You couldn't be more wrong, it's a done deal Mind telling what pick it is for then? And why isn't hasn't gone through yet? There is still a lot of water to go under the bridge and Saints are even cooling on Hickey a little at this point. Plus, despite reports, the Pies are beginning to become very ...

Con Gorozidis wrote:Sounds like Hickey is a done deal with the Saints. Just working on details.

You couldn't be more wrong...

AFL site and a few others saying we have interest in Greg Broughton.

He could be ok at the right price.

The Saints send pick 37 to GCS for Tom Hickey Then we send Farren Ray to Melbourne for Jordan Gysberts Cripps & 25 to WCE for Brown & 61. Would leave us with picks 13, 46, 57, 61 Etc. 4 picks in the first 3 rounds plus a ruck, mid, KPD! Thoughts? I'd think that would probably be the ideal s...

Why is all the attention on Raph? Wny not C.J.? Or even Sam Gilbert who makes as many stuff ups as Raph ever did. Why is all the hatred poured out on Raph? Raph is out of contract and so far hasn't been offered a new contract, while Jones and Gilbert are contracted. And I must be reading a differen...

If Ray leaves, I'd give Raph another year on a minimum contract. There's nothing wrong with having a couple of experienced guys running around at Sandy for depth. Unfortunately as much as I try and tell myself, we are no longer vying for a premiership, therefore our 'depth' players should be kids. ...

Potential potential potential. Is far from a sure thing but he is a bit Ahmed Saad like in the sense that he is very new to the game. Quayle comments excite me but also concern me, I really don't want to spend pick 13 on him! While yes, he is mainly potential, it is worth noting that every player w...

There was a rumour that the Eagles inquired about Hooker from Essendon, if that rumour is true, Brown is very much on the table. However, this is just a rumour and could easily be false in which case, Brown is no chance.

It's very hard to quantify value for a second-year project ruckman. He has a lot of potential and could 'potentially' because a A grade ruckman, but at the same time he could turn into a flop, it's just too difficult to say at this early point in his career, considering how long it takes for ruckman...

If Melbourne offer us something half decent, sorry but you'd have to trade him. I thought he played well this year in the games he got, but the fact is Watters doesn't see as part of the best 22. He's on the fringe and Watters would rather go with younger guy to deveop than play Ray, which is fair e...

So people want to give Pick 25 for a player who won't be in our best 22?

Because Riewoldt has never played CHB in his life and he isn't going start at age 30.

I think I found the solution.

F. Ray for J. Frawley
Pick 13 for G. Ablett
Pick 25 for N. Naitanui

Premiership 2013?

If we spend any more than Pick 34 on Hickey I'd be disappointed. Even 34 is a tad too much...

Thread has a bit of de ja vu about it.

The Free Agency period finishes tomorrow. It feels like it started on Boxing Day. You can bet that we wont be told the pick numbers until Monday. The geniuses finish the Trade Period at 2pm, but no, the FA period finishes at 5pm. The precious ones would have knocked off for the weekend by then. We ...

There is a rumour that GWS offered Pick 2 for Sam Fisher. St Kilda has declined, but if you were in charge would YOU do the trade and start the full rebuild? Personally I'm happy the Saints have said no. If we start trading our top players who offer valuable leadership for high picks, we are pretty ...

Free agency isn't meant to be fair compo. We're lucky we got anything for Goddard. You can't compare that to a trade where both parties are agreeing to a deal.

What's the rush? Most other trade periods in sports around the world go for a lot longer.

I'd rather the club make patient calculated decisions, rather than rush it all and make a bad trade because they only had a week.

Steven or Boughton would be a similar pick imo. Both pretty young but haven't done much yet and look like they want opportunity elsewhere. Both could be anything. Broughton is about 3 times the player Stevens is at the moment. He would be a great pick up. The only problem is why is he even mentione...

People need to realise that not everything they hear in the media is actually happening and just because it isn't in the media doesn't mean it isn't happening.

OK, not so smallish, but the question still remains for me - is he primarily a ruckman or a defender? The most I know of him is that I had him in my Dreamteam the year before last, very cheap, and his numbers were consistently pretty good, but that doesn't necessarily translate into influence in a ...

probally watched him as much as you have,does that mean we both know f*** all.........some people I just find it hilarious that you can cast judgement on someone when you clearly haven't seen them play as you don't know what position they play. Please don't speak on behalf of myself as well, thanks.

imo we dont need another small forward,behind milne,saad and milera Not a small forward... he is a inside mid. But I wouldn't go after him. still no Because obviously you have watched him a lot? He is an ok player, but he will suffer the same fate at the Saints as he did at North. He is just behind...

No.