St Kilda Collingwood 2017 Rd 4

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

http://m.afl.com.au/match-centre/2017/4/coll-v-stk

Maybe the current Saints list isn't as bad as we might think.

[dragit]

I think you're clutching at straws again dude.

We have beaten the premiers in the H&W season on plenty of occasions.

4 scrappy wins this season tells a better story than 9 goals we kicked 18 months ago.

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

http://m.afl.com.au/match-centre/2018/15/melb-v-stk

http://m.afl.com.au/match-centre/2017/16/stk-v-rich

http://m.afl.com.au/match-centre/2017/20/stk-v-wce



"The greatest glory in living lies not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall."
-Nelson Mandela

[SaintPav]

[CURLY]

Give us the easiest draw and the greatest free kick differential and I think anything’s possible.

[SydneySainter]

http://m.afl.com.au/match-centre/2018/15/melb-v-stk

http://m.afl.com.au/match-centre/2017/16/stk-v-rich

http://m.afl.com.au/match-centre/2017/20/stk-v-wce



"The greatest glory in living lies not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall."
-Nelson Mandela

Haven’t you got a “this is why we should keep Richo” thread to create?

[dragit]

4 wins will get you the wooden spoon most years... 2 of our 4 wins were extremely lucky against fellow bottom 4 sides.

Stop trolling us.

[Scollop]

http://m.afl.com.au/match-centre/2017/4/coll-v-stk

Maybe the current Saints list isn't as bad as we might think.

Who is we? It doesn't matter what we fans think

Lethers doesn't have much faith in the list

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2018/05/24/ ... s-wallace/

Richo has been lamenting the lack of leaders all year.

Stuv is asking questions about whether the club is rebuilding...Why would he do that if the coaches and admin believed we had the list to be a contender?

[kosifantutti]

4 wins will get you the wooden spoon most years... 2 of our 4 wins were extremely lucky against fellow bottom 4 sides.

Stop trolling us.

4 wins is terrible but wins are wins and I can’t understand why a 25 point win is lucky.

[dragit]

4 wins will get you the wooden spoon most years... 2 of our 4 wins were extremely lucky against fellow bottom 4 sides.

Stop trolling us.

4 wins is terrible but wins are wins and I can’t understand why a 25 point win is lucky.

I think we were lucky to play Brisbane when we did, they improved a lot over the year and were a far more dangerous side than us overall.

We went into the game basically at full strength against the reigning wooden spooners, they lost Rich early in the game but were still in front late in the 3rd quarter… 25 points is pretty flattering IMO, I thought we were lucky to get away with a win in the end.

Ironically after this very ordinary game, richo claimed that we had a lot of A graders and we have enough talent on the list to challenge

http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2018/1/stk-v-bl

[SydneySainter]

4 wins will get you the wooden spoon most years... 2 of our 4 wins were extremely lucky against fellow bottom 4 sides.

Stop trolling us.

4 wins is terrible but wins are wins and I can’t understand why a 25 point win is lucky.

I think we were lucky to play Brisbane when we did, they improved a lot over the year and were a far more dangerous side than us overall.

We went into the game basically at full strength against the reigning wooden spooners, they lost Rich early in the game but were still in front late in the 3rd quarter… 25 points is pretty flattering IMO, I thought we were lucky to get away with a win in the end.

Ironically after this very ordinary game, richo claimed that we had a lot of A graders and we have enough talent on the list to challenge

http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2018/1/stk-v-bl

I said the same thing about 5 or 6 rounds into the season. I copped a bit of eye-rolling at that point.

[Superboot]

I think you're clutching at straws again dude.

We have beaten the premiers in the H&W season on plenty of occasions.

Carlton at Waverley 1995 was the best I can remember

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

4 wins will get you the wooden spoon most years... 2 of our 4 wins were extremely lucky against fellow bottom 4 sides.

Stop trolling us.

4 wins is terrible but wins are wins and I can’t understand why a 25 point win is lucky.

Only new here, but your signature sums it up well.

[SydneySainter]

4 wins will get you the wooden spoon most years... 2 of our 4 wins were extremely lucky against fellow bottom 4 sides.

Stop trolling us.

4 wins is terrible but wins are wins and I can’t understand why a 25 point win is lucky.

Only new here, but your signature sums it up well.

Hi Parkey.

[st.byron]

4 wins will get you the wooden spoon most years... 2 of our 4 wins were extremely lucky against fellow bottom 4 sides.

Stop trolling us.

4 wins is terrible but wins are wins and I can’t understand why a 25 point win is lucky.

Only new here, but your signature sums it up well.

LOL.....
Parkeysainter disappears, Ted arrives. What a coincidence.

[Scollop]

4 wins will get you the wooden spoon most years... 2 of our 4 wins were extremely lucky against fellow bottom 4 sides.

Stop trolling us.

4 wins is terrible but wins are wins and I can’t understand why a 25 point win is lucky.

I think we were lucky to play Brisbane when we did, they improved a lot over the year and were a far more dangerous side than us overall.

