Mid season draft. What every club needs

[saynta]

https://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/ ... ff3c908466

"More than 300 players have already nominated for the mid-season draft and now AFL club’s will have to decide who to take a chance on to fill holes or make their lists better.

Decision date is Wednesday, June 2. Who will follow in the footsteps of the likes of two-time premiership Tiger Marlion Pickett and regular AFL men John Noble and Will Snelling?

Watch the 2021 Toyota AFL Premiership Season. Every match of every round Live on Kayo. New to Kayo? Try 14-Days Free Now >

News Corp footy experts have joined forces to run the rule over every club’s needs and predict who they might target.
South Adelaide hard man Eamon Wilkinson looms as a target for the Crows
ADELAIDE

The Crows have three list spots available and are set to take two players in the Draft.

Lachie Murphy’s syndesmosis injury has further emphasised the Crows desire to add a small forward, while midfield speed could also be targeted.

South Adelaide tackling machine Eamon Wilkinson is set to come under consideration, as could Panthers teammate Hayden Sampson – son of 1997 Premiership Crow Clay.

Zane Williams at Woodville-West Torrens is getting interest from AFL clubs and booted four goals against the Crows’ SANFL side this season, while in Victoria Eastern Rangers’ Corey Preston has attributes Adelaide is looking for.


Tasmanian inside midfielder Oliver Davis has been training with the club and is playing for the Crows SANFL side but is more of an outside chance to be taken in the Mid-Season Draft.
BRISBANE

The Lions don’t have a vacant list spot, leaving them unlikely to take part in the mid-season draft barring any serious long-term injuries. The club does have the option to put Cam Rayner – who has been ruled out for the season with an ACL injury – on the long-term injury list though and pick up another player in the mid season draft. The plan of attack is still being discussed by Brisbane hierarchy.
Ben Crocker has been carving it up for Carlton’s VFL team. Picture: AFL Photos/Getty Images
Ben Crocker has been carving it up for Carlton’s VFL team. Picture: AFL Photos/Getty Images
CARLTON

Will have at least one spot and will assess what David Cuningham’s knee injury means for the list. Former Magpie and Adelaide Crows’ mid-size forward Ben Crocker, 24, is on the radar to get an opportunity at a third club. Crocker has been in sensational form in the VFL, booting 16 goals in four games. The popular club man has averaged 124 ranking points, 5.5 marks inside-50m and a whopping 11 score involvements a match for the Blues’ VFL team. Carlton has some opportunity in the forward half after losing Jack Martin, Zac Fisher and Cuningham to injury this year. The Blues are midtable for forward half pressure.
Would the Pies take a chance on Tyson Stengle? Picture: SANFL Image
Would the Pies take a chance on Tyson Stengle? Picture: SANFL Image
COLLINGWOOD

Is this where the Magpies take a risk on a highly-talented player who has been cut for behavioural issues? Former Tiger and Crows’ livewire Tyson Stengle is someone who could make a difference to Collingwood’s forward half, adding some electric speed and goal kicking power. Beau McReery has shown promising signs as a pressure forward and Josh Thomas and Will Hoskin-Elliott have been used more in the midfield this season. Stengle, 21, was cut by Richmond and Adelaide for misdemeanours including being caught in possession of cocaine alongside former Crow and St Kilda midfield hard nut Brad Crouch and is one of the most intriguing options in this year’s talent pool. Can he commit to a disciplined and professional lifestyle? It would be a punt.
The Bombers could pluck Cody Raak out from under the Bulldogs’ noses. Picture: Hamish Blair
The Bombers could pluck Cody Raak out from under the Bulldogs’ noses. Picture: Hamish Blair
ESSENDON

In a strong position to take the best available talent after an excellent draft haul last year adding Archie Perkins, Nick Cox and Zach Reid, as well as former St Kilda speedster Nick Hind in exchange for a bargain-basement late pick. Slick Western Jets’ halfback Cody Raak, who is tied to the Western Bulldogs through the next generation academy program, could be a nice fit. A developing ruck such as Oakleigh’s Ned Moyle or Calder’s Liam Podhajski may appeal as a long-term play or former Geelong key defender Blake Schlensog to help support an injury-hit backline missing Michael Hurley. The Bombers could go a few different ways. Couldn’t rule out a strong ball winner either as the Bombers rank 16th for contested possession differential this season.


