Votes

[plugger66]

5 hayes
4 Steven
3 Rooy
2 saunders
1 Dempster

[maverick]

5 hayes
4 Steven
3 Rooy
2 saunders
1 Dempster

Dempster…really?
Thought that was possibly the worst game I have seen him play for us, the other 17 must have been shocking...

[plugger66]

5 hayes
4 Steven
3 Rooy
2 saunders
1 Dempster

Dempster…really?
Thought that was possibly the worst game I have seen him play for us, the other 17 must have been shocking...

Well its only an opinion and when picking 5 when you lose by 70 you could get things wrong.

[maverick]

5 hayes
4 Steven
3 Rooy
2 saunders
1 Dempster

Dempster…really?
Thought that was possibly the worst game I have seen him play for us, the other 17 must have been shocking...

Well its only an opinion and when picking 5 when you lose by 70 you could get things wrong.

True, was only (half) joking….

Suppose I should give mine…

5 - Roo
4 - Hayes
3 - Steven
2- Dunstan
1 - Saunders

[The Redeemer]

Lets give it to Jones. Nah. He has made a career out of being s***.

[8856brother]

5 Roo star
4 Lenny star
3 Dunstan
2 Steven
1 Tezza

Saunders ok and I found out what foot Longer kicks with, which is a positive. Rest poor. Kicking and tackling training this week please Richo.

[desertsaint]

Hayes
Steven
Dunstan
Roo
Newnes

[PADDLEPOP1001]

Roo
Lenny
Dunstan
Dempster
Saunders

[BigMart]

Riewoldt
Hayes.... Worst game he would have played to get 4 votes and an incredibly sad indictment
Dunstan.... And he wasn't great either
Saunders... Did well at times
Not sure on the last, trying to think of who wasn't terrible?

Flip of the coin on Weller, Lee, Simpkin, Murdoch... Whom were all beaten but tried
I'll go
Lee.... He had a go

Dempster ..... Easily his worst game since being played as an underdone defensive fwd on GF Day. Never seen him make so many mistakes... He looked slow and out of sorts and Robbie Gray and Winguard made him look second rate. He's entitled to a shocker though...

[plugger66]

Riewoldt
Hayes.... Worst game he would have played to get 4 votes and an incredibly sad indictment
Dunstan.... And he wasn't great either
Saunders... Did well at times
Not sure on the last, trying to think of who wasn't terrible?

Flip of the coin on Weller, Lee, Simpkin, Murdoch... Whom were all beaten but tried
I'll go
Lee.... He had a go

Dempster ..... Easily his worst game since being played as an underdone defensive fwd on GF Day. Never seen him make so many mistakes... He looked slow and out of sorts and Robbie Gray and Winguard made him look second rate. He's entitled to a shocker though...

No idea why Dempster was mentioned but at least get it right, didnt play on either of those 2 guys. glad even when giving votes you knock players. And i know why dempster was mentioned. Simpkin had a kick.

[BigMart]

P66 Didn't know you flew to Adelaide?

I thought Sean played back, I thought those two played fwd. Sean spent a half it seemed as a loose back, and went on to Gray. He also found himself opposed to Chad at times unfortunately, although Murdoch had him in the fisrt half generally as a direct opponent

Shenton... Westhoff
Delaney .... Shultz
Bruce ...... Trengrove

This is a thread for giving votes.... So allow people to do that.... I bought up Dempster, because I was surprised at how poor he was... Normally our most reliable... He was out pointed a number of times, turned it over and had no defensive or offensive effect.

[plugger66]

P66 Didn't know you flew to Adelaide?

I thought Sean played back, I thought those two played fwd. Sean spent a half it seemed as a loose back, and went on to Gray. He also found himself opposed to Chad at times unfortunately, although Murdoch had him in the fisrt half generally as a direct opponent

Shenton... Westhoff
Delaney .... Shultz
Bruce ...... Trengrove

This is a thread for giving votes.... So allow people to do that.... I bought up Dempster, because I was surprised at how poor he was... Normally our most reliable... He was out pointed a number of times, turned it over and had no defensive or offensive effect.

No i didnt go but neither did you. Yep its a thread about giving votes so why did you mention dempster? It isnt a thread about who you thought played badly. never noticed anyone do that I this thread previously. Still think Dempster didnt play on either player but its very hard from TV for most people.

[Zed]

From where I was sitting high in the stands
5 Reiwoldt
4 Steven
3 Hayes
2 Dunstan - would have given him 3 but his disposal let him down occasionally
1 Lee

[borderbarry]

5.. Lenny
4. Roo.
2.. Steven
2.. Dunstan
1. . Milera
1. . Lee.

[stinger]

5. Lenny
4. Roo
3. Dunstan
2. Ross
1. Saunders

[BringBackMadDog]

5. Lenny
4. Roo
3. Steven
2 Saunders
1. Dunstan

[avid]

5 Hayes
4 Newnes
3 Dunstan
2 Steven
1 Riewoldt

6th best, for me, was Simpkin. He had some real presence on the ground -- probably 'beat' several players on the just with single bumps.

[MCG-Unit]

5 - Hayes
4 - Riewoldt
3 - Dunstan
2 - Steven
1 - Ross

0 - PA crowd & umpires

[RW&B]

5 Hayes
4 Riewoldt
..
..
3 Dunstan
2 Steven
..
1 Milera

[Sainter_Dad]

59 Hayes
51 Riewoldt
31 Dunstan
28 Steven
9 Saunders
5 Newnes
3 Dempster
3 Lee
3 Milera
3 Ross

Therefore
5 Hayes
4 Riewoldt
3 Dunstan
2 Steven
1 Saunders

[Sainter_Dad]

59 Hayes
51 Riewoldt
31 Dunstan
28 Steven
9 Saunders
5 Newnes
3 Dempster
3 Lee
3 Milera
3 Ross

Therefore
5 Hayes
4 Riewoldt
3 Dunstan
2 Steven
1 Saunders