Who would you prefer in your team - Goddard in his 2010 form or Goodes in his peak brownlow form?
Both are brilliant midfielders who can be very successful playing up forward.
Goodes seems to be a better forward, and better in the hard ball gets.
Goddard has better foot-skills, is a little bit more versatile being useful down back.
However, Goodes has (had) the ability to be an absolute match winner and rip a game apart singlehandedly.... So i'm leaning towards Goodes.
But Goddard is brilliant and should possibly get better. So really i'm not quite sure....
Goddard or Goodes
Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators
