5. X Clarke
4. S. Fisher
3. M. Gardiner
2. M. Hudghton
1. S. Milne

If at a minimum Goddard comes in next week who goes out? it's very difficult maybe gilbert? then you have the added issue of; Goose- still think he'll be a couple weeks off Jones- missed his fwd pressure at times Gardiner- allows mobile target without becoming top heavy Armo- Showed form when played...

I'm sorry,

played really well tonight.. sorry I doubted you, expected too much straight back from injury.

the man runs as hard as anyone in the team... doesn't stop, ever. and then to take a mark like that when he knew what was going to happen is amazing... right in front of me his thought process seemed to go like this my mark oh s*** its in the air a lot big man running at me I'm going to get hit F it...

damn have armo and jones in my SC team...

at least jones is awesome value : )

I think out of those 5 this week the max they will bring back is BJ- Fiora prob, although I like him : ( Gehrig- L Fisher prob (which is hard because he did his job! depth! Blake- Gilbert now this would be a hard decision essentially those who I considered outside of above a ruckman charlie (felt he...

fish destroyed blakes usual man

port...

went something different...

was tempted to go swans solely because if they won i'd be more than halfway to winning

I said the same thing a couple weeks back

love the guy.. but question his value now...

yes great spoiler... but offers nothing on the rebound... and I think the injurys may of made him lose pace

I dunno. Milne persists in doing everything he can to endeavour he will fail alot of the time. How was he last night when in the clear from about 30 out slight angle he dropped the ball ACROSS his boot !!! Totally unecessary. Thankfully there was none of his ridiculous play on from a mark inside 50...

yeah sorry you guys are right...

perhaps archie meant they'd all still get 11 games at thier home ground?

this bit confused me... "(But) you obviously can't do that just with the Swans playing there, so it might well mean that teams from all around the country have got to play games at (ANZ) Stadium. " Potentially that means a modification of the existing fixture, it doesn't necessarily mean ...

you guys don't think your teams have too much reliance on the saints players?

unneccessary

I previouslly hadn't thought of vet list + so maybe max could play on next year : )

I expect both rix and blake to become backmen over the coming year with blake still more of a utility...

Max is aging as great as he is and will occasionally find him self getting beaten

I firmly believe it is his last year

I've just created a Herald Sun SuperCoach league for anyone to join.

229727

Hope to see you guys there.. I'm really pumped for it this year.

http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/

How about we play the first proper game of the season at least before plonking some bloke's head on the chopping block at season's end? Fair dinkum ... :roll: 2 reasons 1) its an interesting guage of how people rate the players 2) its a challenging exercise that illistrates our depth.. seriouslly I...

I think RL has made it very clear his intentions

playing the best team available but managing the game time of those alot of people would be calling to rest.

I think this is a good approach as alot of the players need match fitness

I know it's way too early to speculate , but i'm bored. Who would be on the chopping block for delisting at the end of this year? Required Additions - 3 National Draft Picks. Probable Additions - 2 or 3 Rookies (This is VR, Eddy, and Attard's last year on the list) Possible Additions - PSD Pick, 4t...

I'd agree re defensive ability re max... and I love the service he provided and still does but today you have to be able to offer something on the rebound... he seems lost when he gets the ball confused and honestly like blake when he's having one of those bad decision days. I'd consider playing a w...

going to cause a stir.. but based on tonights game...

when goose is up and running, I'd almost be disappointed if max got a game.

I love the guy and all just think the backilne is better without him... but maybe he was just rusty

thought rix played well in defence... wasn't very attacking but went alright

you have one c gard twice

seems a pretty honest character with the "enjoying myself but don't bond without playing together"


which gives credit to

"pretty similiar to the cats"