Stevie J playing forward coach

[CURLY]

Great for a year on field then in the box there after. Reckon our young forwards would learn a heap.

[prwilkinson]

Nah, He'll surely head to a club who think they're in the 'window' and want a top up player

[Teflon]

douchebag

[CURLY]

douchebag

Very smart footballer.

[dragit]

Would be more value than keeping Ray on another year IMO, as he brings others into the game.

[Teflon]

douchebag

Very smart footballer.

very selfish player

[CURLY]

douchebag

Very smart footballer.

very selfish player

Right up there in goal assists more years than not.

[elizabethr]

Absolute dick wad!

[supersaints]

No thank you...

[plugger66]

The last 3 threads I have read suggest drugs are involved.

[magnifisaint]

Why why why?
For starters he'd want to play finals. Secondly I don't think he'd want to play for St Kilda.

[matrix]

lol
yeah, he'll come to us


richmond or dogs i reckon

[LTN16]

Let's trade Jack Steven for him?

The Herald Sun might run with that story tomorrow..

[CURLY]

Would make an ideal replacement for Sneider and is a much better player. If he would come on three years one playing two coaching I would be happy with that.

[Toy Saint]

Reckon he'd be wrapt with a 12 month contract, would come relatively cheap, and would add a bit of class to our forward line.

The trade off is that he would add a positive to our forward line, but the negative is that he would take the place of a kid.

I'd be happy if we got him.

[plugger66]

Reckon he'd be wrapt with a 12 month contract, would come relatively cheap, and would add a bit of class to our forward line.

The trade off is that he would add a positive to our forward line, but the negative is that he would take the place of a kid.

I'd be happy if we got him.

I can honestly say I don't see the point. Anyway may as well start a thread that we are getting Fyffe because we have equal hope of both and that is exactly 0%.

[Toy Saint]

Reckon he'd be wrapt with a 12 month contract, would come relatively cheap, and would add a bit of class to our forward line.

The trade off is that he would add a positive to our forward line, but the negative is that he would take the place of a kid.

I'd be happy if we got him.

I can honestly say I don't see the point. Anyway may as well start a thread that we are getting Fyffe because we have equal hope of both and that is exactly 0%.

Well, I'll agree and disagree. Don't see the point; fair arguement. He may have one or two years left, certainly won't be in our next premership team, and he would deprive a kid of gaining match experience. But I disagree that we have no hope of getting him; my understanding is that he wants to play football and will probably take the best offer he gets. If we offer 'match payments', and a 12 month contract, and if there is no other interest (doubt it), he'll be happy to play for the Saints.

[Wayne42]

Some players just don't know when their time is up, Stevie J is one of them.

What will he do now that his playing days are done ?

[plugger66]

Reckon he'd be wrapt with a 12 month contract, would come relatively cheap, and would add a bit of class to our forward line.

The trade off is that he would add a positive to our forward line, but the negative is that he would take the place of a kid.

I'd be happy if we got him.

I can honestly say I don't see the point. Anyway may as well start a thread that we are getting Fyffe because we have equal hope of both and that is exactly 0%.

Well, I'll agree and disagree. Don't see the point; fair arguement. He may have one or two years left, certainly won't be in our next premership team, and he would deprive a kid of gaining match experience. But I disagree that we have no hope of getting him; my understanding is that he wants to play football and will probably take the best offer he gets. If we offer 'match payments', and a 12 month contract, and if there is no other interest (doubt it), he'll be happy to play for the Saints.

My reasoning that we have no hope of getting him is simple. Our club wont have the slightest interest and thank goodness. Great player but he needs to do to a side who gets knocked out in the semi's or prelim. Icing on the cake to them.

[CQ SAINT]

I would have thought McCartin Lonie Sinclair deserve the development more than we need Stevie J.

[St Chris]

Anyone who thinks Stevie J would be a good idea needs to remember Monkhorst and Tony Francis.

Their heart just aren't in it, especially if the new side is struggling.

[loris]

remember Monkhorst

Saw his head on telly last night..... obviously in some coaching role for the Hawks........... thought to myself: 'Only a mother could love that face'.

Gee he was standing at the back of the queue when God (or whoever) was handing out good looks!

[saintbrat]

I would have thought McCartin Lonie Sinclair deserve the development more than we need Stevie J.

and would have thought they already have an ideal, mature, known, high achieving Forward player to learn off- One N Riewoldt

[Con Gorozidis]

Personally I don't think Stevie J works for us. He will either go to a side in the top 6 or he wont go on. It wouldn't suit either party for him to go to a developing side down the bottom half. Hence why Geelong probably parted ways.

But these last two finals games have really shown the value of quality small fwds.
Le Cras, Hill, Cripps, Walters, Ballantyne, Betts, Cameron have kicked 20 goals between them. 4 of those 7 indigenous.

So hopefully Lonie, Billings and Sinclair can become regular goal scorers.