FREMANTLE

The Dockers technically don’t have any list vacancies, but young players Heath Chapman (shoulder) and Sam Sturt (knee) are out for the season and can be moved to the inactive list. They’ve ruled out Stephen Hill retiring early to open up a spot. A tall defender who could potentially play this year or ruck project wouldn’t be the worst idea, given Joel Hamling, Alex Pearce and Luke Ryan have all spent time out this year.
GEELONG

The Cats don’t have any list openings or long-term injuries, so something would have to change for them to get involved. Patrick Dangerfield (ankle) and Gryan Miers (fractured leg) have the longest recovery time ahead of them but they should be back inside five weeks. They have a veteran core and depth at most spots, so it’s unlikely they will try to manoeuvre anything.

Foxsports5:32
Suns press conference
AFL: Listen in to the Gold Coast Suns post match press conference
GOLD COAST

Gold Coast currently have no spots available on their list. However they do have the option to add someone to their long-term injury list – players such as Jarrod Witts and Connor Budarick who are both out for the season with ACL injuries – and recruit another ruck through the mid season draft. Back up tall timbers Zac Smith and Sam Day are tracking well to return from their own knee injuries so the club will be weighing up their options in the coming weeks.
GREATER WESTERN SYDNEY

If any club needs some injury relief, it’s the Giants. They don’t have any list openings, but key defender Lachie Keeffe’s season-ending ACL rupture and subsequent knee reconstruction means one can be created. GWS skipped the mid-season draft two years ago and is typically tight in the salary cap, so that could preclude it from getting involved. The Giants’ main need is a tall defender, especially with Keeffe’s injury.
The Hawks could target a ruck prospect like Ned Moyle. Picture: Michael Klein
The Hawks could target a ruck prospect like Ned Moyle. Picture: Michael Klein
HAWTHORN

Jon Patton’s retirement in April has created a spot for the Hawks, who could also open further vacancies if they choose to place James Sicily (knee) and/or Seamus Mitchell (ankle) on the inactive list. Coach Alastair Clarkson indicated after Patton’s decision that they would look to fill his list spot in the mid-season draft. It wouldn’t surprise to see Hawthorn pluck one of the ruck options in contention, including Jacob Edwards, Ned Moyle and Max Heath. Ben McEvoy and Jon Ceglar are both in their 30s and Ned Reeves is yet to make his AFL debut. Jackson Callow and Will Bravo trained with the Hawks in the pre-season and have nominated for the mid-season draft.
Will the Demons hand son-of-a-gun Kobe Farmer an AFL lifeline? Picture: Michael Klein
Will the Demons hand son-of-a-gun Kobe Farmer an AFL lifeline? Picture: Michael Klein
MELBOURNE

This is a tough side to break into at the moment, but the Demons might be interested in taking a flyer on a longer-term prospect. The season-ending injuries to Marty Hore, Aaron Nietschke and Adam Tomlinson mean they can get involved if they choose to. Werribee dasher Kye Declase and Swan Districts’ Kobe Farmer – son of Jeff – have both nominated for the mid-season draft after training with the club in the pre-season. Melbourne picked Majak Daw and Deakyn Smith over that pair as pre-season supplemental selection period signings. They already have Next Generation Academy ruck prospect Mac Andrew available at the end of the year, so key defensive depth could be a priority.
Is Jacob Edwards a done deal to North? Picture: Steve Tanner
Is Jacob Edwards a done deal to North? Picture: Steve Tanner
NORTH MELBOURNE

Opposition clubs believe it is already a “done deal” that the Kangaroos will pick up Victorian Jacob Edwards with pick No.1 in the mid-season draft.

