Think the question is do we think he'll ever be an A grader? I don't know the answer - it's 50/50 IMO Been a solid contributor this year without starring. That's why I think he could be traded. We could cover losing him but he has value in the trade market as part of getting a genuine star in the do...

If we are going to trade "quality" it won't be Jack Steven.
My guess would be Jack Newnes, which would hurt but if it was part of a Bennell trade I think we'd settle for it.

Milera? Lil' Wayne is from SA though. On a side note there are two or three South Aussies I reckon could be nice late picks. I really Like Will Snelling, Stephen Tahana- Knightmare says he might not even get drafted but has great touch. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kgtU_RJT7Ak a bit like Shane s...

loris wrote:Very strong footy pedigree too..................... both Dad & his uncle have played AFL footy.

Ok I'm keen to play.
Two words....second word sounds like?

LTN16 wrote:

stjay wrote:

LTN16 wrote:Spencer can't get a game in the Sandringham seniors let alone for the saints and people think we will trade him for a first round selection.. We may get 2 top 10 picks if we trade Markworth!?

Aaaah, in one word - No.

Maybe 2 top 10 picks and a player?

Forget it. He has no trade value.

Well you wouldn't want to spend too much money on Aish which could upset others when we could use our first pick on our own gun who doesn't have history of being upset with their club. Straight swap for Spencer seeing you think hes worth a first round pick? You're joking right? Spencer is OOC &...

LTN16 wrote:Spencer can't get a game in the Sandringham seniors let alone for the saints and people think we will trade him for a first round selection.. We may get 2 top 10 picks if we trade Markworth!?

Aaaah, in one word - No.

Well you wouldn't want to spend too much money on Aish which could upset others when we could use our first pick on our own gun who doesn't have history of being upset with their club. Straight swap for Spencer seeing you think hes worth a first round pick? You're joking right? Spencer is OOC &...

Given the recent poor return for the number of inside 50's and a couple other random events, I am starting to suspect we could have a new forwards coach by year end. Probably wrong but have a sneaking suspicion.

Check out "On the couch" from Monday night - they lay out the equation perfectly. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r-e0lg5j6LY 13.43mins It is the average scores against vs. scores for. They show where every team is sitting and that the "premiership quadrant" is less than 80 point...

Excellent news - this guy will only get better. Plenty of upside.
Puts paid to the idea that he's going to be trade bait - at least for this trade period.

We might have lost to Norf today however it is certain that Norf will never win a Premiership with their current playing squad and Brad Scott as coach and in 2 years time we will have gone past them Our future looks brighter while they will be left treading water Agreed. They're massive pretenders....

I see where Carlton stalwart , Alex Marcou reckons that disastrous recruiting has been at the core of Carlton's problems, and that there recruiting hasbeen shocking for the best part of ten years. He reckons that they have never had the right guy in charge . He then goes on to name a decade of top ...

Cannot believe Wayne Hughes despite the different role was ever considered based on Carlton's recruiting performance.

Has to be a back story there. Unusual to make this change mid-season. They're not doing that. The article says "Current High Performance Manager, Adam Basil, will continue in the role until the end of the season. Hornsby will start with the club in October." Presumably Basil decided it wa...

Agree with others suggesting it wont happen! He is contracted and unless he is completely damaged goods there is no way the Suns release him after all they have been thru! Barrett was just creating fodder for the media train -move on people to more realistic targets! After the story hit there was m...

Has to be a back story there. Unusual to make this change mid-season.

3) Club has stated that #5/6 will only be traded for a certain player who is not Bennell Bennell Please explain. +1 Can't let this slip thru to the 'keeper.... So there's only one player in the league who we would trade our first pick for? I doubt that. Bennell would be a worthy candidate. Sounds l...

I don't know what this guy can become. As others have mentioned, he certainly knows how to win his own ball and can get plenty of it. He had a stinker on the weekend - I don't know how you can put any other spin on it - it wasn't AFL standard. Watched the replay and his errors stood out. Maybe he ge...

Got a sneeky suspicion Hickey may keep his spot just based off Richo end-of-game presser comments (pretty vague). Can't understand all the trade talk on SS around Hickey. When you think about possible rule changes to lower the interchange rotations, that will call for ruck types that can rest forwar...

Markworth is the only one of the three that's a chance to get a game this year. And that's mainly because he hasn't had that chance over the past two seasons, rather than his form this year for Sandy. The clock was ticking on Spencer ever since he received only a one year contract last year - i.e. ...

Where did the notion of us trading our pick 6 for Carlisle ever come from?
When you listen to everything coming out of the club we are desparate to get another high quality mid and I agree.
The chance of us trading our first pick are 1 out of 10 tops.
Best guess - pick #6 Rhys Mathieson

. The day Humpty Dumpty fell off the wall! No amount of "Kings horses" or "AFL men" will mend the rift created on this day . . Strongly stated opinions pro or con only confirm your own bias . . don't expect to change the "other"! So you are saying he was wrong to stop ...

. The day Humpty Dumpty fell off the wall! No amount of "Kings horses" or "AFL men" will mend the rift created on this day . . Strongly stated opinions pro or con only confirm your own bias . . don't expect to change the "other"! So you are saying he was wrong to stop ...

The Fireman wrote:I don't want to resort to name calling but I really feel the need to say this and am prepared for any wrath from the mods but
I've come to the conclusion that stjay is either unintelligent or simply a sh*t stirrer...i'm going with both.

Get over it pal, everyone's moved on except you.