I don't think it's worth it personally.

Fisher is an interesting one. Would be a pretty juicy FA prospect for a top side you would think.

I agree on the stadium deal. We should just say 'f*** you' to the AFL, walk out of the deal and play our games somewhere else. Let them pay off their own stadium. The fact that we pay to play is a joke. Obviously that's not very realistic but man, that stadium deal stinks and has been screwing us fo...

Good news. I loved Ahmed, has a lot to offer and still young.

Our recruiting of first picks in the last decade is exactly why we're in the shyte right now. The tragedy goes as follows : 2003: Raph Clarke 2004: Andrew McQualter 2005: Fergus Watts 2006: David Armitage 2007: Ben McEvoy 2008: Tom Lynch 2009: traded for Andrew Lovett 2010: Jamie Cripps So of that ...

Tough decision this one. Very important that we get a good'un.

Would make it a lot easier if the AFL gave us a PP and we landed them both

GC, Dogs and Tiges are the winnables.

IIRC Ball wasn't happy with the contract he was offered. Felt it was disrespectful considering his achievements. I don't blame him to be honest.

Got offered a lot more by the Pies and proved to be a bloody good player there.

Lyon didn't rate him for some odd reason.

Any chance someone could put it on youtube?

So we can assume that a number of those in the side are playing for their careers over the next seven weeks.

The implications of Joey's comments on the Footy Show raise a bit of a conundrum...is he to be applauded for showing loyalty to a great mate, which is a great attribute in ny team sport...or is it an indictment on Montagna's lack of respect for authority and the feeling that senior players were run...

If Dal was still in our side he would be tagged out and cop heaps on here. A few times BJ got tagged he didn't go very well,opposition would line him up too. Sure if all the exits were still here we'd be more competitive hanging around 9th forever. Business. I also see the reason in this. Thank you...

Bruce must certainly be wondering what he has to do to get back in.

I was sad to see Dal go, but he was so poor last season that I think it was the best for all involved for him to head to the Kangas.

The one that hurts is Goddard. Would love to see him still at the club, it was very weak of us to let him leave and we didn't really get good value for him.

The idea of it getting worse than this year is pretty unnerving. Still, a very distinct possibility. I still think injuries have played a huge part in our bad form this year.

Pick 1 should never be traded unless we get an unbelievable offer like a ready made near elite player plus a top 10 pick. Otherwise let's just shoot ourselves in the foot and show the afl world that we really are a basket case. . Completely agree. Pick 1 should only be traded for a star. It's pick ...

Looks like he'll permanently have tape on his dodgy shoulders. Not a good sign. Really think it's the nail on his career. Wayne Carey permanently had shoulder tape. How did he go? Yep. Lee will be another Carey. Thanks for clearing that up! Lee's a spud like Siposs. But I fear both will clog our li...

If he's good to go then I think we should pick him up for sure. He is 26, that's a great age, and he's a gun. Would immediately beef up our forward line.

I think he would be a fantastic pick up for us, and could be a great story too.

What do we know about this kid? Can you enlighten me. I've a feeling he's number one, not based on any mail mind you.

Definitely a season to forget for poor old Tom. Hope he can get the body right for next year.

Agree with plugger. We're crying out for midfielders that can win the football and use it. We need about ten more at the moment.

Once we have that, watch the forwards thrive.

Having just watched his highlights from the VFL, there is so much to like about Spencer. His body size and pace are perfect. I'm glad that he's finally finding a bit of form in the VFL firsts, I think we should keep him there and see how he continues to improve. Watching him though, it's just so exc...

Very stern words from Richo. This weeks outs will tell a story, I suspect some of them may never come back in. This is a good thing by the way, if effort is a problem then we need to weed out those that aren't giving enough. Looking at the stats, I wonder if Montagna may be looked at. 13 disposals a...

Pathetic thread. Billings will be a star.

Ok I must be missing something, if Ross Lyon stayed what would be the difference? Dean Polo would be captain. If anyone is wondering why we're stufed at the moment have a read of this.... http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/new-saints-find-their-way-home-20101124-187g9.html That picture certainly...