Edwards had not nominated as of the end of last week, but has until May 25 to do so.

The 202cm Sandringham Dragons product is still in Year 12 at Mentone Grammar but is a left-footer who can kick goals as a forward, run through the ruck and impact in the air.

Some scouts believe Edwards is capable of playing some senior games for the Kangaroos this year.

The Kangaroos also have a second list spot available and could open up a third spot by moving the injured Flynn Perez (knee) to the inactive list given he has been ruled out for the season.
PORT ADELAIDE

The Power have a list spot available, but at this stage are planning on not entering the Draft.

But, if the Power’s long injury list continues to grow then Port might have to look at bringing another player to the club.

The issue for the Power though, is that they are unsure whether any of the talent out there could almost immediately add to their side at AFL level.

Foxsports2:58
Tigers nab tightest of wins over Giants
AFL: Richmond were pushed right to the final siren but ultimately held off the GWS Giants in a photo finish.
RICHMOND

The Tigers struck gold by selecting Marlion Pickett in the 2019 mid-season draft, but it remains unclear whether they will make a selection this year.

Richmond does not currently have a vacant list spot, however ruckman Ivan Soldo (knee) remains a “long term” prospect on the club’s injury list and could be moved to the inactive list to open up a spot.

However, Soldo had been expected back at some stage later this season and the Tigers would want to give the two-time premiership player every chance to return for the pointy end of the season.
ST KILDA

The Saints have options if they want to use them.

They were left with one spare list spot even after signing ruckman Paul Hunter and forward Mason Wood through the AFL’s pre-season Supplementary Selection Period.

The retirement of Dylan Roberton opened a second spot and there is also the option to put Jade Gresham (Achilles) and Ben Paton (leg) on the inactive list, given both have been ruled out for the season.

That leaves four possible selections – not that the Saints are likely to use all of them.

The Saints appear to have most bases covered on their list as it stands, but could look to select a talented young player or two.
He’s serving an untimely suspension, but could the Swans pick up former Saint Patrick McCartin. Picture: Getty Images
He’s serving an untimely suspension, but could the Swans pick up former Saint Patrick McCartin. Picture: Getty Images
SYDNEY

The Swans left one spot open to give themselves the option of grabbing someone in the mid-season draft. Paddy McCartin is playing with the club’s VFL team but is serving an untimely five-week ban for whacking Geelong’s Aaron Black. Whether that incident or McCartin’s lack of matches will cruel his draft hopes remains to be seen. A long-term ruck option could be on the cards, given Tom Hickey and Callum Sinclair are both over 30 and Sam Naismith is on the way back from a second knee reconstruction. Sydney picked two players – Michael Knoll and Cody Hirst – in this draft in 2019.
WEST COAST

The Eagles don’t currently have a list spot and don’t have any season-ending injuries, leaving them unlikely to play a part in the mid-season draft.
WESTERN BULLDOGS

The Bulldogs don’t currently have a list spot and don’t have any season-ending injuries, leaving them unlikely to play a part in the mid-season draft.
More Coverage
Big Vic club considers shock Stengle lifeline The Tackle: No excuse for Blues’ broken defence

Josh Dunkley (shoulder) and Lin Jong (hamstring) are still expected to return in the later part of the season after surgeries.

The club signed midfielder Anthony Scott during the AFL’s pre-season Supplementary Selection Period.

[Munga]

I can't see why we wouldn't use all four picks if they are signed until the end of the season. A ruck and mids, if anyone else goes down there we're screwed.

[Yorkeys]

300 nominations. Consolation lottery. Better chances finding gold behind MARS Stadium. Is there a player called Gold that's nominated?

[Impatient Sainter]

I can't see why we wouldn't use all four picks if they are signed until the end of the season. A ruck and mids, if anyone else goes down there we're screwed.

