Does Windy get a RS nomination

[terry smith rules]

He must be a chance, brilliant performance I thought

[The_Dud]

He, NWM and Owens should be picked every week (if fit) at this point

[saynta]

He must be a chance, brilliant performance I thought

Nah, he plays for the Saints.

[skeptic]

Certainly deserves it

Stella performance

[Banger9798]

Should get one

[CURLY]

Be as good as any game a first year player has played this season.

[Sainter_Dad]

He must be a chance, brilliant performance I thought

Nah, he plays for the Saints.

This

[aaron82]

Unfortunately I feel Ugle-Hagen should be $1.01 for the nomination this week

[Vortex]

His kicking might be an issue but he's put himself in the potential category for the next year or two.

[Trev from the Bush]

He should.

He won't.

He wears the wrong jumper.

[meher baba]

Gee, I reckon even most Saints supporters would nominate Ugle-Hagen if it was up to them. He was amazing.

Bad luck for Windhager, but his time will come.

[bangaulegend]

Gee, I reckon even most Saints supporters would nominate Ugle-Hagen if it was up to them. He was amazing.

Bad luck for Windhager, but his time will come.

Great post agree 100%

[bigcarl]

Think it will go to Jamarra, but Windhager is quite a prospect. That burst out of the middle for our goal near half time was something to get excited about. Leave him in the starting clearance midfield. He’s already big and strong enough.

[CURLY]

Windhager with 530 meters gained 24 touches and keeping Kelly to 4 is as good a game as Jamarra.

[bigcarl]

Windhager with 530 meters gained 24 touches and keeping Kelly to 4 is as good a game as Jamarra.

Probably it is, but five goals including three in the last quarter of a close game and the match-winner with not long to go will be hard to overlook. Plus the fact that Ugle-Hagen is a No.1 National Draft pick. I’d be surprised if he he doesn’t get it.

The way Windhager is tracking he will get his nomination against Hawthorn.

[whiskers3614]

Be as good as any game a first year player has played this season.

So you haven't heard of a bloke called Daicos?

[CURLY]

Be as good as any game a first year player has played this season.

So you haven't heard of a bloke called Daicos?

Yep I have. What Windhager did defensively was elite.

[Mr Magic]

Is Ugle Hagen eligible for a nomination?

[bigcarl]

Is Ugle Hagen eligible for a nomination?

Very good point you make there Mr Magic.

I think he is

[kosifantutti]

Windhager with 530 meters gained 24 touches and keeping Kelly to 4 is as good a game as Jamarra.

Probably it is, but five goals including three in the last quarter of a close game and the match-winner with not long to go will be hard to overlook. Plus the fact that Ugle-Hagen is a No.1 National Draft pick. I’d be surprised if he he doesn’t get it.

The way Windhager is tracking he will get his nomination against Hawthorn.

I remember years ago we had a guy who kicked 4 goals got 8 coaches' votes and 1 Brownlow vote but was passed over for some guy who got 15 disposals chipping it around the backline.

[bigcarl]

Windhager with 530 meters gained 24 touches and keeping Kelly to 4 is as good a game as Jamarra.

Probably it is, but five goals including three in the last quarter of a close game and the match-winner with not long to go will be hard to overlook. Plus the fact that Ugle-Hagen is a No.1 National Draft pick. I’d be surprised if he he doesn’t get it.

The way Windhager is tracking he will get his nomination against Hawthorn.

I remember years ago we had a guy who kicked 4 goals got 8 coaches' votes and 1 Brownlow vote but was passed over for some guy who got 15 disposals chipping it around the backline.

I remember a guy who kicked 10.7 on the supposed full back of last century … including the match winner with 43 second left on the clock. He got one Brownlow vote and a serviceable midfielder who did nothing special got the 3 votes.

Life isn’t fair sometimes

[chook23]

Not for this week

[WellardSaint]

Some on twitter are saying Kelly got 2 kicks+2 handballs
And the 2 kicks, one was a free n the other was a kick off the ground.

Amazing.
Teenager beats a highly paid mercenary

[meher baba]

Has any club received fewer RS nominations than us over the past decade or so?

What does that say about the quality of our recruiting over most of that period?

Nothing, of course. It’s all the coach’s fault apparently.

[CURLY]

Has any club received fewer RS nominations than us over the past decade or so?

What does that say about the quality of our recruiting over most of that period?

Nothing, of course. It’s all the coach’s fault apparently.

Does it really mean anything at all though?

How many players have received a nomination than never played a decent game again.