Changes v Tigers

[Jacks Back]

Out: Newnes, Marsh, Kent/Parker, Richardson
In: Paton, Brown, White, The Janitor

[WellardSaint]

Richo says we had too many passengers when the Lions went up a few notches.
If he only drops 2, then we know he's full of hot air.
I agree with your changes, and Newnes belongs at the Zebs for the rest of the season.
Did NOTHING to help. As usual.

[Linton Lodger]

Out: Armitage, McKenzie, Marsh, Newnes

In: Paton, Brown, White, Long

[bigcarl]

When’s Webster back?

[Jacks Back]

When’s Webster back?

1-2 weeks

I forgot about Armitage. Good changes Linton Lodger.

[Toy Saint]

I'd prefer some youth.

In: Paton, Coffield & Langlands

Out: Armitage (sorry), Newnes, Kent

[St Chris]

Out: Armo, Marsh, Newnes.

In: Paton, Brown, Coffield.

Stick a fork in Armo, Marsh is depth at best and not AFL standard, and Newnes can go back to VFL and remember how to be involved in the game for 4 quarters.

Sinclair pretty lucky there's no one to replace him, Parker did nothing until halfway thru the last quarter, so many dumb decisions made by most.

Wish we could make more changes, but the cupboard's pretty bare at the moment.

[bigred]

If Newnes gets another game, then we know it's all over.

[freely]

Sinclair was pretty good I thought (by comparison anyway!!) and I'd keep Dmac in. Beaten by Cameron but not for lack of trying. Consensus would probably be he should've been moved so harsh to drop him.

Out: Armo, Newnes, Marsh.
In: Paton, White, Brown.

Play Carlisle back and Battle forward. Get Clark well away from the backline. Stick him somewhere near Hannebery so he can learn something!

[saintadamski]

Newne's magnet is superglued to the white board under Richardson's watch.

You will NEVER see him dropped until our current coach is shown the door.

[Ajantis]

Newes - Out
Parker - Out
Marsh - Out
Seb - would like to see out. But not going to happen

Brown - In
Coffield - In
White - In

Move Bruce to Half Back
Battle to Forward.

[WellardSaint]

Seb out. Newnes out.
Hanners to be elevated to captain for the duration of 2019.
Seb can leave with Richo, they can share an Uber on the way to their next club- Wantirna Seconds

[saynta]

Out: Armo, Marsh, Newnes.

In: Paton, Brown, Coffield.

Stick a fork in Armo, Marsh is depth at best and not AFL standard, and Newnes can go back to VFL and remember how to be involved in the game for 4 quarters.

Sinclair pretty lucky there's no one to replace him, Parker did nothing until halfway thru the last quarter, so many dumb decisions made by most.

Wish we could make more changes, but the cupboard's pretty bare at the moment.

Langlands can replace Sinclair. He has been the emergency for the past two weeks and even traveled to the banana state last week.

[silverhalo]

In: Sandringham
Out: St.Kilda

[older saint]

Should:

Out: Newnes, Parker, Marsh, Armitage, Sinclair
In: Brown, Long, Rice, Langlands, Paton

Will be
In: Brown, Long
Out: Marsh , Parker

[WellardSaint]

Should:

Out: Newnes, Parker, Marsh, Armitage, Sinclair
In: Brown, Long, Rice, Langlands, Paton

Will be
In: Brown, Long
Out: Marsh , Parker

Long wasn't in the best for Zebs,
he got 14 disposals, 2 tackles, played at half-back.
Why half-back, when he plays seniors in the F50?
Why would he be promoted after that return?

[SaintPav]

It sounds like we should be more worried about who the Tigers will bring in. They will have up to 6 key senior players available for selection after the bye.

[cwrcyn]

Out: Carlisle (get him fit first, for God's sake), Marsh, Newnes
In: Brown, Paton, White,

There are others to make a case for being dropped (McKenzie, Clark, Armitage), but we have so few available at Sandringham to replace them. You can't have half back line with Armitage Marsh, and Clark like we did last week. Paton must come in to replace Armitage in that role, and Armitage can spend time on-ball and a little bit forward.

[Bruce G McAbee]

And for the good news, Richmond get 6 of their premiership players back.

[Scollop]

In: Sandringham
Out: St.Kilda

It wouldn't matter

They need to try the AFLX system with no coach. Then we might be a chance

[Special]

And for the good news, Richmond get 6 of their premiership players back.

Good for them.

I want us to play a strong Richmond side to see where we really are at.

[mad saint guy]

Out: Newnes, Kent, Armitage
In: Langlands, Paton, Coffield


B: Marsh, Wilkie, McKenzie
HB: Savage, Carlisle, Coffield
C: Ross, Hannebery, Sinclair
HF: BIllings, Battle, Hind
F: Parker, Bruce, Membrey

Foll: Marshall, Gresham, Acres
Int: Clark, Dunstan, Langlands, Paton

[Beno88]

When’s Webster back?

1-2 weeks

This is becoming a little strange. He injured his hand against GWS nearly two months ago. He did play the following week when he probably shouldn't have, but even then we were told he'd only miss 1-2 weeks. It's now been 7 weeks. What sort of hand injury keeps a player out for 7 weeks?

[Bernard Shakey]

When’s Webster back?

1-2 weeks

This is becoming a little strange. He injured his hand against GWS nearly two months ago. He did play the following week when he probably shouldn't have, but even then we were told he'd only miss 1-2 weeks. It's now been 7 weeks. What sort of hand injury keeps a player out for 7 weeks?

He was injured before the Canberra game and shouldn't have played. He was the only one who didn't participate in the Captains Run on the Friday up there.

[To the top]

Who SHOULD be out as automatic:-

Marsh, Kent, Newnes, McKenzie, Parker, Savage, Sinclair, Ross

BUT, who replaces them from the numbers playing at Sandringham?


Joyce, Coffield and Paton - perhaps punt with Clavarino?

And go back to Brown yet again?

Will White be available?

So there are 6 "possible" names, to replace at least 8 so some will remain playing at AFL level by default.