Agree with all that. HOWEVER. I have a question about him. When the whistle blows, and it is obviously your free kick 10 metres out from goal, and the ball is bobbing around on the ground, why would you soccer the ball going for goal? Tonight it came off. Against the hawks it did not. It can mean o...

I thought he was stiff on those two free kicks. He was the unluckiest man on the ground until he became the unluckiest man off the ground.

I thought a pass to Riewoldt would have been a more difficult kick than a shot for goal. And that's not taking into account the chance of Riewoldt kicking a goal.

A bit of an over reaction from the captain but he's a passionate man and it's a passionate game.

Handy goal

http://www.afl.com.au/video/tabid/76/co ... fault.aspx

borderbarry wrote:Is Tom too old for a Rising Star nomination?

yes

I wonder if Luke Hodge was watching that game this evening?

He tried to take Armo out with that knee in the back three weeks ago and hasn't played since.

Why wouldn't we be?

kosifantutti wrote:Geary subbed off.

By the way. 3AW, worst boundary rider ever.

"I can tell you Geary is being subbed off but I can't quite work out who's going on"

Maybe it's that bloke who was sitting there with the green jacket for just over an hour.

Geary subbed off.

Cripps actually took a strong overhead mark in the first quarter. Maybe he thinks he can be a KPP.

I can't believe that Jack Steven soccered the ball through when Goddard had the free 10m out again!

That ball could have gone anywhere.

Great quarter. Brownlow votes for Blake.

Tune in worked you just needed the correct AFL URL that didn't change from week to week.

But now the AFL app works really well for radio so why bother.

not alot about the game on here so I'll spend my few bob, players that stood out for me; Curren - keeps impressing and improving, handy and speedy smarts Markworth - my first look at him and is a little bigger than what I was expecting and did some nifty work around the ground Ledger - another good...

kosifantutti23 has gone. But I have taken over the sponsorship for him.

If I was picked in next week's team I'm sure my workrate would be fantastic. I'd get to plenty of contests.

But I can't mark and I can't kick and I'm not very strong or co-ordinated. Is that going to be a problem?

The only relevant part was the first phrase "out of contract St Kilda midfielder Leigh Montagna" the rest was fluff.

plugger66 wrote:

Dont have my rule book handy. Just give the AFL a call and ask them the question. The question is if you blow your whislte for a mark but realise it wasnt a mark what is your next decision. They will say call play on.

I rang, Demetriou called me an idiot and asked if I knew you.

I'm not sure if you said that either. Who knows what you were trying to say. But it made no sense. The Stanley mark was the incorrect and correct decision. He paid a mark that wasnt held which was the incorrect part but then correctly called play on because he was incorrect in the first instance an...

Con Gorozidis wrote:

hungry for a premiership wrote:For all his skill, he has one glaring deficiency in his game: UNABLE TO PROVIDE ANY ARIAL CONTEST WHATSOEVER.

he is only 137 cm.

Yeah but he should still beat Arial or at least be competitive against her.

Bernard Shakey wrote:

kosifantutti wrote:Bob Skilton was a triple Brownlow Medallist.
David Wojcinski is a triple Premiership winner.

I don't want any Bob Skiltons. I want some David Wojcinskis.

I'd have Skilts ahead of Wojo anyday.

I'd take a Premiership over a Brownlow any day.

Bob Skilton was a triple Brownlow Medallist.
David Wojcinski is a triple Premiership winner.

I don't want any Bob Skiltons. I want some David Wojcinskis.

]About as much sense as your theory that they make deliberate mistakes to make up for the mistakes they know they made earlier on. Not sure I have ever said that but carry on. I'm not sure if you said that either. Who knows what you were trying to say. But it made no sense. The Stanley mark was the...

Dont know. was watching a race. Anyway the umpiring has been good apart from maybe that decision. There's your answer Curly. The director of umpires was watching a race. When you compare that non fifty to the one against Kosi and the one that Gaff got in the last couple of minutes when nobody went ...

Silvagni?

Two minutes in Hayes takes a mark fifty five out Selwood comes in and retards him. Umpire gives nothing. Well Plugger66 why? Dont know. was watching a race. Anyway the umpiring has been good apart from maybe that decision. There's your answer Curly. The director of umpires was watching a race. When...