OK - so Scneids was one of the SOBER ones - and they reckoned the girl was the real one *pissed*. How reliable is her evidence? don't start that s***. you're building up to say that she asked for it, right? doesn't sound like it to me - if she asked for it then i don't think she would have been cry...

I thought the funny thing to come out of the case was the fact that Rooey said this in his statement. Nick Riewoldt was in bed asleep when he received a "frantic" call from Fisher about 2.30am saying police were at the apartment. "I turned my phone off thinking they were joking,"...

I thought that they was about 10 'Baker' like incidents againt Roo all game. Just proves the MRP is sh**t

5 Hayes
4 Schneids
3 Jones
2 Goddard
1 Milney

The first two were miles in front of everyone else.

Classy response thinline! :roll: Try READING THE POST SLOWLY AND TRY TO DIGEST WHAT I WAS SAYING I'm NOT asking people to give up on them ...simply saying that history and current form point toward another blank season, enjoy going to the game and dont get disappointed at the inevitable outcome! I'...

We are not going anywhere with the ultra defensive tripe we served up tonight. All it takes is the opposition to jump us with five or six quick goals and our gameplan is a massive FAIL. Scoreboard pressure is not our forte and we've got to do something about it if we are to have any chance in Septe...

How about the players wear screw in boots.

I have hear a lot of commentary from recently retired players in the last week saying that it is the cleat boots as much as the surface but current players refuse to wear anything else.

I don't think he really played on anyone in particular.

On Rioli at times Hodge at times on no one at times.

He just sort of played as an onballer.

aye we are 4 full points behind the pies. first place is a key because its a passage to the 3rd round of the finals. The dogs or freo are a weak link atm in final 4. That said if the saints drop more and the hawks keep rising, they'll seriously put the cats to fright. could have beaten the cats and...

It hasn't worried us the last two years when we pants them on the G in finals.

I think that at the end of Bakes' carer he should look at a case for discrimination in the workplace. In court you can site other things where people weren't charged and where people were. If he showed all the incidents where he has copped weeks and then show incidents that have been let go he would...

Do you really need to see them to comment? You had Sam Fisher condemned without seeing the incident. I am f****ing sick of people commenting on what I said and getting it wrong. I declared I did not see it and I said that in my opinion if someone is with a trainer and another player makes contact h...

I have done a quick mini ladder of the top5 playing against each other and it makes for interesting reading. It looks good for us P W L F A % 1. St Kilda 5 5 0 381 293 130 2.Collingwood 5 3 2 466 448 104 3.Geelong 3 1 2 250 245 102 4.Fremantle 4 1 3 382 444 86 5.Bulldogs 3 0 3 242 291 83 We are clea...

Do you really need to see them to comment? You had Sam Fisher condemned without seeing the incident. I am f****ing sick of people commenting on what I said and getting it wrong. I declared I did not see it and I said that in my opinion if someone is with a trainer and another player makes contact h...

Is there anywhere I can actually see the vision of each incident that both Baker and Johnson have been reported for?

5- Scneids
4-Gwilt
3-Micky G
2-Lenny
1-Steven

[quote="saint vince] Fisher is a bit different as Bartel was coming off and in the hands of the trainers. I aven't seen it but I rekon any contact in that situation deserves a week. IMO[/quote] If you go back to my original statement and not distort it I said any contact in that situation deser...

I said I haven't see that incident but IMO if you make contact with someone who is coming off the ground with trainers and is clearly injured you should be cited and recieve at least one week. I am sorry for having an opinion on something in a general sense and not exactly see what happened. I didn...

I aven't seen it but I rekon any contact in that situation deserves a week. IMO Do you post on BigFooty? You should. I didn't see it but he should get a week is pretty standard fare over there. I said I haven't see that incident but IMO if you make contact with someone who is coming off the ground ...

I personally didn't like Baker hitting Johnsons hand, and I didn't like Fisher attempting to bump Bartel while going off in the hands of the trainers. I agree I hated seeing what Brisbane did to Roo and knowing his hand was injured Bakes probably pushed the buttons a bit too far. Missed the other t...

I see no problem with the punch on Stevie J hand as I saw no problem with the Birsbane attack on Rooey once he ran away from the trainers. If you are on the ground you are there to play. If you are injured go off. However the feeling of the last four weeks has seen everything go against the tagger a...

I have a reserved seat at Etihad and the lady who sits behind me and is a reserved seat member of the saints is a mad Geelong supporter but her and her best friend go to St.Kilda and Geelong games.

Maybe just maybe he is a member.

rodgerfox wrote:Arguably the difference was that Geelong's 'top 6' didn't perform.

I am pretty sure this is what the OP is saying. Our top 6 performed theirs didn't and we won. I think you actually are agreeing with something.

That is is combined tally in second halfs kicked against us so far this year from the other 3 big 'contenders'

Geelong 0
Collingwood 0
Dogs 3


Standing up when it really counts.


Go saints

The last thing the AFL and surely people want is conferences. Surely that makes the draw even more unequal. It will hopefully stay as it is and we play another 2 games to make 24. Of course the draw isnt equal but unless we have 34 games it cant be equal. It isnt equal even with 17 games. Keep as i...