Out
Roo
Sinclair
Lonie

In
Acres
Membrey
Saad

What id like to see
Out
Roo
Sinclair
Lonie (con)
Shenton
Templeton

In
Acres
Membrey
Minchington
Goddard
Curren (inside mid only)

Love the way he goes about it. Unfortunately has a massive height disadvantage with forwards in today's game all 195+

Last year we seemed to have highlight packages of players each week in the vfl. What has happened to that?? Looking through other club websites, it seems that they have certain highlight packages of stand out games from youngsters. Being an interstate supporter, i really appreciated the weekly vfl 2...

Plugger, the whole we have a chance of winning thing I dont get. We played the most conservative team in gws and lost, same with carlton and collingwood which we thought we could win. We ended up getting pumped in 2 of those games. Now against essesndon we were writing how much the losing margin was...

dragit wrote:

S.A Saint wrote:

dragit wrote:none love for Schneider?

You have a problem with me not rating Schneider?

massive one
i challenge you to a duel

keep it in your pants

dragit wrote:none love for Schneider?

You have a problem with me not rating Schneider?

borderbarry wrote:5... Armo.
4....Bruce
3....Dempster
2.....Lonie
1....Steven

x2

I think people's frustration comes from him being spectacularly average at kicking clutch goals. Those one's you think "gee we really need this", Schneider's record is poor. Agree with this. And to think it was his clutch goals that killed us in the 2005 Prelim. Still, he's been a super p...

FQF wrote:Playing Joey in the VFL, dropping Acres... some craziness going on here.

i dont think its that crazy at all to have joey play a game in the ressies to get match conditioning after a month or so out. Its not like we are challanging for a flag

I would do Roo in for Schnieder and let him play around the wing area as that get out of jail kick with bruce deep forward. Or Roo and Joey in for Scneider and one of sinclair/acres/mckenzie. Would have Monty have one more week off But he is fit according to the club. Im going for Roo for Hickey or...

I would do Roo in for Schnieder and let him play around the wing area as that get out of jail kick with bruce deep forward. Or Roo and Joey in for Scneider and one of sinclair/acres/mckenzie. Would have Monty have one more week off But he is fit according to the club. Im going for Roo for Hickey or...

I would do Roo in for Schnieder and let him play around the wing area as that get out of jail kick with bruce deep forward.

Or Roo and Joey in for Scneider and one of sinclair/acres/mckenzie.

Would have Monty have one more week off

Scoop

What player has the ? Hanging over him..

Im pretty dissapointed with some of the selections to be honest. Now before some of you jump down my throat I will say this, Bruce should never be played in the forward line when we have lee, white and Paddy as actual forwards. I would understand if we had no forward tall options available, but for ...

Dempster Delaney Geary Roberton Fisher Savage Newnes Weller Acres Billings Roo White Membrey McCartin Lonie Hickey Steven Dunstan Saunders Sinclair Shenton sub: Bruce If monty is fit then he comes in for Shenton, and if they really want to use bruce as second ruck then he replaces roberton in the si...

Just signed my first membership!

Go the Saints!!!

Are we getting anything done with the swans.. Surely we would have gotten Tim Membrey by now!

Hate to agree with you Trav, but you are 100% correct

3. Billings
18. Dunstan
19. Jones

I would be over the moon if we ended up with these 3 guys. Combine that with a successful trade period and we have really set ourself up for a quicker rebuild than most would expect.

Our midfield has been woweful for the last couple of years since he has been there.. Dont think it will be a massive loss as some people are suggesting

What picks or players are we exchanging for him?

Here are some of the stats for this season. I mean they dont paint the full story but all the forwards are pretty much in the same ball park the only difference is that saad and milera do have a few years on their side. I would personally be dropping milne for his efforts than the two others. Give ...

Here are some of the stats for this season. I mean they dont paint the full story but all the forwards are pretty much in the same ball park the only difference is that saad and milera do have a few years on their side. I would personally be dropping milne for his efforts than the two others. Give h...

All those who have been bagging gilbert about his disposal need to take a leaf out of his book.. Dont think he missed a target!

Look we can blame the umpires, the birds, the grass, the hot weather, but there is one thing you cant be is that we have THE worst disposal in the league by far!!