Votes v Dees

[Ghost Like]

5 Ross
4 Bruce
3 Steele
2 Gresham
1 Clark

Credit to Marshall for fighting it out all night against a great modern day ruckman.
Apologies to Sinclair, Long & Dunstan, loved all your efforts.

[Josh Battle]

5 Ross
3 Bruce
3 Gresham
2 Sinclair
1 Steele
1 Clark

[6621104]

1. Bruce
2. Ross
3. Gresham
4. Clark
5. Marshall

[Linton Lodger]

5: Gresham

4: Long

3: Bruce

2: Ross

1: Dunstan

[SemperFidelis]

5. Bruce (was everywhere, and not just for kicking the goals when he should, but the second and third efforts)

4. Seb (best game all year; who knew he possessed a flat, accurate kick, & 2 great goals)

3. Gresh

1. Hunter

1. Sincs (also best game all year)

1. Steele

Membrey, Dunstan and Marshall unlucky. I reckon Dunstan is playing consistently better than I’ve ever seen him.

[PADDLEPOP1001]

Ross
Bruce
Clarke
Members
Gresh

[MCG-Unit]

5 - Ross
3 - Marshall
3 - Gresham
1 - Steele
1 - Sinclair
1 - Acres
1 - Bruce

[minneapolis]

Was just going to give them all to the the back line but lots of players earned a vote tonight:

2 Bruce
2 Marshall
2 Ross
2 Dunstan
1 Carlisle
1 Wilkie
1 Brown
1 Steele
1 Clark
1 Gresham
1 Membrey

Lonie - back to his putrid pre-good-Lonie self.
Gresham - lively but muddle-headed.
Paton, Hind, Langlands, Long, Clark - all very impressive.
Brown, Carlisle, Wilkie, Clark - a great foundation for a back line.

[Bernard Shakey]

Ross
Gresham
Clark
Sinclair
Acres

[Scollop]

Was just going to give them all to the the back line but lots of players earned a vote tonight:

2 Bruce
2 Marshall
2 Ross
2 Dunstan
1 Carlisle
1 Wilkie
1 Brown
1 Steele
1 Clark
1 Gresham
1 Membrey

Lonie - back to his putrid pre-good-Lonie self.
Gresham - lively but muddle-headed.
Paton, Hind, Langlands, Long, Clark - all very impressive.
Brown, Carlisle, Wilkie, Clark - a great foundation for a back line.

Most other posters seem to think that Gresham was in our top 3 or 4 players. Don't take this the wrong way, because all voting by individuals is subjective and I'm only posting (as a sort of play on words) because I want to reply on your comment about Gresh being 'muddle-headed'.

You've given a lot of players similar votes. You've named half the squad! Surely there were standout performances from our guys weren't there? Perhaps your voting for this particular game is a bit muddle headed

[Sainter_Dad]

Interesting Votes - Quite an even distribution

[derby Street]

5 ROSS
4 BRUCE
3 STEELE
2 GRESHHAM
1 BILLINGS

[StPeter]

Was just going to give them all to the the back line but lots of players earned a vote tonight:

2 Bruce
2 Marshall
2 Ross
2 Dunstan
1 Carlisle
1 Wilkie
1 Brown
1 Steele
1 Clark
1 Gresham
1 Membrey

Lonie - back to his putrid pre-good-Lonie self.
Gresham - lively but muddle-headed.
Paton, Hind, Langlands, Long, Clark - all very impressive.
Brown, Carlisle, Wilkie, Clark - a great foundation for a back line.

Most other posters seem to think that Gresham was in our top 3 or 4 players. Don't take this the wrong way, because all voting by individuals is subjective and I'm only posting (as a sort of play on words) because I want to reply on your comment about Gresh being 'muddle-headed'.

You've given a lot of players similar votes. You've named half the squad! Surely there were standout performances from our guys weren't there? Perhaps your voting for this particular game is a bit muddle headed

And no mention of Sinclair among the 15 players or so mentioned in our best. Most commentators put him in the best 3 St KIlda players on the ground.

[evertonfc]

5 - Ross, best on ground by the length of the flemington straight.
4 - Bruce, was a fantastic target all night.
3 - Gresham, best game I have seen from him in the midfield.
2 - Sinclair, his best game for the year.
1 - Long, with Ross was our most effective transition into the forward line player.

Agree with this. Great summation.

I also though Marshall was terrific in competing with Gawn and then having a bigger influence as the match wore on. In the key moments in he second half, Marshall was superb.

[St Chris]

5. Ross
4. Bruce
3. Dunstan
2. Long
1. Sinclair

Gresh got plenty of the ball, loved his clearance work, but these up and under chip kicks have got to go.

Marshall was good in patches, but I reckon our expectations have skyrocketed for him, which is a good thing. Gawn kepr the Dees in the game in the 3rd qtr, he had a pretty good game for them.

[spert]

5. Bruce - when the game was in doubt he kept jumping in with some very good positive play to swing it our way
4. Ross - good consistent game which is what we need from our onballers
3. Brown- inconspicuous, but added massive strength and direction to the backline contests two weeks in a row
2. Sinclair -good in close and a lot of his work is not seen until you watch the replay
1. Dunstan- strong at the contest

Mention to Gresh, good game but he needs to work on his field kicking and consistency.

[saynta]

Glad to see Brown get some recognition. One of our best players and certainly the most consistent.

[Scollop]

Seriously good analysis and commentary. It's a shame we didn't win Powerball a few weeks ago when it was $110 million

Could've paid off our debt, and taken over the running of the club

[StPeter]

5 Ross
4 Bruce
3 Sinclair
2 Clark
1 Gresham

[Sainter_Dad]

145 Ross
106 Bruce
74 Gresham
36 Clark
32 Sinclair
29 Steele
16 Dunstan
11 Marshall
8 Billings
7 Long
6 Membrey
4 Brown
3 Acres
2 Coffield
1 Carlisle
1 Wilkie

Therefore
5 Ross
4 Bruce
3 Gresham
2 Clark
1 Sinclair

[saynta]

145 Ross
106 Bruce
74 Gresham
36 Clark
32 Sinclair
29 Steele
16 Dunstan
11 Marshall
8 Billings
7 Long
6 Membrey
4 Brown
3 Acres
2 Coffield
1 Carlisle
1 Wilkie

Therefore
5 Ross
4 Bruce
3 Gresham
2 Clark
1 Sinclair

I think SS nailed top 5

[Scollop]

16 players in the votes

Fix our bottom 6 and we're premiership material

[saynta]

16 players in the votes

Fix our bottom 6 and we're premiership material

Bottom six to be added next year.

King, Bytel, Steven, Hannas. Robbo/Webster and Gears.

Certainly top 8 material.

[Scollop]

16 players in the votes

Fix our bottom 6 and we're premiership material

Bottom six to be added next year.

King, Bytel, Steven, Hannas. Robbo/Webster and Gears.

Certainly top 8 material.

Too bloody right. Ratten gets us into 7th spot next year and we win our first final since 2010

In 2021 we appoint Lenny as assistant to Ratts and we win the whole bloddy shabang

[B.M]

Steele robbed

His Job on Oliver was superb.

He’s been in the best few in the last two weeks