maybe even Raf are as well. Probably need younger guys like LJ conners and justin Sweeney.

[matrix]

yup joey and dal and a second round pick for pick one

when we're likey to get pick 2 3 or 4

troll thread surely

[ShanghaiSaint]

why not just hand every senior play over as well.. hell our 2014 season will be just like there 2013... yeh great idea.

[Con Gorozidis]

Joey and Dal plus our second pick (probably pick 23), in exchange for their pick 1, would you do it?
Discuss.

nope

way too much risk.

that would leave us with 2 less mids and only 2 picks in the top 40. wed be worse off.

id want 3 picks in the top 40 before i looked at a trade.

[saintspremiers]

Joey and Dal plus our second pick (probably pick 23), in exchange for their pick 1, would you do it?
Discuss.

I'd suggest BFUSA bans you for being a repetitive troll.

[plugger66]

Joey and Dal plus our second pick (probably pick 23), in exchange for their pick 1, would you do it?
Discuss.

I'd suggest BFUSA bans you for being a repetitive troll.

I would hope not because it would only be a rumour. IMO he says things that I totally disagree with but I have seen nothing to suggest he isnt a saints supporter and also he never says anything really against the rules. Seen nothing to suggest he follows us either but at least he creates discussion even if its a bit stupid. We dont want to make this forum a love in with no robust discussion surely.

[ShanghaiSaint]

we need the city wests or it wouldn't be fun on here.

[matrix]

agreed
nothing like a stupid robust discussion to liven up a sunday arvo

[Majority]

Trade citywest to

http://www.gwsforums.com/

He would not even have to change his name.

[Con Gorozidis]

yes i am aware cw is trolling but i thought id answer him/her anyway

[citywest]

Thanks guys, I think.
GWS has stated that they have enough young talent and want more experienced heads. Dal and Joey are still young enough for them to be around in 3 or 4 years which is when GWS will be gunning for a premiership. I reckon GWS would at least look at this deal and if they went for it the end result would be.....

Saints lose Dal, Joey and pick 21.
Saints gain pick 1.

Giants lose pick1.
Giants gain Dal, Joey and pick 21.

In summary.
Saints could use pick 1 for Boyd (KPF) and their own pick 3 for Aish (Mid)
Giants would have 2 ready made mids to help their young stars and pick 21 to trade for another experienced player.

Win win in my opinion.

My only question mark is would GWS take this? I think they would but I'm not sure.

[BackFromUSA]

As GWS want a ruckman and key back ... I would consider:

Saints lose TDL, Fisher and Stanley.
Saints gain pick 1 and 20.

Leaves us with 1, 3, 20 and 21.

[whiskers3614]

As GWS want a ruckman and key back ... I would consider:

Saints lose TDL, Fisher and Stanley.
Saints gain pick 1 and 20.

Leaves us with 1, 3, 20 and 21.

If you can get that deal done see if you can also sell them Sydney harbour bridge!
Stanley for pick 20 would be reasonable, so you are suggesting pick 1 for a broken down 30year old and a bloke who we will/should delist?

[bergholt]

Saints lose TDL, Fisher and Stanley.
Saints gain pick 1 and 20.

Leaves us with 1, 3, 20 and 21.

That would look more favourable for GWS if TDL wasn't included. Still massively over the odds though.

[ShanghaiSaint]

As GWS want a ruckman and key back ... I would consider:

Saints lose TDL, Fisher and Stanley.
Saints gain pick 1 and 20.

Leaves us with 1, 3, 20 and 21.

stanley is not included... going forward he could be anything.

[ljpoyz]

The club would take this deal in a second.

[St Ick]

As GWS want a ruckman and key back ... I would consider:

Saints lose TDL, Fisher and Stanley.
Saints gain pick 1 and 20.

Leaves us with 1, 3, 20 and 21.

stanley is not included... going forward he could be anything.

We'd be lucky to get pick 10 for Fisher and Stanley to be honest.

[plugger66]

As GWS want a ruckman and key back ... I would consider:

Saints lose TDL, Fisher and Stanley.
Saints gain pick 1 and 20.

Leaves us with 1, 3, 20 and 21.

stanley is not included... going forward he could be anything.

We'd be lucky to get pick 10 for Fisher and Stanley to be honest.

We wouldnt. Its that simple. stanley is still completely unproven and Fisher is an injured 30 year old with issues.

[savatage]

As GWS want a ruckman and key back ... I would consider:

Saints lose TDL, Fisher and Stanley.
Saints gain pick 1 and 20.

Leaves us with 1, 3, 20 and 21.

If you can get that deal done see if you can also sell them Sydney harbour bridge!

Agreed!

[Sainternist]

Trade citywest to

http://www.gwsforums.com/

He would not even have to change his name.

+1

Whatever it takes to get rid of an Essendon troll.