Is Caminiti in trouble?

[shanegrambeau]

1970s Dad's advice #101
"If someone hits you, give them one right back"

That should be his defense.

I guess we could make a plea around bullying or young players. Lol would put the AFL in a hard spot, given it’s activism on social issues

Love it!

Yeah

And the language they use too
No doubt the equivalent of the prosecution will say something like “causing him to miss Anzac day” which sounds so much more damaging than “causing him to miss one match” which is what it is.

[samoht]

If his nickname was feather duster ... he probably wouln't have been cited.

[King Max]

1970s Dad's advice #101
"If someone hits you, give them one right back"

That should be his defense.

I guess we could make a plea around bullying or young players. Lol would put the AFL in a hard spot, given it’s activism on social issues

Love it!

Yeah

And the language they use too
No doubt the equivalent of the prosecution will say something like “causing him to miss Anzac day” which sounds so much more damaging than “causing him to miss one match” which is what it is.

Commentators referred to Ginnivan as reigning Anzac medalist.
No such comments were made about the reigning Silk Miller medalist, Rowan Marshall or Brad Crouch as the reigning Ian Stewart medalist.
But Ginnivan got his for playing well against the 15th best team.

[CURLY]

1970s Dad's advice #101
"If someone hits you, give them one right back"

That should be his defense.

I guess we could make a plea around bullying or young players. Lol would put the AFL in a hard spot, given it’s activism on social issues

Love it!

Yeah

And the language they use too
No doubt the equivalent of the prosecution will say something like “causing him to miss Anzac day” which sounds so much more damaging than “causing him to miss one match” which is what it is.

Commentators referred to Ginnivan as reigning Anzac medalist.
No such comments were made about the reigning Silk Miller medalist, Rowan Marshall or Brad Crouch as the reigning Ian Stewart medalist.
But Ginnivan got his for playing well against the 15th best team.

It's Collingwood apparently they were patched up and banged up and it was a courageous victory.

[Life Long Saint]

Commentators referred to Ginnivan as reigning Anzac medalist.
No such comments were made about the reigning Silk Miller medalist, Rowan Marshall or Brad Crouch as the reigning Ian Stewart medalist.
But Ginnivan got his for playing well against the 15th best team.

Every game in ANZAC Day round should have an ANZAC Medal.
It's selfish and ridiculous that it's only two teams that are ever eligible for this.

[Trev from the Bush]

Commentators referred to Ginnivan as reigning Anzac medalist.
No such comments were made about the reigning Silk Miller medalist, Rowan Marshall or Brad Crouch as the reigning Ian Stewart medalist.
But Ginnivan got his for playing well against the 15th best team.

Every game in ANZAC Day round should have an ANZAC Medal.
It's selfish and ridiculous that it's only two teams that are ever eligible for this.

Or no medal at all. What have these privileged prats given for their country? The only sniper they are likely to encounter would be a stray fist behind the ear in a pack mark.

[HardSaint]

makes me wonder again what went on behind play when Jimmy O'Dea put John Greening on his arse back in the day

[seano1]

makes me wonder again what went on behind play when Jimmy O'Dea put John Greening on his arse back in the day

I was a young bloke and standing right near when that happened…… both were running elbowing each other and Jim let a harder one go but it lifting off Johns shoulder into the side of his head …bloody shame both good footballers Greening probably better but

[Sainternist]

f****** Ralph can't tell a punch from a push. Who is surprised?

Ralph is always keen to be the first to break a big story. The other week he reported that Mason Wood would miss 6 weeks with an injury. It’s like Ralph wants to be the next Hutchy or something

[Sainternist]

The media-driven love fest for the Filth has been nauseating. They are making out that they are every non-fan’s second team. Now, they’re scapegoating Caminiti, making out that the kid is a thug. This is absolute BS that makes my blood boil! Collingwood are the biggest crybaby club in the history of the game. Maybe they should wrap their prized coward Murphy in cottonwool the next game he plays. The Filth are weak as piss!

[Saints58]

Belted Murphy in goal square off the ball. Murphy went off and wasn’t happy. Commentary team went quiet when they showed it

If you look at the footage Murphy hit caminiti on the side of the head first so if the hammer is in trouble so is Murphy

[Waltzing St Kilda]

Good grief. Media now talking "at least four weeks" and "the footage isn't flattering".

Why, exactly? The footage doesn't show the area of contact. For all we know Murphy dropped like a sack of spuds to draw a free kick.

And it was the oddest "concussion" in AFL history. Murphy left the fireld unaided and mouthing off -- not exactly Paddy McCartin stuff.

Neverthleess, it's St Kilda so expect five weeks.

Nine weeks if it had been Steven Baker.

[Life Long Saint]

OFFICIAL: Straight to tribunal
Nothing for Murphy

[CURLY]

Week for Adams

[chook23]

4 weeks plus

You are kidding

[Life Long Saint]

4 weeks plus

You are kidding

Up to four weeks

[magnifisaint]

So what does that can't Murphy get?
He hit him first!

[chook23]

4 weeks plus

You are kidding

Up to four weeks

[Sainter_Dad]

4 weeks plus

You are kidding

Up to four weeks

Nope - four plus

[chook23]

4 weeks plus

You are kidding

Up to four weeks

Graded intentional....high contact....high impact

4 weeks plus according to Sen
Minimum 4

[chook23]

4 weeks plus

You are kidding

Up to four weeks

Graded intentional....high contact....high impact

4 weeks plus according to Sen
Minimum 4

[chook23]

4 weeks plus

You are kidding

Up to four weeks

Graded intentional....high contact....high impact

4 weeks plus according to Sen
Minimum 4

[Sainter_Dad]

Hey Chook - stop spamming the submit button

[B.M]

But Kosi Pickett?… for a disgusting act
What?? 2 weeks

Outcome should not determine penalty

Appeal if you have the nuts!

[Sainter_Dad]

I would argue with 4 umpires there is a duty of care to stop the initiator - apparently Murphy was at it behind play all night