We can not survive if we were to go solo Have you done the figures on these? What's the basis for this statement? This doesn't mean however he doesn't give the saints players a fair go. the players all love him both at the saints and casey. If I was a senior listed St Kilda player and Banfield wasn...

st.mart wrote:Will finish Top 4 in the B&F for the 3rd consecutive year

True, but on the basis of our season this year, he won't have much to beat to finish Top 4.

n1ck wrote:Laws, rules and regulations are what MAKE us a civil society.

n1ck surely you can't be intimating that Saintsational is civil ?!?!?!?!

GT on SEN now. Just said that were he still in charge, he'd have told Harvey that it was time to quit as the club had to move on. to bad youre not in charge then grant...iv never really being pro or anti GT iv just sat back and watched the arguments but this pisses me off - "the club needs to ...

I wish some people would have a logical think about this scenario....... We have just had a 60 - 80 goals a year player retire who is going to be hard to replace. Does anybody realistically think Watts or Kosi can cover Gehrig's loss? I mean seriously......? Watts would be lucky to play more than 12...

Umm yeah anyway back on topic......... Awesome defence, midfield and forward line. Will be pretty hard to exploit their weaknesses.... Deserve to win the flag - I might have bagged them in previous years for my own reasons, but from a footballing point of view I reckon they're miles ahead of Essendo...

My source says that all will not be rosie for him when the case involving him, bikies, strip clubs and shooting at things goes to court Are you referring to jail time? I don't think they would have any problem moving him on if that's the case. Someone else picking him up would be a problem though!

18 of the 22 played finals.

Pavlich, Johnson and J. Brown had better seasons than Roo......

Dustin Fletcher is the only contentious one imo......

I reckon McIntosh and Foley were stiff. FWIW I would have had Sammy Fisher in first if we had any Saints players.

Seriously what would people like more around here......... ?

For individuals at the St Kilda Football Club to keep accumulating meaningless awards such as All Australian Selection?

OR.......

A premiership?


Who gives a rats arse about AA selection!!!!!!

stinger wrote:just goes to show what a crap year we have had.....imhfo....

Ding Ding Ding!

We have a winner!

*cough cough Collingwood Preliminary Finalist no nominees cough cough*

And you think we get dudded.........

Seriously............ its a BS award.

Ask Banger what he'd rather have.......... a Premiership medallion or umpteen All Australian gigs.....

Got a feeling I know what he'd say

Brooks achieved more in one game against Brisbane than what Rix has done in his 28 games. He actually had a positive impact on the team. Rix is praised if he isn't completely slaughtered in the ruck and gets a couple of handballs. He doesn't contribute, he just tries not to be a liability. Again wi...

Munga wrote:SA news say Cornes brothers, Lade, McLeod, and ALL nine cats!

Agree with all except Lade........

Saint Corin wrote:Top 10 in VFL goal kicking 2 years in a row I think.

.........does not necessarily mean anything.

If you judge Sweeney as a fair player based on that, what does that make Nick Sautner?

Wouldn't it have been easier to just name the kid "Chris"? Has anyone here named their son "Harvey"? I will be when the missus is ready :D Have repeatedly told her she won't have a choice! On the Judd issue, he's got every right to decide where he wants to go. Football is a pret...

in...........

Are you worried that the facts will get in the way? Are you on the board? Ive been round here longer than you... Agreed teflon, and FWIW I've shut my mouth long enough on this topic. So I'll have my say...... I havent bothered reading most of the posts as everyone has had their own agendae on the l...

As much as some of us are aggrieved at the Baker (non) incident...... Are we now going to have to have every incident scrutinised by posters? Nothing we can do about Baker (and no it's not a case of me just rolling over here) And no point worrying about things we can't control such as MRP decisions....

Armoooo wrote:the AFL believed that Amon Buchanon only deserved one week off for his identical bump on the first year Irish import Martin Clark

Kind of incorrect........... 3 weeks originally - 1 week with the early plea - and I would have taken it too!

Yes, St Luke, it's that simple. If Collingwood win & we win we play finals. After countless posts upon posts upon posts about mathematics..... well done snoopygirl! I don't care who we play - WHEN we beat Richmond and WHEN Adelaide get done by Collingwood.... we are good enough to beat anyone i...

Gee, I remember about 18 months ago, confidential documents belonging to an AFL club were found spilling out of a skip bin by several people from this site at a social game. Club involved didn't seem too concerned about privacy of their players then. Careful don't name the Club..................! S...

Thanks for that.

So the documents were "said to have been found outside a drug rehabilitation clinic in Ivanhoe."

Are they sure the documents weren't found inside a mini-skip outside Glenferrie?

TimeToShineFellas wrote:For a VFL/AFL game - Ed James for Geelong 5.16 against........ yes us in 1899

Plus we also hold the dubious honour of being on the receiving end for the most accurate individual scoring effort.....

Fred Fanning of Melbourne with 18.1 in 1947.

At least we excel at something!

He kicked 2 goals 11 behinds... Is that a record???????????? I believe the record is Dave McNamara (again) who kicked 18.16 in a match for Essendon 'A' versus Melbourne City in 1912. For a VFL/AFL game - Ed James for Geelong 5.16 against........ yes us in 1899! *taken from the 3AW Book of Footy Rec...