Most clubs will have at least one pick now and I dont think the talent pool is that deep? Callum Twomey reported most clubs have no more than 6 names on their mid season lists. Given a lot are probably the same names, they are going to get scratched off pretty quickly over 18 teams come draft day.

Our only hope is our recruiters have been scouring the country and thinking outside the norm when it comes to scouting.

[Munga]

I can't see why we wouldn't use all four picks if they are signed until the end of the season. A ruck and mids, if anyone else goes down there we're screwed.

Most clubs will have at least one pick now and I dont think the talent pool is that deep? Callum Twomey reported most clubs have no more than 6 names on their mid season lists. Given a lot are probably the same names, they are going to get scratched off pretty quickly over 18 teams come draft day.

Our only hope is our recruiters have been scouring the country and thinking outside the norm when it comes to scouting.

Another Marshall find would be great!

Even if the quality isn't there to be a regular senior player, improving Sandy for the rest of the season would beneficial. But yeah, it doesn't sound like there will be much quality available.

[MickThomas]

I can't see why we wouldn't use all four picks if they are signed until the end of the season. A ruck and mids, if anyone else goes down there we're screwed.

Most clubs will have at least one pick now and I dont think the talent pool is that deep? Callum Twomey reported most clubs have no more than 6 names on their mid season lists. Given a lot are probably the same names, they are going to get scratched off pretty quickly over 18 teams come draft day.

Our only hope is our recruiters have been scouring the country and thinking outside the norm when it comes to scouting.

Tried that with Parker.
Didn't pan out.
Got lucky with Wilkie.
Can't see us getting that lucky again.
He's a one-in-100 shot that nobody in the AFL was seriously looking at.

[CURLY]

Plenty of talent out there. People get all uppity because a player isn't 19 when they are recruited. For every kid that gets driven to elite training programs there will be one that can't get there for what ever reason. Given that kids also develop at different rates grabbing a player outside of the TAC system is a very viable option.

[Devilhead]

I can't see why we wouldn't use all four picks if they are signed until the end of the season. A ruck and mids, if anyone else goes down there we're screwed.

Most clubs will have at least one pick now and I dont think the talent pool is that deep? Callum Twomey reported most clubs have no more than 6 names on their mid season lists. Given a lot are probably the same names, they are going to get scratched off pretty quickly over 18 teams come draft day.

Our only hope is our recruiters have been scouring the country and thinking outside the norm when it comes to scouting.

Tried that with Parker.
Didn't pan out.
Got lucky with Wilkie.
Can't see us getting that lucky again.
He's a one-in-100 shot that nobody in the AFL was seriously looking at.

So when a recruit doesnt pan out its s*** recruitment

But

When a recruit does pan out its pot luck?

[Banger9798]

All we need is to draft 3 guns who will play 200 games for the club....get on with it!

[saintbob]

The best outside mids available, no more inside mids or half back flankers

[Joffa Burns]

I can't see why we wouldn't use all four picks if they are signed until the end of the season. A ruck and mids, if anyone else goes down there we're screwed.

Most clubs will have at least one pick now and I dont think the talent pool is that deep? Callum Twomey reported most clubs have no more than 6 names on their mid season lists. Given a lot are probably the same names, they are going to get scratched off pretty quickly over 18 teams come draft day.

Our only hope is our recruiters have been scouring the country and thinking outside the norm when it comes to scouting.

Tried that with Parker.
Didn't pan out.
Got lucky with Wilkie.
Can't see us getting that lucky again.
He's a one-in-100 shot that nobody in the AFL was seriously looking at.

So when a recruit doesnt pan out its s*** recruitment

But

When a recruit does pan out its pot luck?

We drafted Parker, Young & Hind as mature age recruits then rookie listed Wilkie.

Either we were confident Wilkie had no other takers or rated Parker, Young & Hind in front of him which seems most likely. Wilkie probably got his chance due to Robbo going down.

Based on that you'd suggest Wilkie whilst being a great get was a surprise packet for the Saints.