We went into the game basically at full strength against the reigning wooden spooners, they lost Rich early in the game but were still in front late in the 3rd quarter… 25 points is pretty flattering IMO, I thought we were lucky to get away with a win in the end.

Ironically after this very ordinary game, richo claimed that we had a lot of A graders and we have enough talent on the list to challenge

http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2018/1/stk-v-bl

5 weeks after Richo thought his players would challenge for a flag he claims his players skills were sub par for AFL level!?!

If the head coach doesn't know whether he's coming or going; whether he's Arthur or Martha or whether we are contenders or sub par pretenders, how the hell are the players going to have any faith in anything else that comes out of his mouth?!?

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-04-29/r ... ills-again

[spert]

4 wins will get you the wooden spoon most years... 2 of our 4 wins were extremely lucky against fellow bottom 4 sides.

Stop trolling us.

4 wins is terrible but wins are wins and I can’t understand why a 25 point win is lucky.

I think we were lucky to play Brisbane when we did, they improved a lot over the year and were a far more dangerous side than us overall.

We went into the game basically at full strength against the reigning wooden spooners, they lost Rich early in the game but were still in front late in the 3rd quarter… 25 points is pretty flattering IMO, I thought we were lucky to get away with a win in the end.

Ironically after this very ordinary game, richo claimed that we had a lot of A graders and we have enough talent on the list to challenge

http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2018/1/stk-v-bl

5 weeks after Richo thought his players would challenge for a flag he claims his players skills were sub par for AFL level!?!

If the head coach doesn't know whether he's coming or going; whether he's Arthur or Martha or whether we are contenders or sub par pretenders, how the hell are the players going to have any faith in anything else that comes out of his mouth?!?

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-04-29/r ... ills-again

I'll trust Arthur and Martha

[tedtheodorelogan2018]

? this other person or poster. Not sure what people call them on here.

Merely highlighting we have beaten all 4 prelim finalists in the last 2 seasons. Our list isn't as bad as some supporters think. If Dylan and Josh get back its big. Plus Dan Hannerbrey.

[st.byron]

? this other person or poster. Not sure what people call them on here.

Merely highlighting we have beaten all 4 prelim finalists in the last 2 seasons. Our list isn't as bad as some supporters think. If Dylan and Josh get back its big. Plus Dan Hannerbrey.

If it walks like a duck.....

[SydneySainter]

? this other person or poster. Not sure what people call them on here.

Merely highlighting we have beaten all 4 prelim finalists in the last 2 seasons. Our list isn't as bad as some supporters think. If Dylan and Josh get back its big. Plus Dan Hannerbrey.

Sure sure Parkey...

To think, the club should never have discontinued Trout's services seeing as our list isn't actually that bad. What was Lethlean thinking? Clearly being too "aggressive".

[dragit]

[samuraisaint]

4 wins will get you the wooden spoon most years... 2 of our 4 wins were extremely lucky against fellow bottom 4 sides.

Stop trolling us.

4 wins is terrible but wins are wins and I can’t understand why a 25 point win is lucky.

I think we were lucky to play Brisbane when we did, they improved a lot over the year and were a far more dangerous side than us overall.

We went into the game basically at full strength against the reigning wooden spooners, they lost Rich early in the game but were still in front late in the 3rd quarter… 25 points is pretty flattering IMO, I thought we were lucky to get away with a win in the end.

Ironically after this very ordinary game, richo claimed that we had a lot of A graders and we have enough talent on the list to challenge

http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2018/1/stk-v-bl

We would beat them in Melbourne anyway - it doesn't matter if they improved throughout the year. 1 win against us in 20 years, and us beating them here every time since 2000, in Melbourne tells us this. We won by almost 5 goals. The rest of your sentiments I agree with though.

[kosifantutti]

4 wins will get you the wooden spoon most years... 2 of our 4 wins were extremely lucky against fellow bottom 4 sides.

Stop trolling us.

4 wins is terrible but wins are wins and I can’t understand why a 25 point win is lucky.

I think we were lucky to play Brisbane when we did, they improved a lot over the year and were a far more dangerous side than us overall.

We went into the game basically at full strength against the reigning wooden spooners, they lost Rich early in the game but were still in front late in the 3rd quarter… 25 points is pretty flattering IMO, I thought we were lucky to get away with a win in the end.

Ironically after this very ordinary game, richo claimed that we had a lot of A graders and we have enough talent on the list to challenge

http://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2018/1/stk-v-bl

I guess we were lucky to have such a good fixture!

Five goals up 22 minutes into the last quarter is not a lucky win. If you want to talk about lucky results, how about the GWS game?

[dragit]

Okay kosi, it wasn't lucky… I thought it was a scrappy and pretty unconvincing performance against an interstate, wooden spooner on our home ground.

The next 21 rounds didn't do much to shake this feeling.

[iwantmeseats]

? this other person or poster. Not sure what people call them on here.

Merely highlighting we have beaten all 4 prelim finalists in the last 2 seasons. Our list isn't as bad as some supporters think. If Dylan and Josh get back its big. Plus Dan Hannerbrey.

Hi parkeysainter. Lol.